Paypal is not the greatest. I can see why as a seller why he won't take it. I know horror stories of sellers who sold a legit watch and a month and sometimes two months would go by and the customer would put a claim on you. Also the empty box thing is used sometime when stuff is sent. That is why Scottb57 is correct. I would video the box and open it on video. Paypal is great for the buyer. Not so great for the seller. Like I said. I would never take a paypal payment unless its a gift. Its a catch 22 here on this forum. I rarely pay with paypal as a sell unless I don't know the guy or he has no sales. I would and have paid Rudy by gift. I would have never seen this.
The system broke down here. We had forum members that are well known, know that he was not being legit. They should have spoken up. At least let the Mods know what is going on. Then we had him rushing people, which is a classic sign of fraud. I will not be rushed into buying a watch from anyone. If I am spending a large amount of $ on a watch I would take my time. Look at pictures. I also would insist he put it in an for sale post.
So all the things that are made to protect us as a buyer were bypassed here. That is bad form for him to take. If and when he returns, he has a lot of explaining to do to his buyer the Admin.
I have become friends with a bunch of people here. I have been texted asked if I wanted to buy something. I have brought things not on this site. I am responsible for it. I have been burned. I have been sold crap here. I brought watches on sales threads that were not anything what they said that they would be. The word Gen here is useless. I have got watches that didn't work out of the box I have got watches where the seller had no idea what they had. I've got parts that were "TC" that were not even close to it. I don't leave them feedback and let them know. Maybe they were sold that by someone who said that it was what they say it is. If that makes any sense.
I don't expect a Rolex when I buy here. I expect a watch that I can upgrade or part out to make something. That is just me.