whatever choice you will end up taking, you will have to sacrifice one thing from the other version, there is no perfect gen like rep PP Nautilus in the market, unless you want to buy different versions and make your own. even then you will still not have the correct everything.
what I am doing, I got the Miyota version, the quality the feel the overall finish is great, a but noisy for a Patek, but I have to live with it. what I couldn't live with is the thin hour minute hands, so I purchased a 21J cheap Nautilus version for $90, and used it as a donor for the hands. now it's with the modder to have them installed. with this I get the best there is in the market.