• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

CALIBRE DE CARTIER JJF VS Gen side By Side

D

d4m.test

Guest
anyone know if the RG is close to authentic or should one just stick to SS?
 

mskwatch

I'm Pretty Popular
12/3/15
2,291
414
83
EU
Blue compared to black is not very accurate.
It is very different from the gen.
Bezel is a completely different color
nobody will ever notice, haven't seen many blue around even at ADs
myself I am really tempted by a blue on bracelet or a blue FF
 

cuba-2013

Active Member
22/4/13
443
17
0
Montreux (France)
I agree that many people will not notice this.
But 99% do not even know about this model, and in general most people do not know much about watches, not to mention the number of brands and models that exist at the moment.
Usually when you buy a watch for yourself, I want the color to match all the same, I personally like to wear watches that look the most like a Gen.
Especially in the last few years, production has gone very far ahead and there is plenty to choose from.
 

Exklusive

I'm Pretty Popular
28/6/15
1,246
185
63
I had the blue JJF in mind but when I went to take a look at the AD, I decided to get the black instead. Blue tone is indeed off...
 
D

d4m.test

Guest
Nice comparison, the differences are hardly noticeable even for a trained eye.
 

peterpl

Respected Member
Supporter
Certified
24/7/11
4,714
675
113
so is it confirmed 8215 or 9015? 23J usually means 8215 which means stuttering and the seconds completely stopping when flicking the wrist.
 

Exklusive

I'm Pretty Popular
28/6/15
1,246
185
63
so is it confirmed 8215 or 9015? 23J usually means 8215 which means stuttering and the seconds completely stopping when flicking the wrist.
It comes with 23J movement and very noisy. Feels like metal and rocks grinding lol. Not ideal for a quiet environment. But after sending to watchsmith for oiling of bearing and rotor, it will solve this issue.
 
D

d4m.test

Guest
e691d4b87b40591c7a4472c075fa9883.jpg


Gen feeling, very accurate and beautiful. Very comfortable on the wirst. Noise rotor, some lub later will be perfect.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hi, your watch looks great! Wear it in good health :) I'm anxious to know if you got rid of the noise from the rotor?
 

tphan

Active Member
4/10/15
278
6
18
I'm still trying to get my movement fixed. According to Stordda, running to problems.
 

tphan

Active Member
4/10/15
278
6
18
What issues are you having with the movement? Its A23J.
bout it from TD and had issues right away so i sent it of to get it fixed. also came with 2 missing screws on the back which the TD sent me.
bezel was uneven but i took that apart and snapped it back in to secure it
loud manual winding
rotor is not working
so according to strodda.
"I have a feeling some or maybe all of that metallic sound you're hearing is the spring itself. This movement winds in a way I've never seen before. The rotor beating has an off center post and that post sits inside the center of the jewel. As the rotor turns, it shakes the center of the wish one and causes the teeth on the ends to move back and forth, making the ratchet wheel turn. Very poor design, IMO."
 

Exklusive

I'm Pretty Popular
28/6/15
1,246
185
63
bout it from TD and had issues right away so i sent it of to get it fixed. also came with 2 missing screws on the back which the TD sent me.
bezel was uneven but i took that apart and snapped it back in to secure it
loud manual winding
rotor is not working
so according to strodda.
"I have a feeling some or maybe all of that metallic sound you're hearing is the spring itself. This movement winds in a way I've never seen before. The rotor beating has an off center post and that post sits inside the center of the jewel. As the rotor turns, it shakes the center of the wish one and causes the teeth on the ends to move back and forth, making the ratchet wheel turn. Very poor design, IMO."

Geez, so many issues. Mine had loud rotor noise and I got my watchsmith to lubricate, noise level went down about 50%. Apart from that, everything else was ok. I hope you can get yours fixed soon. Its a nice looking watch.