Lol. You have to be careful when you say edge because, as you know, there is a thin border around each subdial which isn't always seen, especially in angled shots like that, and depending on how the light is refracting. I like the comparison, and I still think the dial looks fantastic.
But if I were going for gen dial, I would pay Nikz to get me one. At $4400, I don't think the price is warranted unless you were going full gen or if that was the last piece of the puzzle on a nice franken build. But at $150 for a Clean V3 matte dial look thrown into a BTF v2 base, I think it's incredibly worth the money for under $1K.
Again, I look at things the way they are. These are reps, and they will never be perfect. I understand we have a lot of folks that look at these 50x images and see tons of flaws, and I have no issues with that. To each their own. I will look at it 1 ft away and be extremely happy. Others will look at it from 3 -5 feet away and think it's a marvel. Most of the time, the only tell of a replica is the person wearing it.