• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

New PPF 5712 with PP240 Super Clone.....

benissimo

Known Member
3/6/21
120
75
28
EU
I think is demand, I'm not sure in China people really like speedy. Remember rep forums like this makes up a very small percentage of the entire rep watch market.

Sent from my SM-N976B using Tapatalk

Exactly, also Speedmaster is relatively cheap in gen compared to Patek or AP, anybody who really wants it can save up and just get a gen, it will be worth it.
 

philwongnz

I'm Pretty Popular
27/1/14
1,798
660
113
Exactly, also Speedmaster is relatively cheap in gen compared to Patek or AP, anybody who really wants it can save up and just get a gen, it will be worth it.
That's what I thought too, except you can get rep Longines, which I do know is a popular brand in China.

Sent from my SM-N976B using Tapatalk
 

benissimo

Known Member
3/6/21
120
75
28
EU
That's what I thought too, except you can get rep Longines, which I do know is a popular brand in China.

Sent from my SM-N976B using Tapatalk

Yeah but they all use A2824 movement, which is cheap and proven, developing a clone chrono movement from scratch is on a whole different level. Just look how long it took them to make a proper Daytona clone movement, and Daytona is one of the most popular watches ever.
 

philwongnz

I'm Pretty Popular
27/1/14
1,798
660
113
Yeah but they all use A2824 movement, which is cheap and proven, developing a clone chrono movement from scratch is on a whole different level. Just look how long it took them to make a proper Daytona clone movement, and Daytona is one of the most popular watches ever.
I hear you, but still odd they rep Longines when they are pretty cheap.

Mate, you don't need to tell me about Daytona, been buying reps for over 10 yrs, waiting so long for the cloned 4130 and waited another 2 yrs before I started getting V3, now I have 11 of them haha

Sent from my SM-N976B using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: benissimo

X24222

Known Member
12/1/22
181
93
28
USA
Curious — what would it take for you to get comfortable with the cloned 5712 movement? What would make you consider it sufficiently “vetted” in order to buy (like the 4130 now)?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

philwongnz

I'm Pretty Popular
27/1/14
1,798
660
113
Curious — what would it take for you to get comfortable with the cloned 5712 movement? What would make you consider it sufficiently “vetted” in order to buy (like the 4130 now)?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Watchsmiths says the movement is reliable. I waited V3 for the daytona is not just the movement, but also the flaws of V1 and V2 exterior like the bezel font is wrong.

Sent from my SM-N976B using Tapatalk
 

X24222

Known Member
12/1/22
181
93
28
USA
I don’t have the history, but in v1 through v4….did the clone movement get upgraded in each iteration (due to reliability issues surfaced by the community or watchmakers), or was it mostly the non-movement elements in the various versions while the movement was unchanged?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Teamjlf

I'm Pretty Popular
9/9/19
1,697
4,182
113
Replica oblivion…
Exactly, also Speedmaster is relatively cheap in gen compared to Patek or AP, anybody who really wants it can save up and just get a gen, it will be worth it.

People are buying rep moonswatches….
the whole point of buying reps is the price point. Although cheaper than Patek and AP, even cheap abused gen speedmasters are still out of reach of most of us, hence we spend inordinate amounts of time trawling rep sites and purchasing reps.

What is happening now though is that the reps are becoming tiered based on the original they are repping. The $4-500USD common pricing has been smashed and we are now seeing more and more models in the $USD 700-1000 bracket.

Even the reps are now getting out of reach for many…..
 

chewy824

Getting To Know The Place
18/7/14
76
55
18
People are buying rep moonswatches….
the whole point of buying reps is the price point. Although cheaper than Patek and AP, even cheap abused gen speedmasters are still out of reach of most of us, hence we spend inordinate amounts of time trawling rep sites and purchasing reps.

What is happening now though is that the reps are becoming tiered based on the original they are repping. The $4-500USD common pricing has been smashed and we are now seeing more and more models in the $USD 700-1000 bracket.

Even the reps are now getting out of reach for many…..

With all due respect, if one cannot afford a 700 rep, his watch screams REP even if he wears a gen.
 

jm_brc_7057

I'm Pretty Popular
9/4/19
2,538
1,873
113
Scandinavia
My point is that there has been price gouging in the last 12-18 months with reps. What was a decent $USD 450 rep not that long ago now sells for $USD 500-600+

Inflation. Materials, workforce, marketing. Everything is getting more expensive. Reps can’t keep their prices when everything else is getting more expensive.
 

Erinoush

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
10/7/19
1,172
617
113
UAE / EUROPE
Inflation. Materials, workforce, marketing. Everything is getting more expensive. Reps can’t keep their prices when everything else is getting more expensive.

I would see it in a different way...
People are paying 100+K for a gen 5712 why nodding when you can get the same stuff for still less than a 1/100th of its price....
 
  • Like
Reactions: ywg and jm_brc_7057

Teamjlf

I'm Pretty Popular
9/9/19
1,697
4,182
113
Replica oblivion…
Inflation. Materials, workforce, marketing. Everything is getting more expensive. Reps can’t keep their prices when everything else is getting more expensive.

Indeed- but don't forget this is a clandestine / illegal market industry where those standard economic forces don't apply in a regulated fashion...Many of these factories ( and TD ) will charge what they like, when they like and how they like.... The biggest driver here is our appetite and subordination to the high prices. Ce La Vie........ Its still cheaper than buying the Gen- but like I said - its creating a hierarchy even within us Rep buyers with the more affluent able to buy the top level reps v those only able to afford the lower level reps. The whole point of the rep stuff was to make it affordable to almost everyone.... The point here is the gap between average and Super Rep and NWBG is getting huge now..... bigger than its ever been.
 
Last edited:

jm_brc_7057

I'm Pretty Popular
9/4/19
2,538
1,873
113
Scandinavia
Indeed- but don't forget this is a clandestine / illegal market industry where those standard economic forces don't apply in a regulated fashion...Many of these factories ( and TD ) will charge what they like, when they like and how they like.... The biggest driver here is our appetite and subordination to the high prices. Ce La Vie........ Its still cheaper than buying the Gen- but like I said - its creating a hierarchy even within us Rep buyers with the more affluent able to buy the top level reps v those only able to afford the lower level reps. The whole point of the rep stuff was to make it affordable to almost everyone.... The point here is the gap between average and Super Rep and NWBG is getting huge now..... bigger than its ever been.

You are right about the lack of regulation etc. I think the point for the repmakers is to make money. If they can divide their market in two categories, they will. Because the margins will be bigger at slightly bigger expenses. I think a rep like the 5712 will give them big margins once their development expenses for the clone movement has been covered.
That’s their motivation.
 

addingwatch

Known Member
27/2/07
134
34
28
also noticed an increase in 5712’s available in M2M.
is the new version announcement impacting current inventory selloff?

Yes, I noticed the same thing. Could be a huge drop in value when the new one comes out.
 

philwongnz

I'm Pretty Popular
27/1/14
1,798
660
113
also noticed an increase in 5712’s available in M2M.
is the new version announcement impacting current inventory selloff?

It will be interesting, for example if the crown sticks out like the current version and also some other visual flaws, a modded 5712 might not have drop much....