Ok, I got it. Wasn't able to get him to budge, his watch buddy said he should be getting $2500 for it minimum so I paid $2000 and promised to buy my next Audi from him. This almost didn't happen like 6 times... don't think I'm ever going to sell it. Found a micro welder who specializes in titanium and he will fix the knick for nothing basically. Assume a jeweler can clean up some of the other scratches. Picking up the boxes, straps and everything else tomorrow... will probably sell a couple straps if anyone wants the calf skin or maroon croc!
Thanks for everyone's help... hope I still got some value here. Feels great to add a gen to the collection. Ill post more pics later and as I clean the watch up.