• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Gen Tudor Black Bay v Rep v4

timnic54

Respected Member
16/2/16
3,409
1,253
113
Thailand
I guess one day this was bound to happen. I was bound eventually to see a rep whereby there were some very slight differences, nothing to get it called out, but in every one of those tiny differences actually better than the gen. I truly believe that in this case the rep looks a better watch.
 

English Gent

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
10/7/14
1,670
410
83
I guess one day this was bound to happen. I was bound eventually to see a rep whereby there were some very slight differences, nothing to get it called out, but in every one of those tine differences actually better than the gen. I truly believe that in this case the rep looks a better watch.

Ive put the Gen strap on the rep and wearing now, the Lume even seems better and its day!
 

unicornpad

Known Member
1/1/15
140
15
18
You can tell all that from this pic? I can´t see a thing :wow:
img_1094_zpse0cted4wcc_zpsdadksssa.jpg

my old V1
DSC_4907c_zpsps45gsxw.jpg

Easiest tell as of the printing thickness and that two stroke of line that they can never get it done right lol

Own a gen hence that's the first thing I look out for

Not the best pic but was a 1min photoshop job lol

YjSioRo.jpg
 

jonny727

Getting To Know The Place
24/8/15
65
0
0
amazing - such minor differences if you had one without the other it would be near impossible to tell.
 

ay42

Getting To Know The Place
21/9/16
46
4
8
Thanks. I've had a browse through and found some from intime, torobravos and iwatchstation. All appear to be from the same factory. The only thing left now is to decide whether I should go for a cheaper movement (23J and v3 of watch) or a 2824 movement (v4 of watch.
 

ay42

Getting To Know The Place
21/9/16
46
4
8
Thanks! Do you know if the v3 and v4 have major differences?
 

yakon_88

Renowned Member
24/4/14
634
7
18
Does the rose gold shine as nice as the gen? On the pics it looks a bit duller.
 

Alex1975

Renowned Member
12/11/15
533
146
43
Many thanks [MENTION=86244]English Gent[/MENTION] for the side by side review & your thoughts.

The Tudor BB Red has evaded me so far, I think primarily because I have been weighing up getting a Gen but feedback has also previously mentioned the closeness of the rep....

Once my dalliance with picking vintage gens up has subsided I think this will be the next rep into the stable....

Appreciate you helping me to make the decision......
 

mech500

Mythical Poster
6/4/12
8,253
3,601
113
UK
Easiest tell as of the printing thickness and that two stroke of line that they can never get it done right lol

Own a gen hence that's the first thing I look out for

I know what you're saying but If overall quality, look and feel is practically gen, then nobody could realistically prove that your watch isn't a gen variation....unless of course you're a member here. Even then most members don't know what precise flaws to look out for.
 

yakon_88

Renowned Member
24/4/14
634
7
18
it is 90% of gen, really there is no difference, it even keeps better time than gen...
Wow would feel a bit passed for the price difference... but do you have the new calibre or the 2824 variant?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
 

Maron

Mythical Poster
16/2/15
9,469
807
113
Canada
Shouldn't matter. A top grade eta 2824 can be timed in as good or better than any other movement

Sent from my SM-G900W8 using Tapatalk
 

dan89

Renowned Member
4/9/16
991
5
0
Did this BB even enter the rep of the year previously? Now even more difficult to make decision on this or a Pelagos, as both model are really close.
 

Omega111

Getting To Know The Place
DO NOT TRADE WITH ME
4/9/16
41
0
0
Does anyone know if there is a v4 of the blue version too please? I can only find it in the red
 

English Gent

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
10/7/14
1,670
410
83
Does anyone know if there is a v4 of the blue version too please? I can only find it in the red

have look on intime, it never needed a v4, as the lume colour was correct from the start.
 

robinstyler

Renowned Member
4/7/16
658
31
28
i just ordered a black bay bronze and two day date 40s. as soon as they release the v5 im sold on it. waiting on them to fix the rose logo. also owned a pelagos v1 before. beautiful watch. those two are definately on the buying list. new blue model pelagos, owned the black before and the bb preferably v5 if its out by the time im looking to buy