I guess it all depends on what you are expecting, a $50 watch for $30 is fine by me. Often not my style, but I can just give them to other people or there are some donation services that you can donate watches to the less fortunate. I just like the surprise of seeing what comes. I don't expect a $200 watch for $30.
I signed up for the Black tier to see what I get. I love reps, but there is nothing wrong with lower end gens either. I only plan to do the black every 3 months or so instead of every month.
The facebook group I had to leave, just a bunch of idiots on there.