Advice on First Replica Watch – Tudor Pelagos FXD

[PeteAlipi]

Hey guys,

Sorry if this question has been asked a lot — I’ve read quite a bit but I’m still not totally sure. I’m looking to order my first replica watch. I haven’t seen the genuine version in real life, but I really love the design. I’m especially interested in the Pelagos FXD, including the GMT version.

The thing is, I’ve come across quite a few comments saying that the dials on the replicas are noticeably off in color compared to the gen. Since I’m not a watch expert, I’d really appreciate your input.

Based on your experience, which version would you say is the most accurate? I truly like the watch and would love to wear it, but I’m wondering — is the difference from the gen really that noticeable?

Thanks a lot in advance for your help!

 

[PeteAlipi]

I also found another Red Bull model and now I am not sure at all..

 

[Hesekiel]

I personally like the FXD M.N. and, to my own surprise, the GMT.

The "closest" to GEN FXD is the black one, which I personally find the most boring.
The M.N. has proper colors, but the white indices on the dial and the bezel differ a tiny bit in color.
The GMT's main flaw is the position of the date window, as it's too far inward.

All that said, in real life, on the wrist, all of the FXDs are great watches that will pass as GEN unless scrutinized close up by somebody in the know.

P.S.
If you like the styling of the Red Bull, go for it. That watch doesn't resonate with me. Its main flaw is the material of the replica.

 

[Reaps]

Buy the black if you're worried.

But you'll find soon enough noone cares about watches, muchless a niche non Rolex dive watch that few people have own or seen in real life.

 

[PeteAlipi]

Thank you very much! And from which factory should I get it — M+F?

 

[PeteAlipi]

Just one question — is the movement on this watch loud? Maybe someone with experience can share?

 

[Reaps]

Read this thread

 

[Reaps]

REVIEW - M+F Pelagos FXD MN vs GEN - loads of pictures

REPOSTING REVIEW I PUT ON REDDIT Today I give you my first review of a new-ish release, the M+F Tudor Pelagos FXD Marine Nationale. I've owned the gen for over 3 months, and it's been a quasi daily wear for me – needless to say, I love this watch. With this rep coming in, I wanted a proper...

forum.replica-watch.info

Tudor FXD

Hanging out for this! I wonder how long it’ll take to get repped. or maybe I should get gen…

forum.replica-watch.info

And read guide in my signature.

M+ the only choice.

More research less spoonfeeding

 

[PeteAlipi]

Read this thread

thank you very much! A great review! Better can not be!

 

[Warwickhunt]

Just one question — is the movement on this watch loud? Maybe someone with experience can share?

I am daft enough to have the blue one and the black one, also have a Tactical Frog Solar version of the Red Bull rep that has 3 working subdials. I plan on getting the GMT eventually. I don't find the automatics that noisy but it's worth bearing in mind that the early versions have the cheaper Miyota 8N24 with the crown stem problem. My blue one snapped the stem in about 3 weeks of ownership and is currently getting a movement replacement. The Black one hasn't given me any problems so far but if it does I'll get the movement replaced on that too as it's the only rep in town of this model. The later versions have the tried and trusted NH34 movement so go for that on if you have the choice. Don't be put off it's a great rep!

 

[PeteAlipi]

I am daft enough to have the blue one and the black one, also have a Tactical Frog Solar version of the Red Bull rep that has 3 working subdials. I plan on getting the GMT eventually. I don't find the automatics that noisy but it's worth bearing in mind that the early versions have the cheaper Miyota 8N24 with the crown stem problem. My blue one snapped the stem in about 3 weeks of ownership and is currently getting a movement replacement. The Black one hasn't given me any problems so far but if it does I'll get the movement replaced on that too as it's the only rep in town of this model. The later versions have the tried and trusted NH34 movement so go for that on if you have the choice. Don't be put off it's a great rep!

some of the dealers said to me there is only Miyota 8N24, are you sure there is NH34 movement?

 

[chrisat]

If you just want a watch with fixed lugs, consider the Tactical Frog. It's a fun watch that is much more substantial than the pricing would suggest (I recently paid 140 Euro including shipping and taxes).

The M+F rep is optically closer to the gen, but also not perfect. Also keep in mind, that the gen has a proper 4Hz movement, while the rep comes with a slower 3Hz movement.

 

[Warwickhunt]

some of the dealers said to me there is only Miyota 8N24, are you sure there is NH34 movement?

You can only read what I read, they are all made by the same factory

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/100...=scene:pcDetailTopMoreOtherSeller|query_from:

If the TD's are telling you different, maybe that's what they're selling.

 

[tejoskave]

There is no nh34 version. Tactical frog and the rep uses slightly different cases, the crown is not aligned with the crown guards and sits a little lower on the rep version. Nh34 and 8n24 does not have the same measurements anyways.

 

[Warwickhunt]

More info for everyone - thanks

 

[chrisat]

There is no nh34 version. Tactical frog and the rep uses slightly different cases, the crown is not aligned with the crown guards and sits a little lower on the rep version. Nh34 and 8n24 does not have the same measurements anyways.

I believe the Tactical Frog case also has a slightly smaller diameter than the M+F (it is smaller than the gen for sure).