• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

DJ 41 - VS F or Clean F?

Ah0rsey

18 hands high, bushy mane.
Patron
Certified
9/8/22
3,581
17,903
113
uk
No I will defo say cf case, vsf smooth bezel, oyster with a mint green dial with a fabulous PROF crystal and waterproof tested of course…..I mean IF you could find one of those, well…..😂😂
 

Kartal06

Getting To Know The Place
28/5/21
20
50
13
EU
For me Clean is better, the bracelet of the vsf doesn't feel like the gen and the case of the watch is so sharpened
 

MapleMarmite

Getting To Know The Place
Certified
5/9/22
32
4
8
Some beautiful watches here!

What's a gen bezel go for these days?
 

Reaps

Learning something new everyday....
Supporter
Certified
25/9/22
6,581
18,027
113
I was asking myself the same question.

My idea is to do two modifications: prof crystal and Xing double platinum coated bezel (https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/new-release-double-platinum-coated-dj41-bezel.10941151/). You haven't talked about the Xing bezel, what do you think?

With those two modifications, I don't know whether to take VSF or CF as a base, it's a complicated decision.
This is my opinion

36 - go VSF, lug and case issue is not super noticeable on smaller watch

41 - go CF for aesthetics. Bonus if you can get a VS3235 swapped in but this has issues with crown tube and stem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mettmett

DrSerhat34

Do not accept unsolicited offers
8/12/23
1
0
1
When I did my research there was very little looks wise between CF & VSF so I went for the better VS3235 movement in the VSF. I also pondered Fluted vs Smooth bezel, Jubilee vs Oyster bracelet and the many different dial colours... I decided I didn't want something that screamed REP or the fact that I was wearing a Rolex, so I went for this one:

VSF DateJust 41mm Smooth / Oyster with the Slate Grey dial... I love it and it's running perfectly, please forgive my crappy photo.
Is there any chance that you might consider to sell this sir?)
 

DQ69

Getting To Know The Place
16/9/23
54
7
8
I just notice that Clean's Jubeli Bracelets has wrong layout in terms of numbers of solid links
 

mettmett

Known Member
10/8/15
176
130
43
GERMANY
Yes it’s a very good replica. Only small issue is the bracelet. Despite being the better ARF unit, it still feels “cheap”. It feels light and hollow and has sharp edges in the midlinks. It’s not a deal breaker but it could have been made better. The oyster bracelets by ARF are very solid and have a higher quality wearing experience. Either way with The VSF or the Clean you get the same bracelet as both factories use it for their DJ reps.

Some say the clean has the more accurate colour dial, especially for the blue DJ and a better executed case ( lug accuracy ). This is very owner subjective and you’ll need to make your choice based on your own preferences. Neither VS or clean are better than the other, they offer different things… pick the ones you want and you’ll be happy. For me it was the crystal and movement and subjectively better blue dial colour - even though it’s less accurate I prefer it.
You are fully right with your statements.
Had all three watches Arf/clean/Vsf in blue. In my opinion the Vsf dial was the closed to the original (except the sunken markers). At the end I changed all dials into originals 😀.
 

mettmett

Known Member
10/8/15
176
130
43
GERMANY


This is my second dj41 (not as heavy frankend as my other one)
Gen dial
Gen smooth bezel
CF case/ crown
Vsf datedisk and hands
Vsf xtal
Vsf bracelet
(Vsf and clean are very good models ootb)
 

Dennis32

Getting To Know The Place
Certified
16/6/23
41
7
8
Germany
@JLK33
Hey my friend
Can you please tell me how you got the VS3235 into the clean case
I am faced with the problem with the crown and the tube
kind regards
 

mettmett

Known Member
10/8/15
176
130
43
GERMANY
@JLK33
Hey my friend
Can you please tell me how you got the VS3235 into the clean case
I am faced with the problem with the crown and the tube
kind regards
You have to remove the clean crown from the VR 3235 stem and attach it to the stem of the VS 3235 movement with some Lock Tight. Perhaps You may have to shorten the tube a little bit. On my second watch, I fitted an original crown with an original tube. However, I had to enlarge the tube hole with a thread cutter because original 605 tube has a bigger thread. The vs crown doesn’t fit onto clean tube. My original crown 605 fittet on clean tube. To remove the crown you can make it hot (there are tutorials)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dennis32

mettmett

Known Member
10/8/15
176
130
43
GERMANY
You have to remove the clean crown from the VR 3235 stem and attach it to the stem of the VS 3235 movement with some Lock Tight. Perhaps You may have to shorten the tube a little bit. On my second watch, I fitted an original crown with an original tube. However, I had to enlarge the tube hole with a thread cutter because original 605 tube has a bigger thread. The vs crown doesn’t fit onto clean tube. My original crown 605 fittet on clean tube. To remove the crown you can make it hot (there are tutorials)
Sorry not shorten tube I meant shorten stem (but don‘t mess it) because if it is to short the game is over 😀
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dennis32

Dennis32

Getting To Know The Place
Certified
16/6/23
41
7
8
Germany
Thanks for the info
If I understood correctly, a Gen crown does not fit on the Clean Tube
But I can build the Clean crown on the vs3235 stem, maybe shorten it a bit and leave the Clean tube as normal?
 

mettmett

Known Member
10/8/15
176
130
43
GERMANY
Thanks for the info
If I understood correctly, a Gen crown does not fit on the Clean Tube
But I can build the Clean crown on the vs3235 stem, maybe shorten it a bit and leave the Clean tube as normal?
Gen 605 crown fitted (but not perfectly) as I wanted to have the perfect feel I installed the gen tube. The clean tube of the watch I replaced the tube was very short. The other one has a little bit longer tube so I can live with clean crown and clean tube. The optical difference isn’t so big, so I left them. And it’s not a must to shorten the stem but Vsf tube is “longer“ than clean so it could be that you have to shorten it. But this depends on the the clean case tube. So don’t worry.