- 4/9/20
- 2,880
- 3,448
- 113
-
Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!
VSF Hulk comparison with Genuine and ZZF
- Thread starter StreetFighter
- Start date
muiramas
Aristocrat
- 18/1/17
- 5,977
- 7,764
- 113
- 24/10/17
- 3,522
- 5,721
- 113
muiramas
Aristocrat
- 18/1/17
- 5,977
- 7,764
- 113
I love it. I’d get the LB and LV right now but it looks like their 12XXXX’s are just round the corner and I’m going to buy the set. The LV insert misses that last 5% and the dial is kooky under halogens. But its good. This is the only LV rep I’ve seen that I can wear.
Yah, I know what you mean. Its not plastic.
Last edited:
Please tell me if I’m hijacking the thread but I didn’t think my question justified a whole new thread. As a complete noob to this hobby I’m after some advice. I’ve just received QC pictures for a ZZF hulk, the timing is showing a gain of 11.7secs/day. It’s better than the first, this was +44secs/day. Would you class this as acceptable? I GL some QC pics of a VSF sub I just ordered and that was less than a second per day. Any help is much appreciated, thank you.
It’s up to you in the end. +44 sec is ridiculous, i would have rejected that aswell. When it’s a clone movement I’ve never received one that was more +-4 sec.
Personally +11.7secs/day doesnt bother me as its nothing in the grand scheme of things. I just wonder if that discrepancy will increase with use? Also would you recommend a service when it arrives?
muiramas
Aristocrat
- 18/1/17
- 5,977
- 7,764
- 113
11 sec is ok - clone movement or otherwise. I would accept. A gen ETA has a wider variation than that.
It depends, if it’s a watch you intend to keep, then yes, I would get it serviced.
I think every Rep has to be serviced to run between -5 +5 seconds i never had a Rep ( ARF JF ZZF VSF noob ) what came out of the box and ran good.
But 11 seconds a day is nothing after one week the watch will go forward 1 minute
to adjust again takes less time than the time it goes forward
Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
But 11 seconds a day is nothing after one week the watch will go forward 1 minute
to adjust again takes less time than the time it goes forward Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
Tete
Active Member
- 4/11/16
- 488
- 261
- 63
I think it's a matter of luck, since I started in the rep game I have had more than 20, Asian ETA and SH31XX clones. I have never serviced any of them and they all run from 2 to 7 s/d
True it can be luck but I had with Amy clone movement problems when I wore it for a time daily. Maybe I bought the wrong models with shit movements
Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
Ciao a tutti. Cosa ne pensate del Noob versione 11 ? . Rolex Submariner 116610 LV Green Ceramic Noob 1: 1 Best Edition 904L SS Cassa e bracciale SA3135 V11
Jayalvin777
I'm Pretty Popular
Im pretty sure you gotta keep it in english mate but I wouldn't go for a noob, it's expensive and not better in any area against the other options in the market, get yourself a vsf or a zzf.
muiramas
Aristocrat
- 18/1/17
- 5,977
- 7,764
- 113
Everyone thinks Noob Submariners suck. And ARF ones too for that matter.
Tobel
Respected Member
- 6/7/17
- 5,456
- 3,673
- 113
You just joined, this is your 2nd post, you have a multi account, you write in Italian in an English forum and you ask about a noob in a thread about the VSF. Can you make just a little effort to respect this place?
- 24/10/17
- 3,522
- 5,721
- 113
buckkiller1
Known Member
- 22/9/16
- 106
- 10
- 18
Hello sir,.I got the VSF Hulk today. Huge thanks again to Trustytime, thanks Andrew!
I have a genuine 116610LN from 2018 and a ZZF V2S Hulk from last month that I am comparing it to. I also compare it to the bracelet from ARF, (supposedly) the best Submariner bracelet and clasp too. My finding below along with unboxing and too many pics too!
The Hulk with the stickers on is the VSF, the black LN is genuine.
Bracelets
Bracelet on the ZZF (C4R) had sharp edges all over and the clasp felt lightweight and the glidelock took very little force to open meaning it would just open and slide every time you opened the bracelet. The glide was not very smooth and far too easy, this does not feel quality. The bracelet as a whole feels quite cheap which makes the watch feel cheap.
I read ARF did the best 116610 bracelet so I bought one for my ZZF watch. It was an E5N code. It fitted on perfectly. The clasp on this felt so much better and infact, when compared to my genuine 116610 the form of the clasp was the exact same thickness where as the ZZF clasp was thinner, I guess this this where the nice weight feel comes from. The ARF E5N bracelet still had sharp edges that I could shave a finger nail with, but after some refinishing work (that took me a couple hours) and lubrication, I had the E5N feeling like genuine with even the clasp flip lock nearly there but a not quite just tight enough to be genuine feeling.
