I have been looking for one of these ever since I heard about them. Today, after a long jounery and a close call with customs, I got one.
First up, Submariner's is my favourite subject. I've been rep collecting since around 2002 and playing with gen Subs since 2004. I cannot even remember how many rep or how many gen Subs I have bought ad sold, it's a lot. I keep them anything from 6 months to a couple of years. I have a lot of experience with the 5 digit Submariner. In my opinion, I'm qualified to say what's a good and bad rep Sub.
This TC (despite the obvious red hand and negative DW) is the best 16610 rep I've had. It's better than the discontinued JF and current ARF by a long way in my opinion.
I always look at crown guards, they are never right on any other 5 digit Sub rep, but this TC has nailed it! Wow, those are near perfect gen like CG's! The crown guard is missing a little angle line where they slope away from the case but this can be polished away or softened on a refurbished gen a lot of the time and it n be added by brushing the case so no matter. The case is great, if a little sharp around the edges, I can fix that, it needs chamfers on the lugs which I can fix too.
Amazingly, the crown and bezel action are very gen like, the crown more so than the bezel but both are great. The crown in particular screws with a smooth tight thread just like gen, without gritty threads. It turns the rong way to set the time but that's because it's a ETA not clone 3135. Dial is really lovely with embossed fonts and the hands look pretty good too. The tube is very slightly different. Crystal is a little bit too high. The rehaut on the TC is not quite as deep as the gen and I detect the gen is ever so slightly more angled/wok than the TC maybe this is an illusion because the TC rehaut has a shorter wall, but the TC rehaut appears to be ever so slightly more vertical than the gen I'm talking fractions. I have a gen crystal to fit, this may alter the appearance of the rehaut. The insert is pretty poor, it's alomst rounded/contoured around the edges, it should be flat. The pip is not perfectly centered in the triangle.
The bracelet has numerous flaws. First it feels very light and cheap around the clasp. The claps blades are too wide and the middle parallel strenghthing lines are too narrow compared to gen. The endlink midlink have too much of a high step and they are elongated. On a plus, the bracelet has very good crisp and clear gen like stamps that you dont get on JF or ARF (or others).
Summary
The bracelet isn't fooling anyone but a newbie (if that) however the watch case set is fantastic and is the best 5 digit Sub I have owned. This one is a keeper. I'll put gen insert, bracelet, crystal, crown and tube, that'll be the project for now, later it may get a 3135 gen or clone and dial etc.. Very pleased with this.
Pictured with 2004 gen 16613.