-
Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!
XF New AP Royal Oak 15202 Releasing Soon!
- Thread starter jtimewatch
- Start date
looks very promising. Will XF release by any change a 15450 or maybe one in bicolor?
Sent from my ANE-LX1 using Tapatalk
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey there. I actually like it very much. I don’t like most comments though. Truth said, the very people that lambast this new release have probably never tried to produce anything themselves, let alone subcontract parts design, production and assembly. I’d really love to see what they get to achieve in reproducing, say, a simple Coca Cola glass bottle. I’m sure they will get the curvature and thickness right but then the bottle opening will go terrible wrong and they may even miss an “O” here and there. But who am I to judge
- 28/2/17
- 2,390
- 1,960
- 113
If i tried repping a coke bottle id be pretty bloody happy if it was water tight. If i spelt things right with my sharpie set, well thats just a bonus!
BIONONE
Respected Member
- 28/4/17
- 3,637
- 2,833
- 113
There is a function where you can mention a member without quoting numerous pictures and texts for a off topic question.
regarding your question - why should they? Is there a demand? Does anybody else rep it? Pretty sure JF will be your savior - maybe not for two tone but for several dial colors in steel.
now let‘s keep on track.
- 3/6/14
- 14,556
- 5,848
- 113
It is a little of a chicken and egg thing. Look at the rep ROO sec@12 movement. It IS unreliable compared with the rest of the rep movements out there, and there is a limit to how much the reliability can be improved, because no modder or watchsmith out there has changed the fundamental design. But yet, this does not stop the market from buying them up, and I think that the rep ROOs have evolved to relatively popular models in the hobby. Over time, due to its market popularity and feedback, the factories have done minor improvements to the movement along the way.
This movement is of course at this stage a complete unknown until there are enough pieces in the market and over a substantial sample size and period. Only then are we able to assess the movement reliability over a period of time, as opposed to sporadic anecdotal accounts of how a movement is running for 40hrs, and another stops within a day of working.
My unscientific guess is that the movement will not stop anyone who is interested in purchasing this release. The design, dial, case and other features will sell the watch. The non-quickset date is a novelty which will convince some fence-sitters to give this a try too. A lot of guys in this hobby can afford to write off the watch price as "a folly of experimentation", trust me.
Look at the A7750 sec@12, 6 and 3 movement models. They sold and will continue to sell despite the widespread knowledge that the movements are "unreliable". This model will be no exception.
So except for purists, the movement of this movement will not pose a central concern to those wanting to take the plunge.
SuperLory
Well-Known Repist
- 22/10/15
- 8,462
- 5,055
- 113
what about this shade of blue - is it gen like?
and here’s the unedited image:
and here’s the unedited image:
Last edited:
Well... "here I am!" ...I'm one of the people who ordered this watch "closed box" with no idea how reliable the movement will be, or how many visible flaws it will have!
Sincerely I don't like the position of the screws on bezel, too near to the outer border, and of course this is a very noticeable flaw watching the magnified photo on the 15" screen of my laptop, but I think that in the "real life" this shouldn't be a big issue! ...and even if I think that I will find some other issues to be improved I need to see this watch in my hands!
Actually my supplier told me it is having some delay in the shipment because the producers are delaying the release... I will keep you updated!
Hidenjoy
Renowned Member
- 8/9/15
- 710
- 252
- 63
I know it is a rough comparison but it might give you a good impression of the differences. Dont know how to add images here, so there are the links
https://clickpix.org/image/h58N4
https://clickpix.org/image/h5B1c
https://clickpix.org/image/h5tKI
https://clickpix.org/image/h56Bj
It is slim, the print looks good, the measures seem to be right, the dial looks great, the date font seems more accurate. Of course a couple flaws are there - obviously the movement looks better in the JF, but you know, who cares. I am wondering, they say it is 30M water proof. Can I go swim with it?
https://clickpix.org/image/h58N4
https://clickpix.org/image/h5B1c
https://clickpix.org/image/h5tKI
https://clickpix.org/image/h56Bj
It is slim, the print looks good, the measures seem to be right, the dial looks great, the date font seems more accurate. Of course a couple flaws are there - obviously the movement looks better in the JF, but you know, who cares. I am wondering, they say it is 30M water proof. Can I go swim with it?
Last edited:
BIONONE
Respected Member
- 28/4/17
- 3,637
- 2,833
- 113
BIONONE
Respected Member
- 28/4/17
- 3,637
- 2,833
- 113
Well... you can measure it via MSpaint and then take a guess regarding the case construction and THEN you will get the answer every other member could give you at this point.
... but seriously - are you really asking such a question only a few days after the web release with the hope of a definite answer? Come on...
Kitosarg
Known Member
- 13/7/18
- 167
- 90
- 28
This watch, Salmon dial. i hope they rep it some day.
- 25/3/17
- 4,317
- 3,811
- 113
Well... you can measure it via MSpaint and then take a guess regarding the case construction and THEN you will get the answer every other member could give you at this point.
... but seriously - are you really asking such a question only a few days after the web release with the hope of a definite answer? Come on...
I ask 3 questions
rayz20
Renowned Member
- 29/6/17
- 577
- 152
- 43
This any better? Photo shop on a phone isnt as easy as on a desktop!
Agreed.
Photoshop should be used on a Desktop PC haha