• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Movement Quiz

Drulee

Renowned Member
7/5/09
648
0
0
Oh, yeah, it's their mistake, not yours, Dru. I didn't mean that to sound like I didn't believe YOU. Sorry for any confusion.

Well it's hard to accuse you of calling me a liar when you've got that .45 pointed at me :err:

No confusion, I just posted the link just in case members wanted to see the source of the pic (so they would know not to trust everything posted there) - as I certainly wasn't expecting that site to post pics of a rep.
 

Fiddo

Mythical
Patron
Certified
16/2/09
7,995
3,761
113
In a Causal Loop
Well it's hard to accuse you of calling me a liar when you've got that .45 pointed at me :err:

No confusion, I just posted the link just in case members wanted to see the source of the pic (so they would know not to trust everything posted there) - as I certainly wasn't expecting that site to post pics of a rep.

I thought it was a gen based off that as well. The quiz was fun....was educational as well!
 

Drulee

Renowned Member
7/5/09
648
0
0
I have a question about B, for those with some 6497 knowledge. It is actually a pic taken from a sales thread over on RG. The seller had stated that the movement was genuine, but didn't mention that the shock assembly had been replaced with a Swiss one. It also seems that another wheel or two are Swiss replacement parts, not Gen.

So what I would like to know, is how can one tell the rest of the movement is actually gen. Is it just the top pate decorations, and the decorations on the base, that you are looking at to tell it apart from rep movements?

Also, what would you suggest I do to my movement (E), to make it closer to one found in an 036?

And thanks to everyone who participated.

I thought it was a gen based off that as well. The quiz was fun....was educational as well!

Glad you enjoyed it.
 

babola

I'm Pretty Popular
19/9/06
1,660
79
48
First of all, whoever did mods on the 'F' mov't - big thumbs up, good work! It would have fooled most of the hard-core peeps 'in the know' of these things.
What gives it away as a non-Soprod hi-beat mov't is the 17.6bph drive train. I should have taken a better look.

BTW, there's no such thing as DSN-mov't, he sources his mov'ts from the same wholesale supplier as the rest of the rep factories folk. ;-)

A - nothing more to say, really.

B - isn't Swinesse or Chiss or whatever the hybrids are called today, it a good old ETA Swiss mov't with decorated/engraved bridges, nothing else was added to the base ETA-6497-1 17.6 ebauche here. This particular mov't is very sought after by Panerai rep collectors, including myself. If I could source few more of these I'd be all over them.

C - pure Asian 6497 rep mov't. No Swiss parts in it at all. I have few of these as well.

D - Swiss ETA hybrid, base ebauche is Swiss ETA 6497-1 (17.6bph)

E - Swiss ETA ebauche 17.6bph, with standard Asian decorations

F - Great work! Whoever did it.

G - Swiss ETA ebauche 17.6bph, with standard Asian decorations

H - Swiss ETA ebauche 17.6bph, with standard Asian decorations

I - pure Asian 6497 rep mov't. No Swiss parts in it at all. The person that posted this on gen forum either didn't know he bought a 'dud' or has a big b@lls ;-)

cheers!
 

Drulee

Renowned Member
7/5/09
648
0
0
First of all, whoever did mods on the 'F' mov't - big thumbs up, good work! It would have fooled most of the hard-core peeps 'in the know' of these things.
What gives it away as a non-Soprod hi-beat mov't is the 17.6bph drive train. I should have taken a better look.

BTW, there's no such thing as DSN-mov't, he sources his mov'ts from the same wholesale supplier as the rest of the rep factories folk. ;-)

A - nothing more to say, really.

B - isn't Swinesse or Chiss or whatever the hybrids are called today, it a good old ETA Swiss mov't with decorated/engraved bridges, nothing else was added to the base ETA-6497-1 17.6 ebauche here. This particular mov't is very sought after by Panerai rep collectors, including myself. If I could source few more of these I'd be all over them.

C - pure Asian 6497 rep mov't. No Swiss parts in it at all. I have few of these as well.

D - Swiss ETA hybrid, base ebauche is Swiss ETA 6497-1 (17.6bph)

E - Swiss ETA ebauche 17.6bph, with standard Asian decorations

F - Great work! Whoever did it.

G - Swiss ETA ebauche 17.6bph, with standard Asian decorations

H - Swiss ETA ebauche 17.6bph, with standard Asian decorations

I - pure Asian 6497 rep mov't. No Swiss parts in it at all. The person that posted this on gen forum either didn't know he bought a 'dud' or has a big b@lls ;-)

cheers!

I only put DSN down, as the pics are from his site, and I figure when you see DSN you think rep. :)

B. is actually a genuine movement (or so the seller and his watch smith say), with a Swiss shock assembly put in. It was part of a franken (rep case and crown?) 036 that just sold on RG.

F was part of a franken that sold for 1k on RWG (?)

You seem to know your movements :) What would you suggest I do to E, before using it for my 036 project?
 

babola

I'm Pretty Popular
19/9/06
1,660
79
48
I have a question about B, for those with some 6497 knowledge. It is actually a pic taken from a sales thread over on RG. The seller had stated that the movement was genuine, but didn't mention that the shock assembly had been replaced with a Swiss one. It also seems that another wheel or two are Swiss replacement parts, not Gen.

So what I would like to know, is how can one tell the rest of the movement is actually gen. Is it just the top pate decorations, and the decorations on the base, that you are looking at to tell it apart from rep movements?

Also, what would you suggest I do to my movement (E), to make it closer to one found in an 036?

Well that person wasn't telling the truth, and to be honest it's easy to fool 95% of rep collectors when it comes to these mov'ts and variations.

The only thing 'genuine' about that mov't is that it's based on a Swiss ETA 6497-1 17.6 mov't ebauche, before Asian factories swapped the bridges with the decorated ones. That's the ONLY Asian bit added to this mov't, so even though it isn't gen Panerai/SOPROD mov't it's still the one I would love to have ticking in my Panerai rep.

The way to tell the bph diff is to look closely at the hour wheel teeth, the faster one will have more teeth which will look more denser along the edge of the wheel. This is one of the trademarks of a faster ETA6497-2 mov't, over the 6497-1 one. Also the 6497-2 mov't on its own (if you can find one anymore that is) used to be priced retail in excess of $450, while 6497-1 under $100.

To answer the second part of your question about E mov't...not sure how far you wan't to take it, but it will have to be quite a lot done to it to make it close looking to 'F' one for example.

- Main wheels lack bevel, and preferably blued screws (but the latter isn't a requirement as gen Panerai used to come with both in the past)

- bridge plates are still glued-on, so are 99% of other square-plate rep mov'ts , so best to leave them as is

- metal ring (circle) around the anti-shock jewel assembly shouldn't be solid/full

Other stuff is just fine and OK.

cheers!

B. is actually a genuine movement (or so the seller and his watch smith say), with a Swiss shock assembly put in. It was part of a franken (rep case and crown?) 036 that just sold on RG.

Only the bridges on the B mov't are/could be the genuine, I could agree that much with that person's statements.
Everything else including the drive train is standard non-Panerai Swiss ETA 6497-1 slower 17.6bph, as well as the escapement as you mentioned.
 

Drulee

Renowned Member
7/5/09
648
0
0
Well that person wasn't telling the truth, and to be honest it's easy to fool 95% of rep collectors when it comes to these mov'ts and variations.

The only thing 'genuine' about that mov't is that it's based on a Swiss ETA 6497-1 17.6 mov't ebauche, before Asian factories swapped the bridges with the decorated ones. That's the ONLY Asian bit added to this mov't, so even though it isn't gen Panerai/SOPROD mov't it's still the one I would love to have ticking in my Panerai rep.

Well that is a bit disturbing, as he claimed it as genuine, a supposedly trusted watch smith (no longer, I guess) backed him up on his sales thread, when I questioned the solid plate on top of the shock assembly. And the watch sold, apparently for the asking price of $3,000

The way to tell the bph diff is to look closely at the hour wheel teeth, the faster one will have more teeth which will look more denser along the edge of the wheel. This is one of the trademarks of a faster ETA6497-2 mov't, over the 6497-1 one. Also the 6497-2 mov't on its own (if you can find one anymore that is) used to be priced retail in excess of $450, while 6497-1 under $100.

Thanks for that information,. I figured it had something to do with the number of teeth on a wheel, but wasn't sure which one or what the diff would be.

- Main wheels lack bevel, and preferably blued screws (but the latter isn't a requirement as gen Panerai used to come with both in the past)

Great, I've got spares of both the beveled wheels and blued screws (some with silver slots, some all blue) :)

- bridge plates are still glued-on, so are 99% of other square-plate rep mov'ts , so best to leave them as is

I actually have another identical movement, which the bridge plate is separating from. I was going to put a dab of glue and push it back down, is there something else I should do?

- metal ring (circle) around the anti-shock jewel assembly shouldn't be solid/full

Yeah I know about that big flaw, but haven't found an easy way to get around it. I did find some Swiss movements with the correct plate/ring, but didn't want to risk prying off the engraved decorative and transferring them over.

Only the bridges on the B mov't are the genuine.
Everything else including the drive train is standard non-Panerai Swiss ETA 6497-1 slower 17.6bph, as well as the escapement as you mentioned.

Wish I knew who the buyer was, as from the looks of it he may have just been ripped off. What I don't understand is why the "extremely trusted" watch smith would backup the seller, saying it is genuine :(
 

alvinado

Watch Nerd
Advisor
27/8/08
6,009
677
113
Asia
F was hard.... I saw very good plates on it ... but the 17600bph and the incabloc gave it away!!!