• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

DHGate Mini Review: Rolex Cellini

thegolfman

Known Member
1/6/20
150
94
28
TL:DR - Rating. Classic DHGate. Poor quality but a great value for what it is (Quartz). Would be a perfect “beater” but that it’s a dress watch. Hmmm.


Price: $18.76
Delivery Time: 20 days


One of the observations I had early on in my Rep journey was that I didn’t own a dress watch (gold on leather variety) and I simultaneously thought, why not see what one of these cheap quartz versions are all about? And for $18, I knew what I would more than likely receive. I wasn’t wrong.


A couple things about this watch
  1. The dial is designed similarly to the Gen, but instead of a date complications, it adds a small seconds hand. No competent Rolex owner would ever mistake this for anything but a Rep.
  2. The Gen dial always struck me as both interesting and very classy. It’s enjoyable to look at and clearly presents a dress watch orientation that is both classy and refined. As far as this Rep goes, much of the “look and feel” of the Gen dial has been preserved. It is in no way perfect, but it is enjoyable to look at and yields much of the same sense of satisfaction as does the Gen. In a word, it’s pretty.
  3. The strap is horrible. Enough said, I already replaced it with a slightly better strap. Don’t buy this and expect to get any real value from the strap. It is a 20mm and easily swapped out at least. If I owned one high end strap, it would be on this watch and very likely allow it to punch above its weight.
I do like this watch, however, and part of me thought it could be used as a beater day in and day out, but it’s almost too dressy to get away with that. I wouldn’t see this as being useful on the golf course, or heading to the supermarket, as it just doesn’t fit those environments.


Is it a good date watch? Probably. It is likely going to get noticed…it has a shine without the added bling that could be somewhat impressive (with the right strap) at arms length.


One of the things I didn’t know that I would appreciate is how easy it is to wear. That’s more of a function of me never owning a dress watch, though. It’s very light (watches can be light…?) and quite thin allowing it to be a very comfortable wear. It’s very good as an alternative to a tool watch as a simple change of pace. I wear this in the 5 watch rotation and welcome the easy wear each time I put it on.


This watch also makes wearing it (no winding, no resetting the time to start the day) less complicated and low friction. I definitely didn’t appreciate this factor in making a buying decision, but it does add to its wearability and getting out the door quickly (not that we do that like we used to).


Overall, it’s a cheap DHGate version of a very attractive Gen that might be implemented poorly, but is, in fact, a pretty nice watch that is almost free to own.






On to the ratings:


Fit and Finish: 4, The watch is clearly cheap to hold and examine, but it does excel once on the wrist as a dress watch. It does what it is supposed to do easily and is definitely a step in formality up from my other watches. Strap replacement resulted in a mandatory 1 point deduction. It looks better than it feels.


Legibility: 7, Easy to read, sometimes I think it has stopped due to the ticklng of the seconds hand, but onward it goes. The dial has no lume so, like other dress watches, it has its limits. I do like this dial a lot, so it could be the only dress watch I care to own (for now, of course).


Comfort: 8, Light and thinner than I’m used to. Easy on/off and almost makes you forget you’re wearing a watch.


Wearability: 7, Slightly better than an average wear due to it’s size and light weight. The dial is a healthy 40mm so it has a lot of real estate, but wears small.


Value: 8, As I said previously, this watch is almost free, particularly if you own another strap that would fit. It’ll be the cheapest watch I own for a long time. I would give this watch away to someone if they liked it in person and feel like I made someone’s day.


Overall: 6.8
 

KJ2020

Time Traveler
Supporter
12/3/18
33,282
61,061
113
Nice review bro. You should at least look at Reg's listings (Narikaa). For a little over $100 and free shipping you could at least play in the minors instead of little league, hehe.
 

thegolfman

Known Member
1/6/20
150
94
28
Nice review bro. You should at least look at Reg's listings (Narikaa). For a little over $100 and free shipping you could at least play in the minors instead of little league, hehe.

Did not know that...will look into this. I am super happy with my Trusty Aqua Terra...and I thought this experiment gave me a look at the whole spectrum. It was actually hard to see the quality of the Gate through reviews, so I thought I'd TOFTT and provide some context to readers. I'm basically $200 into this experiment and I like what I've found so far. My worst case is I have some watches to share or bust open and learn more about movements.

I'm sure many have done this already and learned something. I'd speculate that, at least with my Air-King, I'm probably seeing where QC failure go when they get rejected by buyers. Who knows, but it is still like getting a small win, when one out of several work out...so far, I'm feeling like I've won more than I've lost...we'll see though...

Thanks for the tip too!
 

KJ2020

Time Traveler
Supporter
12/3/18
33,282
61,061
113
There are some OK things to be grabbed at the gate, it's something a lot of us do once or twice.

I bought this one but it was nothing like the pics.

15610988278090.jpg


I still might pick up this quartz Montoya Skelly Daytona, even though its 42mm. Sometimes we just like what we do!

https://m.dhgate.com/product/2019-t...h-vk-quartz/490438800.html#cartitem-null-null

Your writing is excellent. Looking forward to seeing more.

https://forum.replica-watch.info/forum/eyecandy-wristshots/321673-dhgate-collection
 

thegolfman

Known Member
1/6/20
150
94
28
There are some OK things to be grabbed at the gate, it's something a lot of us do once or twice.



Your writing is excellent. Looking forward to seeing more.

https://forum.replica-watch.info/forum/eyecandy-wristshots/321673-dhgate-collection

Many thanks! Took a little soul searching to decide to both buy and review my Gate purchases. It seems like it's a well travelled road but sometimes it feels like a lesser part of the online communities for some reason. I prefer to think about collecting Reps as a bit of a portfolio play...there should be some value items to go along with your blue chippers...nothing wrong with some measured risk taking I suppose.

I also think some that tried this over the years probably were burnt early on with 1-2 crappy watches and that would discourage anyone. I feel like I'm on a roll with four above average buys and a couple I'm still thinking about...I think I need to test the waters with a ceramic Daytona and possibly a dress PP. We'll see...
 
  • Like
Reactions: gilrob and KJ2020

thegolfman

Known Member
1/6/20
150
94
28
Just changed up the strap for something more casual/autumnal. Actually looks more distressed in the pictures, and does a pretty good job at making the watch a little more informal. Nice quality strap too. Have a rose gold clasp on order...probably will have over $50 invested in this Rep by the time I'm through!
 

Maro-JAPAN

Horology Curious
11/8/20
22
0
0
My goodness!
It's looking more and more like a great watch.
Maybe it will continue to tick precisely, by the oscillation of the crystal.