• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

HWF 724 Review - an affordable maritime Luminor (pic heavy)

JayBee0815

Repoholics Anonymous
Patron
Certified
20/1/21
9,327
28,068
113
Heart of Europe



If you like the classic Bettarini case of the 44mm Luminor and would like to have a Pam with a light maritime flair and blue notes, the Pam 724 is a good choice. It was released in 2016 along with the Luminor 1950 models 727 and 732 and the 725 and 726 chronographs as part of Panerai's sponsorship of the America's Cup sailing regatta. The 724 has been released in two series (S and T) of 200 pieces each. The Gen is equipped with manual Movement P.5000, which should provide eight days of power reserve. As a Rep, it was already released by ZF. But these copies are rare. One of the proud owners is my friend thenut , who provided me with some pictures of his ZF 724 for comparison. This year, HWF has reissued the 724 and brings it to the market for the comparatively low TD price of 288 USD. This is reason enough to take a closer look at this watch.

Dial

The dial of the 724 is a black sandwich dial with white/yellow numerals and indices with green lume. The special feature of this model is the blue "America's Cup" lettering, which harmonizes with the blue second hand. Interestingly, the "pam-typical" rather average AR ensures that the black dial takes on a dark blue tone when exposed to direct light. This completes the maritime character.







HWF has done a good job with the colors. The printing is clean and crispy but compared to the Gen, the lettering seems a tad too thick. These are minor things though. More problematic is the typical HWF problem: The numbers and indices are punched out too thick! This may not be so dramatic in the detailed view. But when you look at the whole watch, it changes the character. This can be seen very well in direct comparison with the ZF, which performs much better here.









The lume is good, both in terms of luminosity and hue.

Hands

The hands are really well made and both the shape and the color are indistinguishable from the Gen without a microscope.



Case

Yes, I'm still "shape-blind" ????For me, the HWF case looks flawless. Even in direct comparison to the HFac 229 and the EL 063c, which are high quality replicas of the Bettarini models, I see no notable differences. Only the lugs are "turned" differently - but this is hardly noticeable when the strap is mounted.




























The workmanship of the case is good, if there were not a really annoying thing: On the bottom side, HWF apparently simply "forgot" to thoroughly deburr the edges on my copy. A small spot on the lower edge is as sharp as a razor. This can be repaired with a sanding pad without much trouble. But if you don't notice this quirk, you could end up with a cut. This flaw is certainly not a problem with the entire series. But it shows how sloppy the quality management is at HWF.



Caseback

The caseback is neatly made and - oh wonder! - even correctly labeled. The motif in the center is even milled out and has a clear embossing. It looks great to the naked eye ... but you should rather leave out the magnifying glass or the macro. Because if you take a close look at the milled edges, you get an idea of why the HWF is $288 and the Gen trades for over $8,000. Interestingly, at least on the photos, the caseback of the HWF looks even better than that of the ZF ... but that can be deceptive, of course.







Movement

There is no clone for the P.5000 and in this case, it's not that important anyway, since the watch has a closed back. HWF uses a normal manual A6496 movement without decoration. Of course, it doesn't have eight days of power reserve, but it's a solid workhorse and if something should happen, it can be replaced for little money. That's ok.

Crown and Crownguard

Again my shape blindness takes effect ;-)
It all looks ok to me.











Straps

Since I have my justified reservations against rep straps, I had already asked the strapmaker papaheia to make me a proper strap in the look of the Gen strap. The result is excellent. However, I also have to admit that the HWF strap is not that bad for a rep strap. Of course it is thin and stiff. But it is neatly modeled after the Gen Strap and in terms of quality better than some rep straps from much more expensive reps from VSF or HFac.



Summary

The HWF 724 is one of the better reps from HWF. If HWF would finally get a grip on the too thick cutouts for numerals and indices, this rep would be a really good alternative to the more expensive reps from other manufacturers. If you like the design of the 724, you can buy it without any problems. You get a solid rep for a fair price, which you will have a lot of fun - as long as you do not cut yourself ????




