• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

XF New AP Royal Oak 15202 Releasing Soon!

Phantomtech

I'm Pretty Popular
28/12/12
1,424
214
63
Hi guys , just got my QC pictures from PureTime
not sure what to do not to happy with screws and date alignment but definitely need a second opinion.
is it ok if post QC pictures here?

If you have a specific question about it then yes.
 

fire007

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
1/3/13
2,950
232
63
On my opinion if we think at the price difference is a is a stunning watch!

My watchsmith did a service to a gen perpetual 25820 and he gave me the chance to take a photo of the two watches side by side... of course they are two different watches but they have the same size case!

Thank you so much for this pic, Prof 2AR ordered...
 

RockerArm

Known Member
2/10/19
180
89
28
EU
you're right, and that's true for every good reps.
nevertheless, in the case of the 15202, the Daytonas, and the 5711 you are more owning an invest value than a watch that is 100 times better than the rep ...

Yes of course, you are right, but on my opinion this is a wery sad news for watch lovers like me!

The constant rise of prices in some watches is only because the 'investors' are buying that watches for 'investor-porpouses' and not because they love watches!
Probably they are not even interested in what they had bought, they joust buy and save!

At the opposite, love watches and not the value they have!
​​​​​
 

India Whiskey Charlie

Getting To Know The Place
14/5/19
51
13
0
The constant rise of prices in some watches is only because the 'investors' are buying that watches for 'investor-porpouses' and not because they love watches!
Probably they are not even interested in what they had bought, they joust buy and save!​​​​​
Yes, this is quite true. I also happen to know some people who love watches but will only buy models that appreciate rather than those they really like. For example, someone likes a white dial 5711 but goes for the blue because that's what everyone else is buying.
 

Erinoush

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
10/7/19
1,174
617
113
UAE / EUROPE
Yes of course, you are right, but on my opinion this is a wery sad news for watch lovers like me!

The constant rise of prices in some watches is only because the 'investors' are buying that watches for 'investor-porpouses' and not because they love watches!
Probably they are not even interested in what they had bought, they joust buy and save!

At the opposite, love watches and not the value they have!
​​​​​

that really what the "hot" watch market is at the moment and it is a petty for real passionate people like us, you're right...
 

nikemok

Getting To Know The Place
28/6/13
16
11
0
Can just somebody make a REAL GEN VS REP post ?

I think I saw somebody said he has a real 15202 here, why somebody just send him his REP to make a comparaison ?
 

Phantomtech

I'm Pretty Popular
28/12/12
1,424
214
63
O mister " there is no bezel issue " :laughing:

I'm not sure how that is a response to my comment?

But I guess I will just say it again in case you didn't understand the first time, go ahead and buy the rep and send it to a gen owner to make a comparison. Or do you just think you can come on here with zero contributions (10 posts) and just tell other members to do the hard work for you??

And btw, there is no bezel issue.
 
Last edited:

lolo1972sg

Respected Member
Certified
3/10/15
3,595
333
83
Sillypore
I think we are all too fussy. Just buy the rep, do a proper QC, shave the hand pinion (probably only mod needed) and wear the hell out of this watch, folks.
 

AndrewTE94

Getting To Know The Place
30/12/19
18
0
0
Hi guys, I'm new to this forum. Just ordered the XF AP 15202 from the TD here. I had given GL for the QC. I'm wondering if the screws are too close to the bezel edge? And is the DW okay? Last question, is the movement okay? The amplitude falls to 249 which is out from the acceptable range at the last second. I'm interested to hear other opinions from you guys. Please refer to the pictures and video below. Thanks.

https://picr.me/image/VHs7ls
https://picr.me/image/VHshQq
https://picr.me/image/VHsSSG
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATJfPKGTV9k&feature=youtu.be
 

bunny123

I'm Pretty Popular
Gold Patron
Certified
18/7/18
1,352
1,134
113
If you have a specific question about it then yes.

thank you.

please just have a look at the pictures I have also marked the concern in one of them. also I never received a video of the movement working shall I ask for that as well?

https://clickpix.org/image/W8lII
https://clickpix.org/image/W81UR
https://clickpix.org/image/W89Q8
https://clickpix.org/image/W8YxL
https://clickpix.org/image/W8nfK
https://clickpix.org/image/W88hv
https://clickpix.org/image/W8rn1
https://clickpix.org/image/W8tuj
https://clickpix.org/image/W8QZ4
 
  • Like
Reactions: Neo_7

bunny123

I'm Pretty Popular
Gold Patron
Certified
18/7/18
1,352
1,134
113
W8lII
 

Phantomtech

I'm Pretty Popular
28/12/12
1,424
214
63

That one screw doesn't look that bad to me to be honest, because I know at wrist distance it will not be noticeable. I am more concerned about some screws being too close to the edge, my watch does not have this issue so I would not accept this...
 

pinprinz

Do not accept unsolicited offers
26/1/19
4
0
0
May I ask for expert advise for whom order XF version.
This are my QC pic. Do they have any obvious issues?
Thank you very very much.

IMG-1271.jpg

IMG-1270.jpg

IMG-1269.jpg

IMG-1268.jpg

IMG-1267.jpg

IMG-1266.jpg

IMG-1265.jpg
 

rayz20

Renowned Member
29/6/17
577
152
43
Keep in mind its a digital photo with high contrast white lite so yeah.

Yes, tiger mentioned something really important.
Many people always compare their rep with rendered 3D model images, which is just not realistic.
Even if you have a gen and compare it to a digitally rendered picture, then it’s still a difference in color and perfection overall.