• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs

G

garaged

Known Member
17/4/17
192
9
18
LuminorReptar said:
Just my observation, but isn't BP's bezel the closest to gen-like? I've always found one of the biggest visible flaws with JF's Yacht-Master is the insert doesnt look anything like gen, because the numbers and notches are not "crisp" or refined. The Noob bezel is better imo, but still not that close when you compare with gen.

BP's as far as I can tell seems to be the closest as the numbers and edges are all sharp and crisp... Wondering if anyone else has thoughts on this.. Pics below:

AsUppxu.jpg


O1kgTFA.png
Click to expand...


The problem I have with the Noob and BP is the weird space between the outer edge of the insert and bezel. To me, personally, it's a bigger issue than the softer numerals on the insert with the JF and I can't unsee it. On the RG 116655, my opinions are reversed (because the black insert hides that small gap and the sharper numerals are more noticeable for me there) but on the 116622, I like the JF better just for that reason.
 
Omagad

Omagad

I'm Pretty Popular
10/11/16
1,570
873
113
Super Reps Temple
garaged said:
The problem I have with the Noob and BP is the weird space between the outer edge of the insert and bezel. To me, personally, it's a bigger issue than the softer numerals on the insert with the JF and I can't unsee it. On the RG 116655, my opinions are reversed (because the black insert hides that small gap and the sharper numerals are more noticeable for me there) but on the 116622, I like the JF better just for that reason.
Click to expand...

You mean none is a Super Rep right ?
 
Repworld

Repworld

Mythical Poster
27/12/16
6,354
1,571
113
garaged said:
The problem I have with the Noob and BP is the weird space between the outer edge of the insert and bezel. To me, personally, it's a bigger issue than the softer numerals on the insert with the JF and I can't unsee it. On the RG 116655, my opinions are reversed (because the black insert hides that small gap and the sharper numerals are more noticeable for me there) but on the 116622, I like the JF better just for that reason.
Click to expand...

BP Bezel look Great


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
dashindark

dashindark

Renowned Member
20/4/17
880
380
63
Great post.

I will contribute to your list by adding 4 watches to it:
1. Ebel 1911 discovery chronograph panda dial
2. Chopard Mille Miglia GTXL Chrono gray dial (All other colors are sub par)
3. IWC Aquatimer Cousteau diver 2008
4. Omega Ploprof V2

These 4 watches plus JLC NSD (in the under discussion list already) and IWC inge by noob (in the super rep list already) are the most well-made products in 2012.

Kind regards,

Ibrahim
 
B

bsmboi1017

Do not accept unsolicited offers
31/8/16
1
0
0
Hi I have a question: why are the other Tudor Blackbay colours not considered NWBIG, but the red is on the list?
 
Repworld

Repworld

Mythical Poster
27/12/16
6,354
1,571
113
Max_Schiller said:
BP bezel is bigger than gen. noob is more spot on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Noob Bezel wrong Olso they used old Blue Model and noob refused upgrade the Bezel


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
J

jaredjohnson

Active Member
26/2/17
255
5
0
bsmboi1017 said:
Hi I have a question: why are the other Tudor Blackbay colours not considered NWBIG, but the red is on the list?
Click to expand...
As far as I know, bezel on the blue version is wrong(should be glossy instead of matt) and black version bezel is of the wrong colour and the red triangle is much less colourful than it should be(rose versions)
Shield versions should have corrected it, but they have wrong movement.
 
G

garaged

Known Member
17/4/17
192
9
18
Max_Schiller said:
BP bezel is bigger than gen. noob is more spot on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

BP's insert is bigger, Noob's smaller (FFS, you can 'see' that damn gap between the bezel and insert), JF's midway :p So why not get the JF.

Apparently, the JF is a bit more inaccurate in some ways on the case (as against the Noob) but no one can really tell without looking too close. That's how I flipflopped and ended up switching my order from the Noob YM to the JF YM with Sead. Pretty happy with it (especially after getting one of the new Blackhole crystals added by Prof).

In any case, they're all 'good' reps and IMO good enough on hand to pass off as gen ... but not exactly super-reps like the new JF Oyster Perpetual.
 
jameslav2003

jameslav2003

Getting To Know The Place
5/8/15
75
1
8
garaged said:
BP's insert is bigger, Noob's smaller (FFS, you can 'see' that damn gap between the bezel and insert), JF's midway :p So why not get the JF.