 

thenut

Renowned Member
Supporter
Certified
28/2/17
520
489
63
Germany
Wonderful Review, many thanks!

Additional information:
The ZF Used to come with Stated P5000 super Clone movement. Mine died after a few months, a few weeks after Service it brokes again and my watchsmith switched the movement for an Asia 6497.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JayBee0815

JayBee0815

Repoholics Anonymous
Patron
Certified
20/1/21
9,327
28,068
113
Heart of Europe
Wonderful Review, many thanks!

Additional information:
The ZF Used to come with Stated P5000 super Clone movement. Mine died after a few months, a few weeks after Service it brokes again and my watchsmith switched the movement for an Asia 6497.

Yes, thats "funny". As long as they dont give you "Gen-like" features or a longer PR Clone-Movements in a watch with solid caseback are a sometimes a troublemaker ;-)
 
  • Like
Reactions: thenut

papabear244

Renowned Member
17/11/20
527
157
43
Thank you JB! It looks indeed one of their best. The crystal also looks ver clear.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: JayBee0815

sonatlas

Do not accept unsolicited offers
8/10/19
9
2
3
That blue pops! Looks great, but I wonder why they weren't able to exactly color match the purplish hue of the gen.
 

JayBee0815

Repoholics Anonymous
Patron
Certified
20/1/21
9,327
28,068
113
Heart of Europe
That blue pops! Looks great, but I wonder why they weren't able to exactly color match the purplish hue of the gen.

You mean the "America´s Cup" Print? I think the picture has a wrong colour correction. Photos from the Net are not suitable for those comparisions. It depends on the light (natural/artificial) and the digital post processing. On other pictures of the Gen the blue looks very similar to the blue from the HWF or the ZF.
 

KOT1917

Respected Member
Section Moderator
26/7/19
3,389
5,501
113
Russian federation
Thanks for another review!

I wanted to point out a few points that seem important to me.

Differences in the form of a case for 8 day movt.,(usually 6937, but I guess 7139 won't be different) and 6497 (for example last 6834) perhaps they have not such a noticeable difference in thickness (about 1mm), but a difference in proportions (case 8 days has more beveled edges of the pillow, thanks to which it seems thinner, thinner lugs, more vertical bezel with a wider chamfer at the base).
Here is a photo of 2 gen for an example:
(lower is 8 days)

And when ZF made their models with the P.5000 clone, they tried very hard to convey this (Their cases were noticeably different from the standard 6497). You can see this well on the example of old models that simultaneously produced both ZF and V6F (For example PAM511 or PAM564)

(I understand that the photos are not very good, but this is what I could find now quickly, and the difference in the shape of the lugs and bezel is visible anyway):
Also, another advantage of the ZF was the absence of the lens or "fisheye" effect on the crystal, which should not be present on HW bettarini models with in-house movt., whether P.5000 or P.6000:
V6F in their "V2" corrected a lot of the shortcomings, and made a new case, which later used the XF for some of their models (I'm not talking about the modern XF, this applies, for example, to the old XF PAM000 which was produced around 2017), but in general, PANERAI set a significantly higher price for 8 day models, tried to make them slightly different than 6497, and ZF tried to convey this as much as possible, V6F was able, but not immediately, and not to the full extent, while HWF is apparently closer to V6F, and did not begin to convey the specifics of this generation of bettarini models.

Otherwise, everything is not bad, except for bold cutouts and bold fonts.

Nice design, good caseback (although the thickness of the polished circle on the edge is not very good), but still it's not the level of rivalry with the gen that ZF showed.

(Just in case, the link to the review from which I got photo 511: https://forum.replica-watch.info/forum/panerai/289188-pam-511-kw-v2-vs-pam-511-zfac-review-pic-heavy)