VSF bracelet and clasp is the best yet, I have 7GJ for reference. It has a high quality feeling tight clasp and flip lock and the edges of the link are finished nice and smooth and there is no way I can shave a finger nail with them! This feels better than the refinished ARF E5N above and it needs zero work to get it there. SEL fit is really good too. This VSF is the best out the box bracelet and clasp I have had on a rep, ever. It feels just like my genuine 116610LN did when it was brand new - and I really mean that. Bracelet and clasp winner: VSF (better than both ZZF and ARF)
Bezel
Noticeable difference in colour between ZZF and VSF bezel inserts with the VSF having a nicer colour to me. The number cut out are the same thickness (not thicker like some suggested) but they are brighter on the VSF, much brighter whiter platinum silver, they really POP like the number infills on my LN. The ZZF bezel insert doesn't have the same wow factor at all. Also, the VSF insert has a nice recess inside the bezel and a clear circular definition that is missing from the tight fit insert on the ZZF.
The insert numbers on the VSF and the colour of the infill and the non finger print insert with bevelled edged are way ahead of ZZF here. Just looking at it in low light here, its gone nice and dark same as the dial but I can't catch it with the digital camera (it makes it look bright).. Winner: VSF
Bezel action
ZZF is nice and tight with no back play. It feels just like my genuine 116610 did when it was new. VSF bezel feels just like my genuine 116610 does now with 2 years of use on it, which is fine too.
Dial colour
Not sure which is right or wrong but they are different. I remember thinking nothing of the genuine LV in pictures, but when I saw one I was blown away, mesmerised with that green, it was so stunning you have to see one yourself. I was so taken with it that I put myself on a list at my local AD but it never came sadly. Roll on last month, I got the ZZF and was delighted but I don't remember being blown away.. rose tinted specs perhaps.. but when i took this VSF out the box today I was BLOWN away with it,the green dial is magic!! The bezel is beyond beauty, I was blown away again. Camera cannot catch it, you need sto see it. VSF dial is mesmerising in a way the ZZF just is not, it for sure takes the win here. It's like a precious jewel!
Hands
I Don't even notice the difference folk speak of myself, but the hand look clean, no marks. If i had to choose probably ZZF wins but I don't see this as anything that matters to me. You decide.
Crystal
ZZF crystal is more or less flush with the bezel insert. VSF crystal sits very slightly above the insert just like the genuine, see pics. VSF has a better black hole effect. VSF is much more like genuine, VFS wins.
Crown guards
VSF has the best crown guards I have ever seen on any replica Submariner past or present. End of. ZZF falls short. It's the thing I look at on Sub reps, VSF looks genuine to me, I am 101% delighted with the crown guards on this rep.. See pics of both versus genuine below. VSF wins.
Crown
Unwinding the crown on the ZZF is gritty and not that great. It's much much out the box better on the VSF. I lubricated both with some silicone grease. The ZZF improved but still was not obviously not threaded well. However, the VSF after some grease feels like just my genuine one when I unscrew it, amazing. Winner VSF.
Movement.
The ZZF is a 2836, the VSF is a VS3135, it feels lovely and smooth. The a2836 in the ZZF feels like a a2836.. ok I suppose. Winner VSF until reliability proves otherwise.
Date wheel
ZZF date wheel font is noticeably thinner than on my genuine 2018 116610. VSF looks perfect thickness too me and the fonts all appear to be exact day to day (even the number 20's) have a nice gloss to them just like my genuine. No need to that at all in the VSF. Winner VSF.
Colour
ZZF is very very slightly yellower hue to the metal, but we are talking miniscule in the right light. The VSF more like the genuine as far as I can tell so far!
Weight
My genuine 116610LN with all 12 links is 158g. The VSF is 156g. The ZZF is 153g each with all 12 links. Winner: VSF
Summary
This VSF I am delighted with, I think its the best rep I have ever had out the box. I have been rep collecting for near 20 years and have had many through my hands and countless genuine sport Rolex to. If someone showed me this watch and took it off their wrist and I got to handle it for a few moments I would believe it was 100% genuine, that's how good I think this looks and feels.
For once while wearing a replica, I don't feel like I have a rep' on my wrist, it feels and looks to me like the a real Rolex, every time I look at it on my wrist I smile, the green is doing something different each time, from very loud to black. It looks very special and it feels great, you could pass this as genuine watch to a WIS who doesn't read VSF forum threads!.
Final word: VSF makes the ZZF look and feel like a replica. VSF feels and looks like a genuine Rolex.
I think this is NWBIG (investment aside) These are my opinions.
Please enjoy my pics.
Great review! I am definitely going to buy the VSF for sure and was wondering if the one reviewed is the 116610 LV Ceramic VSF 1:1 904 Steel A3135.
Thanks
Sent from my motorola edge plus using Tapatalk