• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

What AP Franken(s) do you have in the works?!

jptrosch

Active Member
Patron
Certified
9/10/18
413
405
63
Well said - it carries a lot of weight coming from you. For anyone following this thread that's thinking about building a franken, I would highly recommend it. It will never be perfect, and that quest for perfection is its own kind of torture. At the same time, it's immensely awarding and a great way to figure out what kind of watch best expresses who you are. I've abandoned several builds at various points in the process searching for the one that felt right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: legend

Revolper

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
7/7/18
1,695
1,382
113
Guys I get that you are very happy with the result (it’s great) but a watch as the extension of its owner? To express who you are? That’s taking it a little too far I think.

Again, great watch. I have a feeling I will get downvoted for this =]
 

Champsy

Active Member
15/4/18
265
323
63
UK
Guys I get that you are very happy with the result (it’s great) but a watch as the extension of its owner? To express who you are? That’s taking it a little too far I think.

Again, great watch. I have a feeling I will get downvoted for this =]

I actually think that is quite true for a lot of owners.

What watch someone is wearing can say quite a bit about the owner.

AP owners they obviously have style:) haha
Patek style and class:) Panerai, IWC, jlc etc etc all want to be different and then you have the Rolex owners.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Revolper

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
7/7/18
1,695
1,382
113
I actually think that is quite true for a lot of owners.

What watch someone is wearing can say quite a bit about the owner.

AP owners they obviously have style:) haha
Patek style and class:) Panerai, IWC, jlc etc etc all want to be different and then you have the Rolex owners.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I am of course aware of that watches do tell something about their owner. I was aiming at the actual phrasing.
 

slaughterer62

Mythical Poster
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
27/1/13
9,280
1,892
113
Congratulations jptrosch on that genstein. It is a fine assembly of parts. I regret missing all the stages of this build. I did not see your preliminary thread on the previous hands you were contemplating using until recently. I am not sure the genuine parts that are still missing would be significant additions, except for maybe a genuine bezel, rhodium plated screws, and a genuine gold rotor. The gen bezel has a slightly different geometry, better metal stock, and polishes up a little different--and the gen bezel accepts the JF crystal (albeit tightly) and the JF screws (albeit tightly again). I do not know what your attitude towards the bracelet is, but I would actually advise against adding a gen bracelet, as I think the differences between it and the rep one is not worth the premium (I can document this if needed). If I were to make a polite suggestion, however, you might want to professionally rebrush some of the scratches from the caseback and do some work on the screws before sending them out for rhodium plating (Flying Tommy has done excellent rhodium screw plating for many people, including me). As for the hands, I do not know if it is the lighting, but they also look like they would use a good cleaning as well. The impossible game at this point would seem to be for the owner of this watch to achieve the finish of a factory fresh watch with parts that were probably removed, stored, shipped, and accumulated little injuries along the way. I know this is a very difficult game, and maybe really not worth it, as all modders must unfortunately use different equipment than APSC, and results may very well vary, with the prospect of the original AP finishing slowly receding under the impact of later refinishing not really being that attractive.
As far as a watch's relation to self, I have often wondered about that, especially in relation to the way women are bonded to their jewelry. With many men a watch is probably the only significant jewelry they can wear, except maybe their wedding band and maybe a few bracelets for the stackers, and I do think there is a significant emotional relation between men and their watches. But I think that emotional relation varies quite alot with different people, and part of the fun is finding out what story each individual owner can tell about their watch. A. is right that the boutique pampering etc. can be a nice way to start that story, and boutique experiences, when they are positive (they are not always positive for everybody though), are a significant part of the story many people have about their watch (the day I went to Bucherer, or the AP Boutique on 57th St...), whereas for most of the Franken builders here, the origin story is often about the difficulty and frustration of getting this or that rare part, the impatience of waiting for the watch to be finished, the disappointment of a hand falling off, etc all somewhat painful things I know, certainly by comparison to "Then, they gave me a glass of Champagne and pulled a tourbillon from their safe for me to try on" I am sure however these negative aspects will fade with time, and the watch will become more and more a source of joy for you, as the story proceeds beyond the initial stages. Although I have seen many people grow bored or tired with their Gensteins, certain people hold on to them for life with a particular source of pride in having "built it themselves" rather than buy it from the slick retail outlet of a sometimes very over-priced industrial luxury company.
 
