• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Swiss watch industry Crisis ? Rep super clone movements ?

derjenigewelcher

Watch enthusiast
Supporter
Certified
22/11/20
9,863
13,504
113
Switzerland
I don't see any crisis ahead. Owning a Rolex is a status symbol, 99,999% of the owners have no clue what's inside or how to differentiate it, but they'll continue to go to the AD to have their status symbol. If a watchmaker switches parts inside, they won't know and they won't care as long as outside it's a recognizable Rolex.
You wanna tell me i never have to change the battery on my 126610LN????
 

Feefo

CEO, Vaselume (TM) Corporation
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
8/5/22
19,998
52,603
113
EU
You wanna tell me i never have to change the battery on my 126610LN????
Never.
Jimmy Fallon Promise GIF by The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon
 

RDRoss

Respected Member
Patron
Certified
28/5/19
4,665
7,398
113
I honestly believe the biggest crisis is the move towards a digital age. While it has been said before, I can say with some sense of certainty that wrist watches will become further niche products worn by us codgers still interested in the beauty of mechanical design.

I was (a rare event) in the office last week and saw no less than 50 people wearing smart watches (aka phone extenders) of various brands. Mostly apple but a smattering of android based beasts as well.

To the best of my knowledge (not saying much here BTW 😅) I am only aware of Tag and Breitling making the major leap towards connected devices so far (I think Fredrick constant did one riff as well but couldn’t find it and yes, montblanc does one but ick, just ick).

At some point i wonder if one of the big players will team up with an Apple or Google to build something?

Me, I just hate running out of juice, so I will stick to mechanical.
 

Zeta7

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
9/11/23
1,148
1,171
113
Cool if it works I was led to belive that sometimes fitting the gen spring cna over stress some of the other components over time where perhaps the gears are not quite as well cut or thickness. Might never be an issue and might only be on the GMT movements due to their extra complication. From and engineering perspective I can see it swinging both ways, the parts can/will fit but might require some of the other addtional moving parts swapped out at the same time probably more the moving machined parts where the gen or gen spec stuff has better tolerances on the finish. Im sure the reps are very close but looking at some of the post on this site comparing internals there can be quite a difference. The reps are very good but I would guess when their tooling is on its downward cycle they will get as much sue as they can where as Rolex would stop and use new tooling to avoid any sub stanard parts going out, also Rolex and Gen spec stuff will have better QC than alot of the China factories, they will take more a Land Rover approach of "that'll do" sometimes as its based on price. A few gen parts can cost the same price as a whole new VR3186.

Modding one with gen parts is a good way though to increase accuracy and longevity along wiht a full service, the main body parts and jewels are not really going to cause any real grief.

Out of interest what kinda money was that? Where did you get it done feel free to DM me if its UK and you dont wanna broadcast it though
I believe you have it backwards. Dandong used a stronger mainspring to attain the 72 hour power reserve that Rolex brags about. Rolex was able to attain 72hrs by using less mass in the escapement ie escape wheel and pallet forks. Rep used a stronger mainspring and sealed it in the barrel. I figured the additional stress was going to cause premature failure and that’s why I had the rep parts swapped out for gen. Reps may be just fine with the stronger mainspring but that was my logic. There doesn’t seem to be many people posting about problems but absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence. Only time will tell. 😂 get it
 

RDRoss

Respected Member
Patron
Certified
28/5/19
4,665
7,398
113
I believe you have it backwards. Dandong used a stronger mainspring to attain the 72 hour power reserve that Rolex brags about. Rolex was able to attain 72hrs by using less mass in the escapement ie escape wheel and pallet forks. Rep used a stronger mainspring and sealed it in the barrel. I figured the additional stress was going to cause premature failure and that’s why I had the rep parts swapped out for gen. Reps may be just fine with the stronger mainspring but that was my logic. There doesn’t seem to be many people posting about problems but absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence. Only time will tell. 😂 get it
Check out @trailboss99 field test and review of the CF. He is currently doing a long term review that is worth keeping an eye on.
 

