1. What is the ultimate opinion ? Success ?
2. What colors look the best ?
Just buy it if you like it. No perpetual calendar will ever be repped well, let alone one that's under 10mm.
I already provided all the photos and videos I could. It's up to you to evaluate.
And if you mean, which color looks most like to gen, none of them do, maybe black and grey, that's about it.
Just treat the watch like a toy/homage. It's a very good looking watch that's 70% of the way there and achieves some of the looks of a perpetual calendar.
Imho it's already miles better than the APSF which has the biggest tell of a seconds hand instead of a weeks hand.
The function for me, is not important, I would take stability over anything else. The week hand, month hand being manual is no issue, you only need to set it 12 times a year and at the end of each week. I have a collection so I have to set a watch everytime I wear it anyways.