There's a whole host of people who know nothing about this rep world and take these listings at face value (my parents included) so don't be too harsh on the birders.
In the past I've contacted winners through eBay and told them they've bought a rep. They take it to an ad, confirm it's fake, raise it with paypal and in the end get their money back. They're usually glad of the contact!
I get your point, but is it not the perogative of the bidder to try everything 'before' bidding or winning to try and confirm authenticity? Even if they are completely novice about the whole setup regarding ebay and replicas then the information is freely available on the web. A little bit of research on the product before throwing down 1k+ is just common sense. Even if they don't want to do it themselves its not difficult to find a watch forum on the web that would do it for them. I feel sorry for those that get caught with very good pics of high quality frankens, I have to say I'm losing a lot of sympathy for those that jump into crap pic auctions and blinding throw down 1k+ just because they think they might be getting a deal. Do they even research actual prices before jumping in? If personally never seen a PO go for below £1K, in fact prices on ebay are nearer £1.25-£1.5K. In fairness the price it goes at should not dictate legitimacy...but it should be another red flag! Just an observation!
True plyman its really easy to get your money back through pp. EVEN IF THE SELLER DOES NOT ACCEPT RETURNS paypal hold the money in sellers account for 30+ days or until you leave + feedback, if the seller refuses return paypal will go into there account and return the money to you by force, its pointless putting accept no returns these days ,and as a seller always send your post by a recorded option as this is also a scam link from the other end YOU HAVE TO SEND WITH A RECORDED OPTION to meet paypal terms and conditions. As a seller and a buyer been fleeced both ends.
POINT HERE ALWAYS USE PAYPAL FOR BUYING OFF NET NEVER PAY AS A GIFT (REMOVES PROTECTION) AND ALWAYS SEND ITEMS WITH A RECORDED SOURCE.
I'm not 100% sure and correct me if i'm wrong but afaik paypal don't have anywhere near that power! They are not an escrow service and once the money clears in the paypal seller account it can straight away be taken out to CC or Bank Account (clears a few days after payment). After that paypal/ebay cannot just go into an actual bank account/credit card and withdraw the money....they are not visa and are not capable of chargebacks or such powers.
I thought that the bulk of their powers are in providing a refund out of paypals own pockets if the seller is completely unresponsive. That is all they are capable of. Yes they can black mark the seller account on ebay/paypal but the cant hold or recover any money. The fact is I wouldn't have much confidence in paypal if I was a buyer. Once payment has been sent then the burden of proof switches to the buyer who has to provide all sorts of detailed information that you tried everything to contact seller and return item At the end of the day yes we might be entitled to compensation from them but the amount of hoops and bullshit one has to jump through to get that 'payment protection' is a pain in the neck and the vast majority of people wouldn't want to go through it a 2nd time. Just my 2c, but the onus is on the buyer to do the research in the auction before jumping in because anything after money is parted with it, it is a nightmare.