Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 Blue X PPF 5711 White - a Humble Comparison

[BlackJaguar]

Phenomenal review, my friend. This is a wonderful comparison.

 

[marcoxxxx84]

Who knows if the crown issue can be fixed by our modders

 

[gilrob]

Who knows if the crown issue can be fixed by our modders

Just like the bezel issue, it may be too costly or too difficult. It's best to ask a modder or wait for the v2.

 

[Chaosg]

Phenomenal review, my friend. This is a wonderful comparison.

Wow, thank you so much! Very pleased you liked unk:

 

[Chaosg]

Just like the bezel issue, it may be too costly or too difficult. It's best to ask a modder or wait for the v2.

I concur too. Bezel fixing would demand a special tool that makes the grinding/polishing around the bezel. It would be useful too for APs bezels - who knows it could be a good mkt opportunity for modder to provide services of polishing AP bezels.

For the crown, it does look a lot of work, bc making the indentation deeper on the case is not a piece of cake - and the mkt for modder is restricted

Really a V2 would be great

 

[mottykytu]

That’s so difficult to answer your question, I guess mainly bc I’m here at RWI with all this crazy nitpickers around me.... :woo:

I’d nevertheless keep what I already said before, that the PPF white one is quite comparable when you see the full picture. If you check the last set of pics on comparison, it was meant to give you exactly the chance to feel it.

But, I guess only bc I’m here I’d recognize it as a replica - should I be a gen owner not aware of that, I’d bet it would pass as gen , although with crown not fully screwed down. Of course, on macro pics this would vanish....

For the blue versions like PF and MKF, I’d recognize as a replica bc colour is not good ( I know lots of you think otherwise). I have to base my opinion on the pics I’ve seen, though, and it’s really necessary to have IRL to make a sure assertion.

For the PPF blue, I’m still waiting to see better pics, so far, I didn’t like the colour. I hope it can be improved.


cheers

Very Nice, One point I really want to ask Gen Owner like you is that Does the BEZEL Thickness different really THAT obvious in real life?

 

[mottykytu]

Just like the bezel issue, it may be too costly or too difficult. It's best to ask a modder or wait for the v2.

And then, they will make another flaws in the V2... This time may be Hands/Dial Flaws?

Sure they never make it perfectly...

 

[Chaosg]

Very Nice, One point I really want to ask Gen Owner like you is that Does the BEZEL Thickness different really THAT obvious in real life?

Well, IMHO, the difference is not that obvious IRL, as you might agree based on the last 4 pics of post.

Also, I think that the increased thickness of brushed area is more obvious on the blue dial due to contrast.

cheers

 

[gilrob]

And then, they will make another flaws in the V2... This time may be Hands/Dial Flaws?

Sure they never make it perfectly...

Maybe? We'll just have to wait and see. If the next version is not good enough, move on to another watch/model.

 

[centrum]

Let PPF take the throne of the rep Nautilus. It is a very handsome watch indeed. If they fix those obvious issues with the next version, I will be tempted to buy one. Thank you for your excellent review!

 

[thumbsarehandy]

Thank you for your review and your insights!

 

[mottykytu]

Maybe? We'll just have to wait and see. If the next version is not good enough, move on to another watch/model.

Normally, how long will it take for TD to make a V2 of a successful Rep Watch? Months or a year? If it 3-6months, I can wait

 

[Xabo]

Amazing thank your for this eye candy!

 

[Tobel]

Excellent post and great comparison, thanks a lot for the effort!

 

[csthe]

Thank you for this great review mate!
If you ever put your hand on a blue pff...

 

[BIONONE]

This thread deserves to be a sticky IMO

informative and well written. Humble all the way and in no way biased. This is the kind of knowledge and valuable information the forum needs.

Huge thanks to you mate - nice to have you here!

 

[Chaosg]

Let PPF take the throne of the rep Nautilus. It is a very handsome watch indeed. If they fix those obvious issues with the next version, I will be tempted to buy one. Thank you for your excellent review!

You're very welcome , mate!

 

[Chaosg]

Thank you for your review and your insights!

I'm happy you guys liked it

 

[Chaosg]

Amazing thank your for this eye candy!

It's my pleasure, mate

 

[Chaosg]

Excellent post and great comparison, thanks a lot for the effort!

Thank you for your kind words