• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

ARF SD43 904L 126600 review (many pics)

m5smg2

Put Some Respect On My Name
Supporter
Certified
23/8/07
5,999
7,601
113
A proper Rolex for AP, IWC, PAM fans. I’ve had a love/hate relationship with the 44mm DEEP-SEA....I love the design and size, but DSSD is too thick even for 44mm, top heavy on the wrist, and its look was never quite balanced like the 44mm YMII. This all new 2017 SEA-DWELLER 43mm design is just perfect in look and wrist comfort with its 15mm thickness. Its beautifully proportioned with its tapered 22mm bracelet and wider clasp (clasp is wider than Sub). I’ve been looking forward to this new 43mm 2017 SD more than any other release. I turned 50 this year, and so did the Sea-Dweller. I’ve included pics with my 1665 DRSD and my Noob 42mm Polar.

About the gen:
Rolex replaced the short run of the 40mm 2014 SD for reasons that can be argued. To celebrate the 50th anniversary of first double-red 1665 Sea-Dweller, rolex makes an all new balanced design in 43mm, dial print in red, and for the first time in a SD adds a cyclops (love/hate). The 126600 houses a new generation 3235 caliber with time set direction same as an ETA movement.

About the rep:
First, big thanks to Angus puretime for excellent communication and service as always, as well as his contributions and insights. The first thing that grabbed me when I took it out of its cool plastic case was the finish. I can’t say how much is from the 904L steel, but the smoothness of the brushed finish is just beautiful and very gen like — as good or better in the detail and quality as other JF products I’ve had, rolex and AP. The SEL fit is good. Bezel turns with a nice feel. Crown position is correct per gen with the A2824 (2836 versions crown looks lower), AND as luck would have it the new rolex 3235 movement time set direction is now the same as an ETA Win Win for our hobby! The A2824 winds smooth and rotor is very quiet. The dial finish looks semi-gloss like the gen to me. It looks more matte in sun light, and glossy in regular light. The “SEA-DWELLER” lettering is raised like the gen, gives a 3D effect, and the red color is correct. The bezel insert fonts look spot on in graphic accuracy and engraving depth. The insert “platinum” looks closest to gen we’ve seen yet it’s bright silver but also metallic, and has excellent contrast in low light.

I knew JF (ARF) made superior APs, but I wasn’t convinced about their rolex efforts until recently with their 904 Daytonas and now this SD43 that they’ve surpassed Noob. I also think JF YMII is fantastic (not my style). I have and love several Noobs which I think are excellent (42 Polar, SD4K, GMT CHS) and to me they are 9. ARF is 9.8

bc92955f1daac29145bc13d794113953.jpg

b4a233a1018c5e8d036f35f862d3c243.jpg

7475b3d1461acad8c6adbfd77581152c.jpg
2638ca4af58641af895cfc5861d47164.jpg
1ebc0ddf5102d19892f222cdd1dc3964.jpg
49df2e7ecb1aa993a6dbc8cdfd146454.jpg
555bdb26b42619358ebb95a67ab2dbae.jpg
57cc2ba730c94724170c96dc30f49a86.jpg
4dda0ee8ceaf5d1bfe51d61d959bdc23.jpg
7ab3c43d360a758c58fd0211f384d366.jpg
b30f6d83690755310e16aa36c38a7f4a.jpg
4ce0a2f6b00e4a3ddb08ef421eb74fe4.jpg
76a652ee2265ea66bcac133ede58efa2.jpg
38ca425bed64249ec50fdab3a9c59edc.jpg
91ddcc6c5fec866401d91a800cd3b8bc.jpg
dba542f3ed6141d7e9bde076bb5c9511.jpg
914b9d34a60eaadb378196ba647360a5.jpg
5971ab6fb890d95e4d1059d1be925caf.jpg
48c3ba16dc8f1f70ebb98e2461b14109.jpg
df60e39961b8ad931600a3b93d761b55.jpg
93db097fddbb7ce9f0ec1582a344f64d.jpg
2c6edec14bb213105511d73373caa73c.jpg
5e0e18340a9025f6afce8f055c51c411.jpg
9ad4f816a1324403dea35086a6810f8b.jpg
 
Last edited:

tom_cat

I'm Pretty Popular
4/7/13
1,071
34
48
Thanks for the review mate. 904L indeed looks whiter than your 1665 and polar. Brushing looks prominent on ARF too. Congrats and wear it in good health.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

macarone

Put Some Respect On My Name
Patron
Certified
7/3/17
5,099
2,983
113
CONUS USA
Congrats Beautiful watchI’ll just sit and wait for a reserved sale![emoji23]


Don't Mind Me, I'm here for complications!
 

m5smg2

Put Some Respect On My Name
Supporter
Certified
23/8/07
5,999
7,601
113
Congrats Beautiful watchI’ll just sit and wait for a reserved sale![emoji23]


Don't Mind Me, I'm here for complications!

Haha. We see we see [emoji6]
 

IceBear454

Known Member
14/5/17
102
0
0
Bloody gorgeous! Thanks for sharing these great photos. For me, it's not worth waiting for the V2 roll of the dice. This looks too good. I'd be more than happy.
 

benZman

You're Saying I Can Sell?
15/6/17
32
3
0
Thx for this great review, I must order this amazing watch...
 

thestefster

Active Member
Patron
9/6/11
488
82
28
Looks great. mine arrives next week. cannot wait. Going to wear it for a few months and if I love it as much as I think I will, the order is going in for a gen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Devinthedoc

unicornpad

Known Member
1/1/15
140
15
18
Looks utterly brilliant, amazing how ARF can pull this off.

If only my wrist isn't so small I'd nick this one off from a TD instantly, patiently awaiting for ARF to drop a submariner
 

efthimis

Mythical Poster
20/6/15
7,122
3,037
113
Hey bro thank you for the pics and review! How big is your wrist? Just to understand the size better...
 

IceBear454

Known Member
14/5/17
102
0
0
This is a big watch. The SD4K and GMT fit my 6.5" flat wrist perfectly, as does the 40mm Explorer. The 40mm Explorer II overhangs my wrist. The DSSD is large and top heavy. From everything I've seen topside, a 7+" wrist is really the minimal size for a good proportioned fit. That said, I wear a TWCO Salvage Diver. It's got a 43mm case and a 51mm lug-2-lug and it fits well and comfortably because of the moderately dropped lugs. Rolex tend to have flatter lugs so even though I lust after this, it might not wear as well as I'd like.