So I just received my Black Bay blue shield and I like it a lot. In the dark there is no lume mismatch, in the light the hour and minute hands appear they may be a slight bit more yellow/greenish than the indices, but honestly once it has been in the sun and the lume is charged, that may be the biggest reason for that color difference. I really couldn't get that difference to come across well in a pic. Aside from that everything is great with the watch. When I have access to my calipers tomorrow I can measure how thick it is for sure. Here are two quick shots with my old phone camera.