Zeta7

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
9/11/23
1,148
1,171
113
Check out @trailboss99 field test and review of the CF. He is currently doing a long term review that is worth keeping an eye on.
I seen he was just beginning on a CF Daytona, is he also doing one on a dd3285 GMT? I’ll definitely keep my eye out for it. Like I said, I haven’t seen many problems posted and a few problems are to be expected. So the ootb watches are probably just fine. If problems do manifest themselves I’d expect it to be several years down the road. Time is a great leveler. Time wounds all heels.
 

RDRoss

Respected Member
Patron
Certified
28/5/19
4,665
7,398
113
I seen he was just beginning on a CF Daytona, is he also doing one on a dd3285 GMT? I’ll definitely keep my eye out for it. Like I said, I haven’t seen many problems posted and a few problems are to be expected. So the ootb watches are probably just fine. If problems do manifest themselves I’d expect it to be several years down the road. Time is a great leveler. Time wounds all heels.
I know he beat the bejebus out of a CF GMT as well. Have a search for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave2302 and Zeta7

TerryRobot

Renowned Member
Patron
Certified
13/9/15
596
461
63
I honestly believe the biggest crisis is the move towards a digital age. While it has been said before, I can say with some sense of certainty that wrist watches will become further niche products worn by us codgers still interested in the beauty of mechanical design.

I was (a rare event) in the office last week and saw no less than 50 people wearing smart watches (aka phone extenders) of various brands. Mostly apple but a smattering of android based beasts as well.

To the best of my knowledge (not saying much here BTW 😅) I am only aware of Tag and Breitling making the major leap towards connected devices so far (I think Fredrick constant did one riff as well but couldn’t find it and yes, montblanc does one but ick, just ick).

At some point i wonder if one of the big players will team up with an Apple or Google to build something?

Me, I just hate running out of juice, so I will stick to mechanical.
I got an Apple watch ive had for years series 4 think I have and app on it that allows me to set the face to a watch of my choosing so for a laugh I choose Polar explorer or Blusey Subs on my left hand, it does many count exercise for me and is handy for metting reminders and paying for a pint doon the battle cruiser! But I still prefer something on the other wrist that I like and is an expression of me and my likes, I buy watches for me but the Smart watches tend to be like modern cars they all look alike and blend in to the back ground, strangely in a society that has to be sooooo individual and have some sort of movement every day for something and not be ruled by "the man" they do seem to choose to support the big corps and blend in alot! With their Tesla's, Apple, and Starbucks and then listening to all those old classics re-produced on vinyl. (on a totally different topic how come records have made a come back but Cassettes and VHS havent doesnt anyone wnat the authentice dirty head crackles and lines on film for that aithentic original viewing pleasure!)

I think the shift has already happened to the digital age, people who used to sayin spending £500 or more on a watch was stupid but think noting off blowing more on an Apple watch and phone.

I reckon Watches are now more than a time piece for knowing when lunch is, they are now the only jewelry for us blokes. and the younger generation dont see the watch or the mechanics, they see bling or a label and if you can afford it liek a burberry scarf then you must be doing allright!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave2302

TerryRobot

Renowned Member
Patron
Certified
13/9/15
596
461
63
I believe you have it backwards. Dandong used a stronger mainspring to attain the 72 hour power reserve that Rolex brags about. Rolex was able to attain 72hrs by using less mass in the escapement ie escape wheel and pallet forks. Rep used a stronger mainspring and sealed it in the barrel. I figured the additional stress was going to cause premature failure and that’s why I had the rep parts swapped out for gen. Reps may be just fine with the stronger mainspring but that was my logic. There doesn’t seem to be many people posting about problems but absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence. Only time will tell. 😂 get it
(y) Yes agree not saying either way is wrong but mixing parts that were not originally desinged to work with other might never be a problem but it might is some of the parts are not designed to the same spec, bit like I guess putting stainless steel sump plugs in aluminium or aluminum sumps, both work but the chances of stripping the the thread on the sum are much higher than if it were made of steel in te first place. but like you said only time will tell either way ;) Might never be an issue and to be fair even if it is swapping in some gen spec parts is not big bill, so as the super reps movements are now taking gen parts, if they really o look the part then they will live as long as a gen, albeit maybe needing a few more parts along the way, or not!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave2302

Zeta7

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
9/11/23
1,148
1,171
113
I know he beat the bejebus out of a CF GMT as well. Have a search for it.

