So, OP, did you present this watch to your local watchsmith for evaluation?
If you posted his findings I missed it.
I get concerned when somebody starts this sort of thread before getting a mod involved. We have little to go on, having only one story upon which to justify a position. Yet posters often tend to line up behind the person who started the thread. This is understandable, sure. But we don't have enough information to reasonably take a position.
The mods are here to help get the facts out, and we should let them do so before we pile on either party. Better still, leave the drama to TNT. If somebody gets banned or no-saled, we know now what we really need to know.
Just my $0.02 USD as always.