Apparently, the JF is a bit more inaccurate in some ways on the case (as against the Noob) but no one can really tell without looking too close. That's how I flipflopped and ended up switching my order from the Noob YM to the JF YM with Sead. Pretty happy with it (especially after getting one of the new Blackhole crystals added by Prof).

In any case, they're all 'good' reps and IMO good enough on hand to pass off as gen ... but not exactly super-reps like the new JF Oyster Perpetual.
Click to expand...

For sure if you're anal enough then its a noob with a jf bezel and you're getting to super rep imho. I loved my noob so much i stopped wearing my gen hulk so had to trade it for a ym and the only really stand out difference is that bezel gap, once you see it you can't unsee it. I did a side by side you can search for, if interested.
 
G

garaged

Known Member
17/4/17
192
9
18
jameslav2003 said:
For sure if you're anal enough then its a noob with a jf bezel and you're getting to super rep imho. I loved my noob so much i stopped wearing my gen hulk so had to trade it for a ym and the only really stand out difference is that bezel gap, once you see it you can't unsee it. I did a side by side you can search for, if interested.
Click to expand...

https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/ym-rhoduium-noob-a2836-vs-gen.377341/

Exactly, that was my problem with the Noob. I saw it and couldn't unsee it ever again.

Sead also said that, contrary to the side by side by zocker, the bezel insert was more wobbly/loose on many Noobs he had sold as against the JFs. At that point, I had already made up my mind to switch to the JF on my order thanks to the un-unsee-able gap haha.

This was zocker's amazing comparison - great information even though it's missing many pictures courtesy photobucket.
https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/big-rolex-yachtmaster-review-6-digit.365876/
On the 116655 though, I completely agree that the Noob is the better choice!
 
r0b9502

r0b9502

Renowned Member
22/1/17
913
305
63
@timnic54 @Omagad, wouldnt we want to consider audio effects while considering status of reps (out of the box) as NWBIG or superReps?

Today I got back into my car after a short visit to a store. After I pushed the ignition on, I was still hearing a scratching/rattling noise for a few seconds. Concerned, I started thinking, hearing, looking around and then realized it was the stupid miyota movement in the 15400! If there were 3 more passengers in that well sound insulated car, and all had assumed that the 15400 was real, blindfolded, they would have spotted a tell.
 
M

mysterio

Mythical Poster
Advisor
19/8/08
9,794
866
0
r0b9502 said:
@timnic54 @Omagad, wouldnt we want to consider audio effects while considering status of reps (out of the box) as NWBIG or superReps?

Today I got back into my car after a short visit to a store. After I pushed the ignition on, I was still hearing a scratching/rattling noise for a few seconds. Concerned, I started thinking, hearing, looking around and then realized it was the stupid miyota movement in the 15400! If there were 3 more passengers in that well sound insulated car, and all had assumed that the 15400 was real, blindfolded, they would have spotted a tell.
Click to expand...

Unless ALL samples of a certain watch had it, you could not use noise to disqualify. It could just be a problem with your watch. As far as your what-if scenario goes, it's pretty unlikely (3 people who assumed your 15400 was real, so most likely well to do people, blindfolded in a well sound-insulated car). Well, unless you were a kidnapper at which point whether your watch was noisy or not would be the least of their concerns. :lmao:
 
M

MonsieurMax

I'm Pretty Popular
22/10/16
1,748
128
63
Earth
garaged said:
BP's insert is bigger, Noob's smaller (FFS, you can 'see' that damn gap between the bezel and insert), JF's midway :p So why not get the JF.

Apparently, the JF is a bit more inaccurate in some ways on the case (as against the Noob) but no one can really tell without looking too close. That's how I flipflopped and ended up switching my order from the Noob YM to the JF YM with Sead. Pretty happy with it (especially after getting one of the new Blackhole crystals added by Prof).

In any case, they're all 'good' reps and IMO good enough on hand to pass off as gen ... but not exactly super-reps like the new JF Oyster Perpetual.
Click to expand...

Crap yes I meant JF not noob! I gotta think before I type, sorry for the confusion


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom