Ok, I was wrong. It was another guy replying to me on another ad telling me the item was gone (not watch related).
This guy finally replied to me and was very excited about my email. I offered $3000, and he jumped at the chance. Yikes. I met up with him publicly at a Tim Hortons (coffee chain in Canada) and tried to videotape the whole thing. I apologize for my horribly bad video skills.
I won't bother describing anything here. I'll let you watch the vids.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b37KFpz-ExU
EDIT: Changed non-working embedded videos into links.
EDIT2: Created youtube video as 1 video instead of 4. Hope it's in the right order. lol.