Got both CF—
These are some of the best Rolex reps I’ve come across. The Polar looks great in photos but feels underwhelming in person— it looks quite plain in my opinion, even cartoonish at times. On the other hand, the black dial truly shines with its polished hands and indexes, giving it a more premium vibe. The minor flaws don’t significantly detract from the overall quality, which holds up well even side by side with gens. In hand and under close inspection, differences can be felt, but for the price, there’s really nothing to complain about.