Last edited:

jptrosch

Active Member
Patron
Certified
9/10/18
413
405
63
Guys I get that you are very happy with the result (it’s great) but a watch as the extension of its owner? To express who you are? That’s taking it a little too far I think.

Again, great watch. I have a feeling I will get downvoted for this =]

I agree. It is pretty ridiculous. People seem to have a strange connection to their watches, even though they're just inanimate things. The Hodinkee Talking Watches with John Meyer where he talks about being on tour and his watch being the only other thing in his hotel room with a beating heart captures it pretty well. It's a bit sappy, for sure.

In my case, I would say things I put together or build myself say something about me. I used to build guitars before I got into watches, and I like to think the design and construction of the guitars reflects my personality.
 
Last edited:

jptrosch

Active Member
Patron
Certified
9/10/18
413
405
63
Nice one buddy, enjoy it. But it seems like you have the caseback upside down, don’t you? ????

I think you're right... I'll take it off when I rhodium plate the screws and realign it. Thank you for catching that.
 

jptrosch

Active Member
Patron
Certified
9/10/18
413
405
63
Congratulations jptrosch on that genstein. It is a fine assembly of parts. I regret missing all the stages of this build. I did not see your preliminary thread on the previous hands you were contemplating using until recently. I am not sure the genuine parts that are still missing would be significant additions, except for maybe a genuine bezel, rhodium plated screws, and a genuine gold rotor. The gen bezel has a slightly different geometry, better metal stock, and polishes up a little different--and the gen bezel accepts the JF crystal (albeit tightly) and the JF screws (albeit tightly again). I do not know what your attitude towards the bracelet is, but I would actually advise against adding a gen bracelet, as I think the differences between it and the rep one is not worth the premium (I can document this if needed). If I were to make a polite suggestion, however, you might want to professionally rebrush some of the scratches from the caseback and do some work on the screws before sending them out for rhodium plating (Flying Tommy has done excellent rhodium screw plating for many people, including me). As for the hands, I do not know if it is the lighting, but they also look like they would use a good cleaning as well. The impossible game at this point would seem to be for the owner of this watch to achieve the finish of a factory fresh watch with parts that were probably removed, stored, shipped, and accumulated little injuries along the way. I know this is a very difficult game, and maybe really not worth it, as all modders must unfortunately use different equipment than APSC, and results may very well vary, with the prospect of the original AP finishing slowly receding under the impact of later refinishing not really being that attractive.

I appreciate your suggestion, and I'm going to listen to it. It's not the lighting - my watchmaker is skilled when it comes to modifications but he is anything but delicate when it comes to handling parts. I would like to have the watch professionally cleaned, but I'm both unsure who to send it to and uneasy about sending it anywhere. My watchmaker worked only 17 minutes north of me.
 

QueTip

Super Duper Galactic NutSwinging BootyGrabbin Mod
Staff member
Global Moderator
Certified
3/6/14
14,640
6,047
113
Guys I get that you are very happy with the result (it’s great) but a watch as the extension of its owner? To express who you are? That’s taking it a little too far I think.

Again, great watch. I have a feeling I will get downvoted for this =]

While this may not be the case for the average Rolex wearer, it certainly is true for many AP wearers and wearers of other brands. Don't you know the saying 'the clothes make the man'? Same goes for a watch. It expresses your taste, style and attitude in a certain way. Maybe not everyone sees it that way but I certainly do fully agree with that as well and so do many others that I know.
 

