Long time lurker - Just stumbled upon this. What a great read!
I‘m on the chemical/ galvanic side for blackening the brass. The process is a lot more controllable in larger batches and imho correlates better with the fading of the tropical dials.
There’s a publication ftom the german „copper institute“ on the chemical processes used.
Page 28 has the info on blackening brass. They also show that shorter time spent in the solution leads to brown gradients. It seems logical to me, that with time and deterioration of the surface oxides this would be reversed from black to brown.
In short they use 200g of copper (II) carbonate in 1000ml of 25% ammonia which leads to a (over-) saturated solution.
Soaking time in a cold (and very stinky) solution - depending on room temperature - up to five minutes for a jet black.