• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

New Black Hole Crystals are available!

Rx4Time

Supporter, Panerai lover
Patron
Certified
31/3/16
11,781
10,027
113
CONUS
I want options, and the information to make an informed decision. How's the AR look, fittment, edge finish, and personally, I'm curious how well they would perform under pressure testing to enable waterproofing, but I know I'm an outlier on that one.
 

Jeane123

Respected Member
6/4/15
4,069
17
0
I was being sarcastic...

Wow you are all piss and vinegar today aren’t you? I think what jack is trying to say is that he believes in the quality as he is one of the few people who has had both crystals currently available (prof and cc) in hand and on his watches. I am also one of the lucky ones to have been able to get my hands on a xtal for the ap diver as well as the cyclops and IMO it’s amazing. See the daily AP thread. I personally own xtals from guru, prof and cc and yes each of them has their own qualities and characteristics and for my diver the cc looks amazing.

I think without having one in your hands you can’t really say good or bad or voice your opinion as strongly as you have done here.

Given your experience in the field you should know that xtals with AR, without AR, or any of them will show some reflective properties and it all depends on angle, lighting and photographic skills when represented in a photo.

I for one am excited to see more choices in this arena and looking forward to getting my next cc xtal! What would you suggest? AP? NSD? Or maybe a Tudor? Those look pretty decent in blue right?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Rx4Time

Supporter, Panerai lover
Patron
Certified
31/3/16
11,781
10,027
113
CONUS
Didn't @2fake4u just sell a blue Pelagos with a 2AR from Prof? I briefly had one and the 2AR is beautiful on the Pelagos.
 

JackJ1980

Mythical Poster
20/6/16
6,280
350
0
Didn't @2fake4u just sell a blue Pelagos with a 2AR from Prof? I briefly had one and the 2AR is beautiful on the Pelagos.
Agreed. I love the crystal cleAR's I've purchased but I've always loved Profs. I've purchased dozens over the year. He was the pioneer and he's great to work with and has a killer AR
 

eazye

I'm Pretty Popular
9/1/13
1,334
261
83
Prof 2AR

ac12749a75bf83f1f7a43a21adaab237.jpg


Crystal CleAR

9f914acbc75a7a062caffee1735e6ed8.jpg


1c9bc67b1e87768d334e7d68fdc93bb6.jpg


Gen

192656ad4ee1c61aa6ab0846880bc74d.jpg


Fun

ae5e1971d7c6be2baf17d3d5b2ede7ac.jpg


baddf30a3026cad906876e91529da217.jpg


WGADF??!?!

Can we talk about something else now? [emoji3]

I'll post a Prof Black Hole tomorrow if you really want to see one [emoji3]
 

Soldier2304

I'm Pretty Popular
10/3/17
1,721
42
48
@Asmodeus not sure why you are criticizing a promising product when instead, you should be focused on showing us better results of your own.
 

Art Tic

Time Machine Collector
26/2/17
948
237
43
California
Competition is good. I hope the AR crystals are cheap enough that I can afford to install them on all of my weekly rotation watches!

Sent from my SM-P900 using Tapatalk
 

Norrie

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
24/5/12
2,063
64
48
I feel like I’ve just subliminally listened to a James Bond soundtrack. It’s tracking 9 and i’m not sure why but I feel anxious.
 

Maron

Mythical Poster
16/2/15
9,469
807
113
Canada
Based on the pictures I've seen so far I think the CC looks good without a cyclops, but the CC with cyclops looks poor. The blackhole effect looks poor and the date magnification looks too weak.

I think the prof blackhole looks far superior to the CC, and much closer to the rolex crystal.

I think the blackhole crystal that occb2 reviewed was also syperior to the CC crystal and similar to the prof and genuine.

I look forward to seeing a review of all four together.

Sent from the RWI App
 

ssouthall6

Respected Member
10/10/13
3,539
1,563
113
Based on the pictures I've seen so far I think the CC looks good without a cyclops, but the CC with cyclops looks poor. The blackhole effect looks poor and the date magnification looks too weak.

I think the prof blackhole looks far superior to the CC, and much closer to the rolex crystal.

I think the blackhole crystal that occb2 reviewed was also syperior to the CC crystal and similar to the prof and genuine.

I look forward to seeing a review of all four together.

Sent from the RWI App

Completely agree from the pictures that have been posted


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

2fake4u

Respected Member
20/9/16
3,037
476
83
Let's just say I'd personally like to see an unbiased set of pictures, same watch, same lighting conditions, different crystals. Post them and put up a poll, gen cc, assmodius's. See what the members think. No reason to argue about it, let the products showcase themselves. I'm not capable of a safe crystal swap, so I cannot volunteer to do the comparison so perhaps another neutral party could? Just my thoughts on this.
I just bumped my prof and cc comparison pics thread
 

2fake4u

Respected Member
20/9/16
3,037
476
83
In all honesty, this thread has turned into one guy whos tryimg to make the perfect rep sub c xtal, and is adamantly saying everyome elses is crap, while this other company isnt even on the boards or in the rep game. They aren't trying to make the perfect 295c-c12 xtal, they are just making affordable aftermarket xtals with AR.
 

Asmodeus

I'm Pretty Popular
17/4/15
1,052
266
83
In all honesty, this thread has turned into one guy whos tryimg to make the perfect rep sub c xtal, and is adamantly saying everyome elses is crap, while this other company isnt even on the boards or in the rep game. They aren't trying to make the perfect 295c-c12 xtal, they are just making affordable aftermarket xtals with AR.

Nope you are wrong, I never said everyone else is crap. Actually I said exaclty the opposite, prof AR is great, however not the proper one for watch applications as he sacrifices durability for clarity.
 

2fake4u

Respected Member
20/9/16
3,037
476
83
Nope you are wrong, I never said everyone else is crap. Actually I said exaclty the opposite, prof AR is great, however not the proper one for watch applications as he sacrifices durability for clarity.
I've had both and honestly, there is no difference. The cyclops has a green hue one one and blue on the other. And the double ar xtals are both very clear.

I got an email saying the blue hue cyclops are finishing up this week so ill do a review on another batch of flat and cyclops xtals, prof vs CC. If you can get yours done and to me, ill throw it into the mix and some gen rolex xtals as well.

Full reviews and comparisons, once and for all. Let the people decide based on pics, not bs. All this bs from the Asmo xtal, the CC and the Prof doesnt help anyone.

And let's be honest here, there is no secret AR formula. There is no secret AR lab. They all use the same shit. I've been chasing this rabbit for awhile now, mainly because i like to diy and i dont like to pay others to do work, and i can tell you now that there are plenty of labs here in Colorado that do AR for watches.