srhoque

Respected Member
28/11/18
3,259
2,467
113
Following jptrosch build, its amazing. Definitely up a notch compared to the other 15400 frankens mainly with gen dials. Jewelry with women supplements their looks/beauty and in some cases elevates them as well. While the watch is probably an important part of a man's attire, it by no means is the most significant and a man can definitely do without it. My only emotional attachment is to my ring and bracelet (because they connect me back to my family and belief system). A watch is definitely not the extension of a man (not for me), I look totally myself and as savvy in a Apple watch as I do in my gen Rolex. I am sure its me but I don't get these "extreme" AP builds. I know this is a very subjective question (and I am sure I tickled a few nerves here) but this 15400 got me thinking. Peace and stay healthy folks!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: jptrosch

slaughterer62

Mythical Poster
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
27/1/13
9,280
1,892
113
While this may not be the case for the average Rolex wearer, it certainly is true for many AP wearers and wearers of other brands. Don't you know the saying 'the clothes make the man'? Same goes for a watch. It expresses your taste, style and attitude in a certain way. Maybe not everyone sees it that way but I certainly do fully agree with that as well and so do many others that I know.

This "extension of the self" metaphor has been around since the 1960s at least. Check out the subtitle of McLuhan's book "Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man." Before it was TV and radio and audio and visual recordings. Nowadays, I think the average person sees their mobile phone and social networking as an extension of their self. Then there is fashion, like QueTip says, and also autos, houses, furniture, etc.... and then the ever more popular world of vintage watches. So many extensions... it is almost as if the self underneath does not matter.
 

Revolper

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
7/7/18
1,695
1,382
113
While this may not be the case for the average Rolex wearer, it certainly is true for many AP wearers and wearers of other brands. Don't you know the saying 'the clothes make the man'? Same goes for a watch. It expresses your taste, style and attitude in a certain way. Maybe not everyone sees it that way but I certainly do fully agree with that as well and so do many others that I know.

You pretty much summed it up. A watch/clothing can express but shouldn’t define who you are.

edit: I see what was wrong with my initial posting now lol.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jptrosch and QueTip

flying-tommy

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
21/8/12
1,438
2,546
113
So guys. I will show you my Watch extensions now. ;)


I don't think quarantine is good for me.

The third Franken project is also set.

591390820113a86886403dd6928405bf.jpg


Summer is coming fast. Will build with a completely new Set of Gen Hands.


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
 

legend

The RWI Dragon
Staff member
✮✮ Lifetime Patron ✮✮
Global Moderator
Certified
20/9/10
64,149
82,027
113
Where I need to be.
You pretty much summed it up. A watch/clothing can express but shouldn’t define who you are.

edit: I see what was wrong with my initial posting now lol.

I think each of us places our own value and definition on what our watch is (or isn't about), so nothing wrong with what you said.
My point is that what we like to do and wear and own forms an inseparable part of whom we are.. but the weight and significance of such preferences is defined solely by us.
I agree that a watch does not define who are are, but it tells the world what we like, and our preferences are a part of who we are.
 

flying-tommy

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
21/8/12
1,438
2,546
113
Hello friends of Franken,

as I have more and more requests and offers concerning the Franken projects I would like to clarify a few things and facts.

This is more information for new users and not for the old Hares.

First of all I would like to take away the illusion that I build the Franken and then sell them cheap (or very cheap after the offer).

I build, or let build, the watches out of pure passion for the projects and to create something new. A building in thoughts of a sale would never rake itself, with all love and devotion, also considering how much time one invests in each project to look for parts, find contacts and always hope that everything goes well.

I set a high value on new parts, or absolutely new condition, under which I would not start a project.

Since it is no secret, what a good Franken construction can cost, I would like to give an example here, to give the newer interested users an overview.

Since there have been some requests for this, it makes more sense to show it in general.

I am aware that you can also make a Franken cheaper by using used or inferior parts. Revolper said very appropriately in a recent post: you get what you pay for.

What I can't understand is that some
want to negotiate constantly with the few modders about the prices for their work.

I usually like to negotiate, but with this work and knowledge, we should be glad that there are a few who have done a lot of research and experimentation to make our wishes come true.

I'm glad that there are people like Domi, Slaughterer, Legend, Mikey.... Without them I would have stopped my hobby already and we should appreciate the work accordingly.

But now finally to the facts:

My example is for the Volcano project, as these were the last parts I bought and all prices are still present.

Let's start with the gen dial and tachy. Here there are of course many price differences and different sources.

In my opinion, for a new flawless set you have to calculate around 1.300-1.600 €, depending on how popular the model is.
In my case I paid 1.500 € for the set.

