Wow this is a great thread! I didn't know RWI is a "All things that will kill you or make you broke" forum!! I recently quit drinking (new year's resolution) and so far it's going well. Before that, though, I used to survive on scotch like water.
It's great because everyone has different tastes and preferences. Here are my top 3 personal favorites (with a reasonable price) in reverse order:
3. Macallan 18 - Speyside - $99
(Special Bonus Runner-up: Macallan 10 Cask Strength. This is now discontinued, cost about $75 at the time, and man was it strong DELICIOUS. If you find a bottle, buy it immediately.
2. Glenmorangie 18 - Highland - $99
1. Oban 14 - West Highland - $50 at COSTCO!!
I'm more smooth/sophisticated Highland/Speyside guy. I definitely like to change it up and experience the variety of scotch, but I can't do the Islay scotch as daily drinkers: Ardbeg, Lagavulin, Laphroaig. Can't handle too much of those smoky peat monsters!
But yea, Oban is my favorite and my daily go-to. The best part was the price, you can find it at costco for around $50. Taste like $200. I had a blind scotch tasting a while back with some of my friends including JW Blue, Mac 15, different Glens 15s, and guess what I chose.
Also, for those who like to gamble in Vegas, i was able to get the cocktail waitress to get me Mac 12 while playing at the tables at Cosmopolitan. I also played for a few min in the high limit room one time and had a glass of Mac 25! I pretty much felt like a winner at that point and quickly left. :thumbup: