[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs

[jpohl402]

Awesome!! Thanks OP!

 

[Omagad]

Great work, dude! I love your attitude too, just hungry for information with no agenda. Good shit.

Awesome!! Thanks OP!

You're welcome guys. My pleasure !

I just thought I could do this since I was looking for myself, why not sharing with everyone

 

[Omagad]

Noob Breitling Superocean II 44 in black? I know the blue has a bezel that's a hair too dark (still great though), but I'm not entirely sure what, if any, tells the black has.

Or the BP navitimer world in black? Only tell I know of is that the sub dials are slightly raised in the center instead of flat like the gen. With the white you can see the slightly yellow crystal, but with black it's unnoticeable.

Or the H-Factory Avenger Seawolf? Basically nailed it, only issue is the HE valve is slightly different. And it uses the notoriously bad Z2 movement, but that can be easily switched out for a 2836.

Thanks man.

Added the Superocean II Black from Noob in "under debate".

 

[Juventus]

Amazing post, thank you very much, great job!!

 

[Omagad]

My pleasure.

 

[SPACECOWBOY 2017]

Hey Mate,

Thanks a lot for that great job. Very valuable information in your list.

As i am very much into PAMs, a quick browse through your list showed some discrepancies (e.g. PAM 312 and PAM 380 as well as missing PAM 390). Did you consider Ale's Pam Guide or Pimlicos extract of this guide only listing super reps of Panerai? (Yeah i know this guy has been jailed here, but his list extract from great Ale's guide is my shopping list). For all other brands your list will be my shopping list as of today....Thank you so much

Sent from the RWI App

 

[Omagad]

Hey Mate,

Thanks a lot for that great job. Very valuable information in your list.

As i am very much into PAMs, a quick browse through your list showed some discrepancies (e.g. PAM 312 and PAM 380 as well as missing PAM 390). Did you consider Ale's Pam Guide or Pimlicos extract of this guide only listing super reps of Panerai? (Yeah i know this guy has been jailed here, but his list extract from great Ale's guide is my shopping list). For all other brands your list will be my shopping list as of today....Thank you so much

Hello !

I am sorry, I can't really help with PAMs, not my kind of watches.

I've trusted the opinion of people who know a lot better than me.

If there is any PAM specialist out there that is reading this, could he help ?

If yes, maybe he can help.

 

[Keniath]

thanks for this list! really cool and great effort!
although adding version numbers would help.

 

[MasterWatch]

Well done on putting together a nice list for the community to go by.
Much appreciated.

Wouldn't the GF Breitling Avenger Blackbird also be considered a super rep? Me having bought one recently. I think it is pretty close to the gen.

 

[Omagad]

Well done on putting together a nice list for the community to go by.
Much appreciated.

Wouldn't the GF Breitling Avenger Blackbird also be considered a super rep? Me having bought one recently. I think it is pretty close to the gen.

Thanks man.

LIST UPDATE: Added to "Under discussion", we will see what people think.

 

[jakekrait]

I think the model version of the AP ROO jf should be specified. I think there is a consensus but there are a number of different models and the latest version (open caseback) does NOT belong on the list (i think there is consensus about this as well).

 

[Danii]

I think the model version of the AP ROO jf should be specified. I think there is a consensus but there are a number of different models and the latest version (open caseback) does NOT belong on the list (i think there is consensus about this as well).

The model is listed, its the Diver by JF. The ROO Chronos are not worthy of this list.

 

[jakekrait]

The model is listed, its the Diver by JF. The ROO Chronos are not worthy of this list.

Are you being serious? I dont want to discredit the thread but it seems like you have no idea about reps.

There are a number of different versions. The latest version should (obviously) not be on the list. Since the version is not specified people will assume its referring to the latest version.

 

[Danii]

Are you being serious? I dont want to discredit the thread but it seems like you have no idea about reps.

Yes I am absolutely serious. The model listed is: Audemars Piguet ROO Diver JF copied directly from the thread. Either V7 or V8 depending on if you prefer the 'wet' dial or not and ETA/Miyota.
The ROO chronos have multiple issues:
Datewheel position
Datewheel font
Datewheel depth
Hand stem thickness
Wrong crown placement
Case thickness
Movement decoration

I'd like you to share the ROO super-reps with the rest of the forum

 

[Omagad]

Can't agree more.

 

[jakekrait]

Yes I am absolutely serious. The model listed is: Audemars Piguet ROO Diver JF copied directly from the thread. Either V7 or V8 depending on if you prefer the 'wet' dial or not and ETA/Miyota.
The ROO chronos have multiple issues:
Datewheel position
Datewheel font
Datewheel depth
Hand stem thickness
Wrong crown placement
Case thickness
Movement decoration

I'd like you to share the ROO super-reps with the rest of the forum

Of course Chronos should not be on the list....

but it seems like you copied the list and copied the flaws of the list as well so there is no point in having another thread. Little to no value was added. The ROO Diver with open caseback (v8) should not be on the list.

 

[Danii]

Of course Chronos should not be on the list....

but it seems like you copied the list and copied the flaws of the list as well so there is no point in having another thread.

I am not the one who made a new thread, however i still support the decision to create a seperate thread exclusively for the list and one for discussion. Noobs may not want to look through 50 pages to find the list. This solves that problem.

 

[JackJ1980]

Blancpain Fifty Fathoms ZF now also I think. Also - Blancpain No Radiation from noob.

 

[JackJ1980]

WM9 16610 and 16613

 

[Omagad]

I am not the one who made a new thread, however i still support the decision to create a seperate thread exclusively for the list and one for discussion. Noobs may not want to look through 50 pages to find the list. This solves that problem.

Yes, also, there was little to no discussion on some of the watches of the list.

I made this because there was no consensus on some watches that were listed. Nearly all the "Under debate" ones were in the original list, even the "debate nearly closed".

Some were not even quoted as Super Reps, some were added you don't know why...

What I wanted to do is not only a separate thread, but also a more demanding one.