I know, it’s always a rabbit hole when you start modding watches. I’m not here to flash watches on the gram
but I do wear a couple of reps in rotation with my gen Rolex watches. Im interested I light mods, mostly to please my own ocd
Ive never had a gen AP, and I’m just now starting to branch out from Rolex. I wanna test drive a couple of models, before investing in a gen (just had a couple of weeks with the 15500) I wanna do a bit of modding to give the watches a fair chance before I move on, or go gen.
On for example a sub, I always do gen crystal, DW If needed, hands and a bergeon block brushing. After that treatment it’s pretty much indistinguishable imo.
i would love to hear your list of flaws on this particular model, and what mods you would do yourself. You have a wast knowledge, and are definitely one of the go to guys on AP and PP
Honestly, what I always tell guys who come see me in person, is that if you just want a nice watch to wear, buy a rep. If you are serious collector, get the gen, keep it BNIB, and wear the rep anyway. So you see there is always room for reps no matter which category you belong :hehehe:
What matters is not whether the watch is 1:1 or otherwise, but how you feel wearing it. Some guys are happy slapping on a stock old V3 diver on the wrist and call it good, and others like your good self may need more to satisfy your sense of ownership. Ultimately and indisputably, each of us wants that feel of wearing a branded or luxury watch on the wrist without having to pay the full price for it. It is a salient aspect of the hobby nobody here can deny, and the difference is the amount of mods one needs to get there.
If I am asked to build a stainless steel diver for myself, this is what I will do. There is no right and wrong, and I am merely sharing my personal preference.
- I will get the movement and datewheel from the XF ceramic diver, a 2836, swiss or asian doesn't matter.
- cyclop can either be retained from the new version, or I will opt for Mikey's one. I have not studied it
- Dial, I prefer a gloss finish myself (There are at least 3 variants in the gen 15703)
- Dive bezel I will opt for the latest one, with the proper borders around the lume. It is NOT perfect vs gen, but will serve perfectly in real life
- Low beat conversion will be done to bring the movement frequency to 21600bph and a movement service and regulation will be performed at the same time
- Bezel screws will be polished, aligned and refined
- hands will be polished and relumed if necessary (I did not study the details to say for sure)
- case and bezel will be rebrushed to gen spec (personal preference, not for visual accuracy)
- caseback will use an i series one if not already
- watch will be waterproofed
Now with the above done, will watch be 1:1? No, it obviously will not. But will it make me happy wearing it in real life? Absolutely. I will appreciate the details of the above modded watch if worn in real life. Therein lies the significance of owner satisfaction, vs needing something 1:1 (which is a synonym for gen if you think about it). There is always a line to draw for each owner on what he can accept and what he cannot, and hence it is a very subjective matter. What makes me happy for the same watch may be inadequate for one, and excessive for another. Learn your own preference, and sometimes, what others like can serve as a point of reference for you too. I do have a collection of about 20+ unworn BNIB Rolex and Patek in my collection, but I never feel the urge to wear them myself. When it comes to wearing watches, AP is the go to brand for me. This is another area where owner preference comes into play, and I like your approach of using reps to test drive what you like in your gen collection.