I’ll search it up. I suppose beating the bejesus out of one for a few months answers a few questions. It’s like the old timex commercials. “It takes a beating and keeps on sweeping” instead of the “it takes a licking and keeps on ticking”.
 

1TrueDeveloper

Known Member
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
INMATE
MULTI ACCOUNT
Certified
9/7/23
125
61
28
Germany
Wait what? This is getting more and more interesting, what type of “training” do pharmaceutical companies invite to? You mean like a way to bribe the right people for their own benefit type of way. Right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zeta7

1TrueDeveloper

Known Member
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
INMATE
MULTI ACCOUNT
Certified
9/7/23
125
61
28
Germany
Modern critics wield the power of shaping the public opinion around an artist or a product. The act of criticism is judging something according to principles of beauty, goodness and truth and explore its boundaries. Hence, it's something that highly reflects personal preferences and biases. Who is to say this aspect also properly reflects the role of art/a product with respect to its proper historical and social significance? Any good orator will be able to argue whatever he wants and influence the public opinion. While until the 20th century the role of criticism was more or less occupied by scholars who knew their stuff (who were nonetheless biased in their own way), nowadays "influencing" has become a profession. Subjective evaluations aimed at market manipulation is the rule today. Getting back to the wine analogy, there's wine critics claiming they taste between 10.000 and 14.000 new wines each year. That's a lot of wine tasting per day. How can such an evaluation be objective, let alone for the organolectic capabilities of one's taste papillae which won't be equal during a year. The same way pharmaceutical companies offer "trainings" in 7-star resorts in tropical paradises wine producers offer stuff under the desk to wine critics.
With art, it's a bit different, art galleries come into play but also these will follow their interests which are to meet the tastes of those who can afford expensive art and not the tastes of the wider population or the significance of an artist and his work in relation to history, society, the evolution of art etc.
Sure, genuine art meeting these requirements still sees the light of the day, but monetary interests of a limited amount of people play a bigger role.
Well, it's quite the complex topic and it can be contradictory in itself, and I'm not able to express it as I would like to. Plus, I have top get back to work...
Modern critics wield the power of shaping the public opinion around an artist or a product. The act of criticism is judging something according to principles of beauty, goodness and truth and explore its boundaries. Hence, it's something that highly reflects personal preferences and biases. Who is to say this aspect also properly reflects the role of art/a product with respect to its proper historical and social significance? Any good orator will be able to argue whatever he wants and influence the public opinion. While until the 20th century the role of criticism was more or less occupied by scholars who knew their stuff (who were nonetheless biased in their own way), nowadays "influencing" has become a profession. Subjective evaluations aimed at market manipulation is the rule today. Getting back to the wine analogy, there's wine critics claiming they taste between 10.000 and 14.000 new wines each year. That's a lot of wine tasting per day. How can such an evaluation be objective, let alone for the organolectic capabilities of one's taste papillae which won't be equal during a year. The same way pharmaceutical companies offer "trainings" in 7-star resorts in tropical paradises wine producers offer stuff under the desk to wine critics.
With art, it's a bit different, art galleries come into play but also these will follow their interests which are to meet the tastes of those who can afford expensive art and not the tastes of the wider population or the significance of an artist and his work in relation to history, society, the evolution of art etc.
Sure, genuine art meeting these requirements still sees the light of the day, but monetary interests of a limited amount of people play a bigger role.
Well, it's quite the complex topic and it can be contradictory in itself, and I'm not able to express it as I would like to. Plus, I have top get back to work...
Wait what? This is getting more and more interesting, what type of “training” do pharmaceutical companies invite to? You mean like a way to bribe the right people for their own benefit type of way. Right?
 

