-
Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!
[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs
- Thread starter Omagad
- Start date
Hi @Omagad,
What tells are you talking about?
In what factory version? I think the YL version is really, really close to gen.
Really curious about this...
Cheers
- 28/2/17
- 2,311
- 1,819
- 113
Thought id chip in, one case where the open case back isnt and instant easy tell, although it is lacking the gold lettered engraving of gen. Pretty good none the less, and more reliable than a 7750!
Gen:
Rep:
Gen:
Rep:
Thickness only wouldn't be a problem.
But.
Thickness, crown, rehaut font size, logo font size, moon phase, date dial font, pin button, bracelet font, bracelet text placement, date window shape, and a few other tells... it's too much.
Of course, on the wrist, you wouldn't notice them all but all of them together makes it no Super Rep, only a First Class rep.
Well, I didn't have them in mind, just checked the comparison pics carefuly :-D
I try to be as accurate as possible for this thread to be a reference.
I suggest you ask in IWC forum and if you think it is relevant, you come back with more infos.
In this thread we don't review watches, we discuss their flaws, which is not the same.
Ah okay, I haven't read all the posts in this thread but I thought I can ask or suggest something here
Here I've found some threads for this 3714 from ZF and comparison with Gen
https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/portuguese-3714-zf-slim-movement-v2-vs-gen.385982/
The dials and subdials should be great for the one from ZF, the movement also has been improved so it's not a time bomb anymore.
Thickness and diameters also the same as genuine.
Ah okay, I haven't read all the posts in this thread but I thought I can ask or suggest something here
Here I've found some threads for this 3714 from ZF and comparison with Gen
https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/portuguese-3714-zf-slim-movement-v2-vs-gen.385982/
The dials and subdials should be great for the one from ZF, the movement also has been improved so it's not a time bomb anymore.
Thickness and diameters also the same as genuine.
Not bad, the markers tho ? And the hands (and the subdials)
But definitely NWBIG imo, what you think ?
Added to first class for the moment.
Desmond20052000
Active Member
- 21/3/17
- 358
- 64
- 28
The "Swiss Made" in the ZF version is too high so it is a obvious tell, I wonder if anyone has photos of the YLF black dial so we could compare a bit.
Can someone please tell me why omega spectre V6F V2 is not a super rep. What is the tell?
Cheers
Cheers
The display back case show a movement which is only a decoration. Unless I am mistaken it for another watch
Sent from my SM-G930F using RWI mobile app
Yes, I agree, even just a bit but it's quite noticeable even when not side to side with gen.
Not bad, the markers tho ? And the hands (and the subdials)
But definitely NWBIG imo, what you think ?
Added to first class for the moment.
After reading some threads I notice that the hours marker esp 3, 9, and 2 sometimes have different shape comparing to gen, but again it shouldn't be that noticeable unless you compare it side to side with gen IMO.
Black subdials for ZF looks close to gen IMO, but not white subdials, their white subdials looks shinier than gen (matte).
The hands look the same for me, in size and length.
Anyway I think it should be V3, not V2. V2 has the old movement, not reliable. V3 has the same case and everything as V2, except the movement is new, modified, more reliable.
Does the Yacht-Master 116622 Rhodium blue Noob has a new version? Does it count as super reps yet?
I saw from one TD that it was updated on 17 Aug 2017.
TIA
I saw from one TD that it was updated on 17 Aug 2017.
TIA