Any Whisky recommendations?

[Cigar_Guy97]

@Cigar_Guy97 , way better choices out there for the $$$. Woodford has become way overpriced. Old Forester is a good option for less $$$.

Old forester is fantastic, but double oaked where I am is only about $5 more than old forester 1910 I’ve even seen them the same price. NC has some kind of law where bottles can only sell retail at MSRP

 

[Cigar_Guy97]

It's a good call, but there are so many good choices out there and better choices for way under 200 bucks

You’re thinking of the double double oaked for $200

 

[dynastydoc]

I’m a fan of the woodford masters collection…

 

[Aquanautilus]

Blanton's Straight from the Barrel however, is worth the $200. World's better if you like high proof.

Just got a bottle, tastes awsome! thx

 

[baxtard]

You cant go wrong with Macallan 18, specially the sherry oak

 

[fatarms]

Old forester is fantastic, but double oaked where I am is only about $5 more than old forester 1910 I’ve even seen them the same price. NC has some kind of law where bottles can only sell retail at MSRP

Just had a 1920, 115 proof last night. Really good stuff, lots of flavor and nowhere near the burn I would expect from a proof that high.

Four Roses Single barrel is another one that kinda flies under some people's radar. Great sub-$50 bottle and is probably one of the best I've had neat, rocks or even in an old fashioned. Always try to keep a bottle of that in the collection behind the bar for sipping and watching some hockey.

 

[Dxp200]

Any scotch is a good scotch, but lately im a big fan of the more isla peaty flavor, like Lagavulin 16yr

 

[arout]

Any scotch is a good scotch, but lately im a big fan of the more isla peaty flavor, like Lagavulin 16yr

If you’re a fan of Lagavulin 16, you clearly appreciate a good smoky dram. For something in a more average price range but still full of character, I’d recommend Ardbeg 10.
It’s peaty, bold, and delivers a great Islay experience without breaking the bank. Laphroaig 10 is another solid pick with that punchy smoke and medicinal edge you might enjoy!

 

[Dxp200]

If you’re a fan of Lagavulin 16, you clearly appreciate a good smoky dram. For something in a more average price range but still full of character, I’d recommend Ardbeg 10.
It’s peaty, bold, and delivers a great Islay experience without breaking the bank. Laphroaig 10 is another solid pick with that punchy smoke and medicinal edge you might enjoy!

Had them both and yes they are great for the price. For me the more smoke the bettter

 

[matt215]

Distillers is my go to.

 

[suffolkdiver]

I drink my whisky like brandy, first warm the glass with my hands and then take a good long sniff to breath in the peat and smoke smells.
Then a small drink to roll around my mouth to cover all the taste buds. Then swallow it slowly.

 

[skskskskkkskkkkssk]

Glenlivet all day

 

[ebzen02]

Any scotch is a good scotch, but lately im a big fan of the more isla peaty flavor, like Lagavulin 16yr

That lagavulin 16 is the only legit good spirit in that group. Everything else is meh.

 

[Greatlakes6]

Considering opening the Black label

 

[pam63C]

You cant go wrong with Macallan 18, specially the sherry oak

Yes, M18 Sherry Oak is really good but getting more and more expensive.

Any Macallan around $200 worth the penny ?

 

[KruisingKhaos95]

Yes, M18 Sherry Oak is really good but getting more and more expensive.

Any Macallan around $200 worth the penny ?

I think the double cask 15 is around that price, maybe a bit less, but honestly, I don't think it's worth it, given the 12 is ~ half the price. I don't think there is much of a difference in the flavour to justify the price difference.

I would either get the 12-year double cask or spend a bit over budget for an 18-year first-fill sherry from either '05 or '06.

 

[Got20Mate]

I drink my whisky like brandy, first warm the glass with my hands and then take a good long sniff to breath in the peat and smoke smells.
Then a small drink to roll around my mouth to cover all the taste buds. Then swallow it slowly.

 

[pam63C]

I think the double cask 15 is around that price, maybe a bit less, but honestly, I don't think it's worth it, given the 12 is ~ half the price. I don't think there is much of a difference in the flavour to justify the price difference.

I would either get the 12-year double cask or spend a bit over budget for an 18-year first-fill sherry from either '05 or '06.

What you said makes good sense.

Has stopped buying Macallan for years and been feeding on the Glenmorangies, Ardbeg and the Yamazaki 12 years. Will get a bottle of the Macallan 12 Sherry Oak to try soon.

 

[KruisingKhaos95]

What you said makes good sense.

Has stopped buying Macallan for years and been feeding on the Glenmorangies, Ardbeg and the Yamazaki 12 years. Will get a bottle of the Macallan 12 Sherry Oak to try soon.

Honestly, same here. I do like Macallan, but there are so many other whiskies in that price range that I prefer. I am often gifted Macallan from friends and family around Christmas time and birthday's and I'm never disappointed, but it's something I'd rarely buy for myself.

 

[suffolkdiver]

Just lately I've been sipping Monkey shoulder, which is 3 malts blended.