1)I would say no, but it looks borderline to me. Why would I have asked if it looked obvious to me?
2) I don't understand what the age of the post has to do with anything. I posted a 2 year old watch I'm looking to buy from another member. I'm assuming the issue with the two would not magically resolve itself over time, as we forget about the problem.
P.s. I admire your work. I wish other brands has such a comprehensive, well stuctured guide.