Feefo

CEO, Vaselume (TM) Corporation
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
8/5/22
19,998
52,603
113
EU
Wait what? This is getting more and more interesting, what type of “training” do pharmaceutical companies invite to? You mean like a way to bribe the right people for their own benefit type of way. Right?
Come on, this isn't really breaking news, and Big Pharma isn't the only sector using such practices. They simply invite a doctor to a "convention" or the likes about an average healthcare problem which the doctor can write off as training (hence recouping taxes) and it turns out the convention is held in a 7-star hotel & golf club, all inclusive. They gather for the "convention" part for a couple of hours (which is mainly marketing of their product) and the remaining 3-6 days the doctors can enjoy the hotel and its services, most of the time accompanied by their wife (or "secretary"). Sometimes this is sufficient for the doctor to feel compelled to make a big order for his private practice, sometimes other "pressure" practices or more concrete bribing methods come into place.
Continuing the original analogy, the wine critic may just get one pallet of wine instead of a bottle or two he actually would need for his tasting. Through his network, the critic will sell the remaining 160 bottles to a restaurant.
Everyone is corruptible.
 

Jackster

I'm Pretty Popular
Patron
Supporter
Certified
8/1/17
1,853
1,652
113
Paradise! (SE Qld)
@TerryRobot ”bit like Triggers boom, he's had the same broom for 20years and its only had 17 new handles and 14 new brushes”

I wonder how many readers have not got a clue what you are on about! 🤣🤣 Classic!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 122146 and Dave2302

TerryRobot

Renowned Member
Patron
Certified
13/9/15
596
461
63
@TerryRobot ”bit like Triggers boom, he's had the same broom for 20years and its only had 17 new handles and 14 new brushes”

I wonder how many readers have not got a clue what you are on about! 🤣🤣 Classic!
I know but its a great saying, just maybe lost on anyone outside the UK :ROFLMAO:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave2302

Zeta7

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
9/11/23
1,148
1,171
113
Come on, this isn't really breaking news, and Big Pharma isn't the only sector using such practices. They simply invite a doctor to a "convention" or the likes about an average healthcare problem which the doctor can write off as training (hence recouping taxes) and it turns out the convention is held in a 7-star hotel & golf club, all inclusive. They gather for the "convention" part for a couple of hours (which is mainly marketing of their product) and the remaining 3-6 days the doctors can enjoy the hotel and its services, most of the time accompanied by their wife (or "secretary"). Sometimes this is sufficient for the doctor to feel compelled to make a big order for his private practice, sometimes other "pressure" practices or more concrete bribing methods come into place.
Continuing the original analogy, the wine critic may just get one pallet of wine instead of a bottle or two he actually would need for his tasting. Through his network, the critic will sell the remaining 160 bottles to a restaurant.
Everyone is corruptible.
They reward doctors with kickbacks that come in all sorts of forms. Vacations are typical but gifts are too. The size of the kickback is determined by how much product the doctor moves.
 

trailboss99

Head Honcho - Cat Herder
Staff member
Administrator
Certified
30/3/08
43,901
20,147
113
Side by side comparison of movements after one has swap out a couple of parts with gen parts a bridge or two .., Could you really tell then apart ?
heck yes, the fit and finish are in no way comparable, it's a less than a minute job to tell when you know what you are looking for.



I seen he was just beginning on a CF Daytona, is he also doing one on a dd3285 GMT?
I haven't done a review yet but I wore it for three months while doing stuff that would give a Rolex tech a look like a modern-day WH&S inspector in an 1800s cotton mill. It's tough, it's very tough. I may do a write-up when I get the chance, I'm a day out of hospital after an argument with my gall bladder that the bladder nearly won.


I know but its a great saying, just maybe lost on anyone outside the UK
Na, it exists almost everywhere in some form, in a lot of places it's Graddad's Axe.
 

Dave2302

Self Confessed Eejit
Patron
Certified
19/11/23
4,260
10,930
113
Bumfuck Nowhere
I'm a day out of hospital after an argument with my gall bladder that the bladder nearly won.

Oh, wow, hope your feeling better now, 20 odd years ago Mel was very ill with it too, I remember sitting waiting for her to come outta the Op