• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs

B

Bigjaymofo

Known Member
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
29/5/17
170
1
0
Omagad said:
Please specify/add pics?
Click to expand...

This one...

BR123_bell_ross_vintage_black_dial_replica_watch_IMAGE_zpscegfzu96.jpg


http://www.marywatch.net/goods.php?id=482

Apologies, not my pic. Waiting on mine to arrive. It seems to be a very accurate rep with the exception of the movement.
 
Omagad

Omagad

I'm Pretty Popular
10/11/16
1,570
869
113
Super Reps Temple
Muni said:
Why not BP as per above link? @Omagad
Click to expand...

Because JF's only flaw is crown's being fat which you'll never see unless you have a ruler with you (this has already been discussed here).

The finish of markers/hands, you'll need a loupe and the bracelet thing you won't notice unless you wear it yourself (and who gives away his Rolex to anyone?)

BP's, on the other hand, have naked-eye-visible flaws, such as the rehaut problem, the lume, the bezel and even the movement if you're a bit careful (but I can give you that one).

So, from an owner perspective, I'm pretty sure BP's superior to JF's because it feels more "gen like" and have a much better clasp. On the other hand, to another dude's eye, JF's look superior to BP's, even tho BP's an excellent rep.

Of course, I'm totally open to discuss that since, again, this list is about consensus and not my own opinion. I'll add BP's to "probably" until we figure it out.
 
LuminorReptar

LuminorReptar

RepTime BST Mod
27/3/17
1,933
1,013
113
Beyond the Pines.
Omagad said:
Because JF's only flaw is crown's being fat which you'll never see unless you have a ruler with you (this has already been discussed here).

The finish of markers/hands, you'll need a loupe and the bracelet thing you won't notice unless you wear it yourself (and who gives away his Rolex to anyone?)

BP's, on the other hand, have naked-eye-visible flaws, such as the rehaut problem, the lume, the bezel and even the movement if you're a bit careful (but I can give you that one).

So, from an owner perspective, I'm pretty sure BP's superior to JF's because it feels more "gen like" and have a much better clasp. On the other hand, to another dude's eye, JF's look superior to BP's, even tho BP's an excellent rep.

Of course, I'm totally open to discuss that since, again, this list is about consensus and not my own opinion. I'll add BP's to "probably" until we figure it out.
Click to expand...

Just my observation, but isn't BP's bezel the closest to gen-like? I've always found one of the biggest visible flaws with JF's Yacht-Master is the insert doesnt look anything like gen, because the numbers and notches are not "crisp" or refined. The Noob bezel is better imo, but still not that close when you compare with gen.

BP's as far as I can tell seems to be the closest as the numbers and edges are all sharp and crisp... Wondering if anyone else has thoughts on this.. Pics below:

AsUppxu.jpg


O1kgTFA.png
 
Omagad

Omagad

I'm Pretty Popular
10/11/16
1,570
869
113
Super Reps Temple
LuminorReptar said:
Just my observation, but isn't BP's bezel the closest to gen-like? I've always found one of the biggest visible flaws with JF's Yacht-Master is the insert doesnt look anything like gen, because the numbers and notches are not "crisp" or refined. The Noob bezel is better imo, but still not that close when you compare with gen.

BP's as far as I can tell seems to be the closest as the numbers and edges are all sharp and crisp... Wondering if anyone else has thoughts on this.. Pics below:

AsUppxu.jpg


O1kgTFA.png
Click to expand...


We're talking about the 114300 right ?
 
M

MonsieurMax

I'm Pretty Popular
22/10/16
1,748
128
63
Earth
Omagad said:
The finish of markers/hands, you'll need a loupe and the bracelet thing you won't notice unless you wear it yourself (and who gives away his Rolex to anyone?)

So, from an owner perspective, I'm pretty sure BP's superior to JF's because it feels more "gen like" and have a much better clasp. On the other hand, to another dude's eye, JF's look superior to BP's, even tho BP's an excellent rep.
Click to expand...

Sorry to be that 'n00b' but I'm on the verge of pulling the trigger on a JF 114300 Grape and want to know what the "bracelet thing" your talking about is and what "feels more gen like" means? Are you talking about the finish of the bracelet?




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
G

gvln

Renowned Member
22/11/11
957
1
0
Omagad said:
PAM 057 - Luminor Power Reserve Titanium (44mm) DSNPAM 127 - Luminor 1960 "Fiddy" (47mm) Latest Noob
Click to expand...

i think you mean PAM027 DSN instead of PAM57 anf PAM 127 is 1950 not 1960
thanx
 
Copterguy

Copterguy

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
14/3/17
1,400
754
113
Florida
I see the pam111 Noob v3 on the list, but I only find a v4 on the TD market, isn't it an improvement or did it mess something up?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom