• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

ZF Master Ultrathin Moon

timnic54

Respected Member
16/2/16
3,409
1,253
113
Thailand
Having a discussion is fruitful But I think we should take comments based on photos only and photos of two watches not taken together in the same conditions with a pinch of salt , they can be very misleading and should not be considered in any way conclusive judgement .
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Gatsby

bpbp

Renowned Member
14/12/13
931
206
43
USA
0afd05b34e7dbccca494b9f653255f24.png




SWen from my iPad using Tapatalk
do anyone know how to get register that forum? I try to register , always tell me they not allowed for register now. ,
 

Naimnaci

Getting To Know The Place
22/6/18
47
9
8
Comment from a user on r/reptime :


Sorry guys. I'll take the heat for pointing out some tells. JLC reps are easy to spot, and this one has several. See the last two pics in the imgur, and focus on the moon subdial, hands, printing, and markers. OK, here we go:

* Blue seconds hand has stains, which is impossible on this model unless it took a dunk in the ocean. It seems it's a poor paint, which means poor paint jobs will continue to flake and oxidize.
* Printing on "AUTOMATIQUE" should be flat, straight, and sit above the guilloche.
* Printing of days of the month (1, 2, 3... 30, 31) are (sorry fam!) bad. Several numbers bleed over the edge like Dali's Persistence of Memory. Spacing between the dates and dots is inconsistent - sometimes a bit left (see right of the 13), other times centered (between 23 and 12), but they mostly skew left.
* Man. This one cannot be unseen. Check out the minute markers, especially the 7 marker. It's dirty either from oxidizing or just dirt. It, along with several others, are 'lifting' from the dial - they should be flat and have an absolute mirror finish.
* "SWISS" is incorrect font and the ink bled a bit making the letters blobby. "D" in MADE is too fat.
* Took a quick look at the movement. The balance cock (the arm that holds the balance wheel) is just wrong. See gen, about half way down: [http://www.jaeger-lecoultre.com/us/...es/master/master-ultra-thin-moon/1368420.html). You'll see the balance cock has a cut out for a blued screw, and two small pin holes, which hold down the arm to a plate. This is not present. Owners will spot this immediately imo.

**Anyway... I think we need to let the factories know these things. They actually listen to their buyers, and can make adjustments. It's a fun hobby. But, the finishing on this one needs work.**

I took delivery of the watch yesterday, swiss made the writing outside the criticism I will not participate, the only mistake I see is swis made printing mistake
 

timnic54

Respected Member
16/2/16
3,409
1,253
113
Thailand
Every one I have seen says “SWISS” in all the appropriate places Including the one I have You must have been unlucky Any photos you can post ?
 

timnic54

Respected Member
16/2/16
3,409
1,253
113
Thailand
Just wondering what the strap lengths are for this watch in the normal strap size? I know widths are 21/18mm.. any help would be much appreciated!

6.0 - 6.5” wrist (150 - 164mm) = 120/70mm
6.6 - 7.0” wrist (165 - 178mm) = 125/75mm
7.1 - 7.5” wrist (179 - 190mm) = 130/80mm
7.6 - 8.0” wrist (191 - 203mm) = 135/80mm
8.1 - 8.5” wrist (204 - 216mm) = 140/85mm
8.6 - 9.0” wrist (217 - 229mm) = 145/90mm
 
G

Guest

Guest
Can someone confirm the rep strap and spring bars are curved?

I'm looking to get the RG version and on InTime it looks straight.

I'm in the middle of ordering a brown Gen strap from JLC for the RG version (reference 1362520).

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
 

Naimnaci

Getting To Know The Place
22/6/18
47
9
8
Can someone confirm the rep strap and spring bars are curved?

I'm looking to get the RG version and on InTime it looks straight.

I'm in the middle of ordering a brown Gen strap from JLC for the RG version (reference 1362520).

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

intime Pink does not appear in gold
 

RobSe1

goes Deepsea
Supporter
Certified
23/6/17
2,093
2,102
113
Has the RG no deployment clasp? There is „only“ a normal pin clasp on the pics..
 

RobSe1

goes Deepsea
Supporter
Certified
23/6/17
2,093
2,102
113
Toro has one RG in Stock!!! If someone is searching ;) but be quick!
 

mech500

Mythical Poster
6/4/12
8,253
3,601
113
UK
I understand it, but it's a bit strange, what's the point of selling like maybe 10-20 watches and then discontinue? :confused:

Maybe they only sold 10-20 on the forums but the real business is outside the forums. Maybe they build a custom batch of 10000 for an investor in Asian .... and Sold only a handful on the forum?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

MarksandSpencer

Active Member
24/4/17
348
78
28
Maybe they only sold 10-20 on the forums but the real business is outside the forums. Maybe they build a custom batch of 10000 for an investor in Asian .... and Sold only a handful on the forum?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I know it is hypothetical, but where might that investor plan to sell those watches? I doubt the average Joe buying reps in market stalls would be prepared to pay $200+ for a rep, which is why I'm curious.
 

VIV54

Renowned Member
13/12/17
688
393
63
Maybe they only sold 10-20 on the forums but the real business is outside the forums. Maybe they build a custom batch of 10000 for an investor in Asian .... and Sold only a handful on the forum?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's possible but not probable. And another thing that I don't get is why they tell to TDs that a new batch is coming next week while they already know they discontinue it?:confused:
 

RobSe1

goes Deepsea
Supporter
Certified
23/6/17
2,093
2,102
113
It's possible but not probable. And another thing that I don't get is why they tell to TDs that a new batch is coming next week while they already know they discontinue it?:confused:

Is it definitely confirmed they discontinue the production? or is it only possible...? Hmm :///

Maybe they make only s few more batches before they stop?
 

joyjoyk

Known Member
10/3/18
135
60
28
Well the post says that it may be discontinued.. it also could very well be continued. Glass half full!
 

mech500

Mythical Poster
6/4/12
8,253
3,601
113
UK
It's possible but not probable. And another thing that I don't get is why they tell to TDs that a new batch is coming next week while they already know they discontinue it?:confused:

I don’t know man....Angus said that forum buyers only make 5% of factory sales. Which means 95% factory stock is sold elsewhere.

The factories are all about money. They will not develop a new release to sell 10-20 reps.

They could have sold a large batch to an international dealer and signed an “exclusivity of sales” agreement with that dealer. Hence factory won’t sell the watch to anybody else until (for example) the dealer has sold out his stock. This type of arrangement is not unusual in business.

Who knows, the Dealer could be selling these as gens.....or at a much higher rate. People won’t suspect anything if the market isn’t flooded with these reps.

Anyways, I’m just guessing man.





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJ2020

VIV54

Renowned Member
13/12/17
688
393
63
Is it definitely confirmed they discontinue the production? or is it only possible...? Hmm :///

Maybe they make only s few more batches before they stop?

What I was trying to say is that in my opinion it's really weird that they discontinue soon after they release it, especially when they tell to TDs that a new batch is coming.

But honestly the replica world never ends surprising me, in a good and bad way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJ2020

VIV54

Renowned Member
13/12/17
688
393
63
I don’t know man....Angus said that forum buyers only make 5% of factory sales. Which means 95% factory stock is sold elsewhere.

The factories are all about money. They will not develop a new release to sell 10-20 reps.

They could have sold a large batch to an international dealer and signed an “exclusivity of sales” agreement with that dealer. Hence factory won’t sell the watch to anybody else until (for example) the dealer has sold out his stock. This type of arrangement is not unusual in business.

Who knows, the Dealer could be selling these as gens.....or at a much higher rate. People won’t suspect anything if the market isn’t flooded with these reps.

Anyways, I’m just guessing man.





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes maybe you are right, but how many times has this happened in the replica world? Look for example at Noob factory. For years they produced the best submariners which is the holy grail of replica watches and they never discontinue it nor signed exclusivity of sales. They improved it with new versions V5, V6, V7...

I'm just trying to analize the situation logiìcally but I can be totally wrong.
 

RobSe1

goes Deepsea
Supporter
Certified
23/6/17
2,093
2,102
113
can´t believe they stop it after putting that much effort in this Watch and Movement...But that exclusive thing and selling some thousands to an international Dealer could also be true.
Fuck i hope we all get our Order....after that they can burn the rest down hahaha :evil:
 
Last edited: