I have read that some find that list out of date and no longer relevant. As this forum does not like the 'which is best rep question' is there anyway RWI could poll its longstanding knowledgeable members to create a more updated list? I took the list as gospel and ordered a vsf sub and I very happy i did. but i don't want to order another based on that list second time around as I might miss a gem that has improved since list was compiled.
-
Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!
[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs
- Thread starter Omagad
- Start date
Choosing watches using this list is not the recommended approach at RWI. Not only is this list outdated, more importantly you are misled to chose reps based on this list rather then the ones suitable for you. A mistake a lot of member committed, so did I. My first purchase was a PP Calatrava NWBIG now sitting in the drawer.
So decide on the model you like first and then make your research in the respective section. There you can find detail reviews and decide whether the rep meets your standards and which factory to choose.
So decide on the model you like first and then make your research in the respective section. There you can find detail reviews and decide whether the rep meets your standards and which factory to choose.
Last edited:
Can't agree with this more. I found myself grabbing a bunch of Panerai's that had the legendary NWBIG status back then only to find that I didn't actually like how the watches felt on wrist even though they were remarkable reps (absolutely massive things) You should decide on the style and types of watch that you like, maybe even down to the particular models that you like, and hunt the rep from there. My two cents of course
I would say if closer to gen is a big factor for you (and tbh to many others), you can just by reading the brand section you're interested in get a feel of which models are better replicated.
Then if some of them interest you, you can go to the thread of each model and read there about the quality of each rep. You can also read the very helpful comparisons that TDs post for some models. That way you will have the best idea of strengths and weaknesses of each factory/model.
That's what I did at least.
- 26/6/21
- 8
- 3
- 3
From the knowledge I’ve gained here, I think I’ve learned getting the watch you like is most important. Making it yours over time and perfecting it with better parts seems like the best option in my opinion. Based on what I’ve seen in the collectors corner etc.. There are some impressively good builds. I don’t think this list has been updated in a year now it seems, and I agree with everyone else it leads users to making that their focal point is it on the list or not.
yeas that is what i did with the list, although it worked out good for me. got a vsf sub, although still know very little about rep watches in general. this place is a fantastic resource with an interesting ethos. Reminds me of my first day in uni. 'We are not here to spoon feed you'.
thanks for replies and opinions. All drawn pretty much same conclusion. My subby might get some enhancement at some point. I think the common theme is dial, hands, crystal. The crystal on my pepsi is a definite weak spot also in my eyes. The bezel looks fine though, as the originals have variations in colour, I can live with that.
- 26/6/21
- 8
- 3
- 3
it seems it is updated. i look it a lot because i wait daytonas to be in more and more ^^
Linksrat
Getting To Know The Place
Sheesh, what a great comparison chart. Lot of work went into that and its helpful. Thanks!
thats not that old tbf, any major changes in a specific build will be posted everywhere as soon as they are available. I used that same list to choose my first rep (vaf 126610ln). i am 100% satisfied with watch. I still have very little knowledge of gens, beyond having a few on wrist in an AD and my memory of them is such that my subby feels pretty close.
It's no longer updated, the Clean 11xxxx Daytona is a great rep.
I believe all the 12xxxx reps are wrong on thickness.
I wouldn't worry about, one of the managers where I work says a Daytona is his grail watch, like most of us he's never had a gen one in his hands, he knows I wear reps, he gets a bit emotional holding my v1 Noob Daytona and it's about 2.5mm too thick! There are people here who would spot what it is from 10' away.
He doesn't know, he thinks it's a full on "super clone" and all but indistinguishable from gen.
Last edited:
- 15/2/20
- 30
- 16
- 8
Excellent, well-researched post that provides invaluable guidance for anyone navigating the world of replica watches. Clear and useful reference that helps buyers make informed decisions without unnecessary hassle. The dedication to accuracy and community involvement truly shines through. Great job!
There is another spreadsheet, this one is up to date as of May 15th...Also if you can't find it, (it's in the very first post), it'll little use to you.
