• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Clean Factory New Release 40mm YachtMaster (Comparison vs. Genuine)

pistebasher

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
13/6/20
1,705
1,355
113
UK
Got mine yesterday and its an amazing piece. Incredibly close to gen. Clean's best work so far. I would say near impossible to find any meaningful tells beyond the cyclops construction and LEC arrangement.
 

GG2019

Active Member
Certified
23/12/19
337
77
28
Uk
I’m also currently in the process of doing this exact build mate…
Clean ym base, Gen 126622 Blue Dial & Gen 126622 Hands
Then going to swap to the vs3235 movement out of my VSF SUB41 into the YM
Any update on your Build/Swap or Advice?
I’m sending all parts to my watchmaker next week.
How did you get on with this build?
I’m looking at doing the same!
Does anyone know if the 116622 bezel is the same ?
 

Samgobigs

Active Member
11/2/20
204
61
28
Between the blue dial and the slate dial, which one is closer to genuine? In my opinion, it seems that the slate has the edge. The blue dial looks good, but in some of the images, it almost looks blue / purple.

It seems that certain colors are easier to replicate (usually black, grey and white). This isn’t specific to the YM, but seems to be the case for various other factories and lineups. I don’t want to deviate from this discussion, but dials like the hulk submariner are hard to replicate, but the black dial sub is hard to mess up color-wise.
 

wubsub

i like subs
Supporter
Certified
31/10/18
2,282
2,988
113
sorry who are?
Between the blue dial and the slate dial, which one is closer to genuine? In my opinion, it seems that the slate has the edge. The blue dial looks good, but in some of the images, it almost looks blue / purple.

yes sir, the rhodium is better, reps cannot accurately replicate the rolex blue especially in sunlight where the blue doesnt keep its dark tone and turns purpleish on the reps whilst gens maintain the blue hue
 
  • Like
Reactions: masterpiece777

masterpiece777

Renowned Member
17/6/19
527
300
63
EUROPE


Received mine aswell great quality.
Have a gen complete bezel assambly,crown xtal hands.

Will send them to tomrep to get it all installed.

I maybe will change the movement with my VSF sub41.

But I must say it’s a realy great watch OOTB
 

bertieng

I'm Pretty Popular
26/11/18
1,262
482
83
What is the construction of the YM bezel like? Not seeing much info on this though.
 

och

Known Member
19/4/22
175
34
28
Got mine yesterday and its an amazing piece. Incredibly close to gen. Clean's best work so far. I would say near impossible to find any meaningful tells beyond the cyclops construction and LEC arrangement.

The lume will usually be an easy tell.
 

diamonds

Renowned Member
Supporter
Certified
17/3/21
649
996
93
The lume will usually be an easy tell.
Are you gonna be standing next to someone in the dark comparing lumes? That would vary depending on charging.

Lume fills are never a tell either, cause even gens have lumes that are overfilled or underfilled, all within what Rolex calls: "Tolerance Standards."
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Yadda Yadda

Wstn33

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
Certified
5/7/22
99
30
18
United States
Beautiful!! 💥 The YM's are not high in demand compared to subs and Daytonas but got to get one or two now after seeing these pics. Stunning from top to bottom!
 

spaceman007

Active Member
5/1/22
219
57
28
Does anyone know how difficult it would be to get an aftermarket gen Rolex bezel for this watch?
 

och

Known Member
19/4/22
175
34
28
Are you gonna be standing next to someone in the dark comparing lumes? That would vary depending on charging.

Lume fills are never a tell either, cause even gens have lumes that are overfilled or underfilled, all within what Rolex calls: "Tolerance Standards."

If we are 15 minutes into the movie and can't see the lume, that's what I meant.
 

diamonds

Renowned Member
Supporter
Certified
17/3/21
649
996
93
If we are 15 minutes into the movie and can't see the lume, that's what I meant.
As I said in my reply, "that would vary depending on charging."

Lume brightness and time duration is relevant to how well charged the lumes are. Under normal conditions, not even gen Rolex lumes last for hours, nor are they obnoxiously bright.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yadda Yadda

hib7&

Getting To Know The Place
24/10/22
19
3
3
How do these compare to the ewf watches? I've heard nothing but good things about them and have heard people say "they look stunning, especially for $300". Are there parts of it that look better than the clean? Is it just considered a bargain for the price? I read through a comparison showing the differences in case shaping as well as the overall finishing between the two but wasn't sure which is closer to gen or which is more accurate. Any info would be appreciated!
 

och

Known Member
19/4/22
175
34
28
As I said in my reply, "that would vary depending on charging."

Lume brightness and time duration is relevant to how well charged the lumes are. Under normal conditions, not even gen Rolex lumes last for hours, nor are they obnoxiously bright.

Noted sir, thank you so much.
I did try putting the watch under UV light for 15 seconds but yet it couldn't withstand for an hour.

Just thought to get ideas/experiences from everyone else here.