For the Gen hands it gets more difficult. Unfortunately there are far too few offers and therefore the prices are often too expensive compared to the Dial/Tachy. Fortunately there are alternatives from Mikey, but for some projects I just want to have the Gen Hands, because it can make a big difference (Lume Volcano).

The new Hand sets are between 800 and 1.400 €.

In my case I paid 1.250 € for new Volcano Hands.

I also don't want to give an evaluation if the parts are worth their price or if they are overpriced. It is a sober view of the current market prices.

You still need a LWO automatic movement, because you can't use the replica movement.

These are used between 400 and 800 €, depending on condition and offer. I get my movements from Switzerland, they are new and do not need any service, the price is 650 €.

Now there are some smaller parts, which fortunately are not that expensive. Lol

I use 1 x AR coated glasses from Domi, which are very thick and come closest to the Gen glasses. Price per piece is 120 €. Of course you can also use rnrprof glass, or Rep glass as you like.

Further we need a datewheel , here you can find solutions from Mikey, Legend and Omega. Price per piece is about 85 €.

I use a Gen deployment clasp for the Volcano, which I bought for 450 €.

Maybe I will add a Gen Hornback to it.

As last material I add the Base Watch, in my case a new JF 42mm for 500 €.

The last point, but for me the most important is of course the work to make a finished project out of all parts.

There are many factors involved and I can't give you a general price, because the price can vary depending on the amount of work and complications. Do Hands have to be re-lume, do parts have to be adjusted?

Are parts Gen used, or mixtures of Mikey, Rep and Gen?

There are many factors that determine the effort required.
In my case it is 1.250 €.

For all parts are no shipping costs listed, please do not forget this point, especially in Germany this can be a bigger item with triangle shipping and customs fees. Here I am at about 350 €.

So now we have a pretty big number standing here. 6.155 € for all of them, if all goes well. Of course it can always happen that parts get broken or damaged during the assembly. Please take these costs on your head and don't try to get them from the modder. It is a big risk to build a watch and something can always happen.

I don't want to start a discussion whether someone paid only 500 € for a Hands set or got part X cheaper.

These are my values from the experience of the last 10-15 Franke projects and should be a rough guide.

I'm sorry if I annoyed you with my long execution, but for some it was hopefully helpful to make certain cost estimates and when bids are made.

Best
Thomas


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

slaughterer62

Mythical Poster
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
27/1/13
9,280
1,892
113
If I could "like" that previous post by FlyingTommy a thousand times, I would. It made my day! It lays out a realistic cost breakdown for current AP Franken projects and the current market prices for nearly every component of it. If you add even more genuine components, please calculate even higher: current market price for a set of gen pushers is about $700, gen crown about $500, gen plots about $250, gen bezel about $1000-1200, gen bezel screw sets about $600-800. As the list goes on, the costs go on. And the more gen parts you want installed in your Franken, the more work it is for your builder. To take an example, just installing a gen pusher housing requires significant preparation and cost for a modder, with hours spent looking for a fresh tapping set (Gewindeschneider/bohrer) for your gen pusher housing because, as I learned last night, every single vendor in the Western world does not have a single one in stock, and you have to look deep into the dark regions of the net for 3 pieces finally, bought at 2am last night. In any case, bravo Flying-Tommy, as this cost breakdown gives a quick, easy-to-understand and FAQ-worthy answer to the most asked question I get: how much does it cost? Maybe I should do the same for the price of the equipment required to machine and finish these watches properly, as the 30 or so invoices from my recent cap ex investment in machines and tools of the last two weeks are lying in front of me right now, but that would be too depressing for me: I spent alot more than I wanted!
 
Last edited:

slaughterer62

Mythical Poster
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
27/1/13
9,280
1,892
113
Anybody in contact with member Swissbeat? I have been messaging him for weeks as I completed his Blue Themes Franken, but he has not logged on in here for more than a month. Hope he is ok. If anybody can contact him to tell him his watch is finished, please do. I only have his RWI moniker.

 

Raphyalex

Getting To Know The Place
4/4/20
16
3
0
Hi everyone, this one of mine AP Offshore Rose Gold & Carbon '' QE II Cup 2016 '' 44mm.