Received my Clean DD3285 Batgirl yesterday. I’m a bit underwhelmed to be honest, here are my thoughts.
(I’m a recent new-comer to the rep world, having ‘only’ owned a gen 3570.50 Speedy for the past decade. I picked up a VSF 126610LN and VSF 122334/Jubilee and have had those for a few months. Obsessively been reading here, as one does, as well as RepTime/QC/Services to get as much info as possible.)
In comparison to the VSF reps, and the Sub Date in particular, the overall general finish of the 126710 is fairly nice.
In the hand, the CF Jubilee Y8C bracelet isn’t as refined feeling as the VSF. The click when fastening isn’t as confidence inspiring. Perhaps an oil bath is in order but I can see why they’ve updated this recently.
The bezel action is ‘just okay’, with quite a bit of backlash in the indexing. It does click to the next index positively enough to align with the number. Oddly, if you move it slowly it doesn’t align well, whereas if you move it quickly it indexes/aligns better. The 12 o’clock position probably has the most play and needs to be tweaked for proper alignment. I noticed a far superior design on here recently and hopefully CF (or ideally VSF in the future?) used this multi-ball design instead. I’ve never handled the gen version so my baseless comparison is just that. Mechanically though, I wouldn’t buy a gen version if it were like this.
The movement is my main concern. When unscrewing the crown, it does not spring out to the winding position nicely like the 3235s do. It makes you wonder if you’re even in the winding position. While winding it, it’s quite stiff and has a ratcheting clicks, unlike the 3235. The crown position movement between winding/hour adjust/hack+time adjust settings is stiff and not easily discernible.
The hour/date adjust is positive with no minute hand movement whatsoever, likely the best experience with this movement. The date changes with positive clicks to the next date and the DW itself is fairly good, though it has a bolder font than the VSFs. The “12” has a floating ‘2’. Again trying to change between crown positions is not ideal.
I use the ‘inward pressure/counterclockwise’ technique for screwing the crown back in. The crown tube threads feel chewy and the lack of finishing attention here is noticeable. Again, not smooth.
Overall, it still looks great on the wrist and the GMT complication is a nice addition. If my VSF Sub were a 9/10 (it’s seriously an awesome rep), my DJ41 a 8/10 [Rolex logo misaligned, lug shape, etc.], I’d rate this DD3285 CF 126710 a 6/10. That’s disappointing considering the price point.
This one will be off to Dogwood for a full service and hopefully that addresses the bezel and movement concerns. Thanks for reading.