• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Budget Ali-E 16610 Submariner Case Review

johloo

Renowned Member
14/3/17
786
227
43
Here's a show and tell of one of these budget 16610 Sub cases for 3135 that's been popping up on across the webs and recently one in a build on m2m. I first seen these on ebay earlier last year and then recently on good ol' Aliexpress for a whopping $35 so I splurged a little and scooped one up to to do some scientific rep research; not sure if there is already a review on this but I haven't seen one so below are my findings and dissertation.

Overview
Case is a rep of an M serial 16610 Submariner with rehaut engravings + no lug holes and made to fit 3135 movements; I used a VR 3135 for this build. Case also came with the rubber protective casing. EDIT to add that dial and hands were not included with the case, those were from my private reserve
ZW3b9f.jpg

ZW3iEd.jpg


Bezel
The bezel construction is the typical lower end style wire retention and not gen construction but is still 120 clicks, minimal lateral play and clicks actually feel nice and smooth. The insert is thin an although it uses a 3M double side adhesive to stick onto the bezel unlike gen snapping into place, the markings on the insert is actually pretty decent, compared side by side with a gen and it doesn't look too bad. I did try a gen spec insert on the bezel ring and it does snap nicely in place. The pearl pip is also the crappy nipple ones, I swapped it out for a busted JF one and the insert instantly looks overall much better.
ZW3QAq.jpg

ZW3UCs.jpg

ZW3vqy.jpg

ZW316X.jpg

ZW3IMG.jpg

ZW3JTp.jpg

ZW3zba.jpg


Crystal
I forgot to take pics of the crystal while it was off the case but interestingly enough the crystal itself appears to be gen spec though it is mounted on a very thin gasket that is then just pressed into the case, unlike gen that would be held in by bezel retainer ring. No AR and the date magnifier cyclops and it also has a 'LEC' that isn't entirely accurate or in perfect 6 oclock position relative to cyclops. Mine also came with a complimentary little scratch by 1 oclock area.
ZW3c86.jpg


Movement Fitting
The case is a direct fit for 3135 clone movements and the movement is mounted in place gen-style where the movement screws are screwed up until it pushes into the case and holds it in place and the movement does fit pretty firmly in place once mount screws are backed into the case. However, cut outs for the mounting screws are not where gen cases have them and they are also pretty crude and doesn't leave much clearance to get the screw through though it does fit. The punch mark by the mounting screw close to stem was made by me since the screw wasn't catching the last few threads in the movement. The case also works with gen spec dial diameter 27.4mm and fits up to I believe at least 28.5mm, haven't tried fitting any larger dials. The stem hole lines up well with the movement as well.
ZW3R3h.jpg

ZW30v0.jpg

ZW3MGD.jpg


Markings
There are laser engravings between the lugs and rehaut, they aren't the greatest looking and the serial number appears both on rehaut and between lugs, otherwise the text is accurate, these are marked for ref 16610LV. Caseback markings appear a bit better looking.
ZW3eqF.jpg

ZW3sEU.jpg

ZW3xMr.jpg

ZW32T8.jpg

ZW39BI.jpg

ZW3PC3.jpg


Crown / Tube
The crown is gen spec and actually looks pretty decent as well, not too far off from the JF ones from what I can remember and the tube fits gen crown without an issue. The crown position / stem hole height also looks pretty decent and not too low like on some 2836 cases.
ZW3o8o.jpg

ZW3w4b.jpg

ZW3lvL.jpg

ZW38G2.jpg

ZW3NHK.jpg


Case back
Is gen spec and swaps with TC / JF one without issue. Also no issues with movement / rotor running into it.

Shape
The overall shape of the case isn't terrible though the lugs are a bit too wide; the crown guards also look pretty decent though can use a very slight trimming as well, imo the CG's look better than ARF / JF and definitely better than the nubs on ST cases. The case also measures slightly thinner at 12.4mm (gen 13mm) though I believe that is because the caseback appears thinner. I don't have any 93250 bracelet to try with this so can't speak to bracelet fitment etc.
Side by side with TC case on right:
ZW3Byh.jpg

ZW3Fee.jpg

ZW3SYZ.jpg

ZW3TBT.jpg

ZW3hUR.jpg

ZW378A.jpg

ZW3d4g.jpg

ZW3qyQ.jpg

ZW3LHf.jpg

ZW3HGa.jpg

ZW3XKy.jpg

ZW3teX.jpg


TL/DR + Takeaways
This case is no TC or ARF and far from perfect, but for $35, it's a pretty good value and has lots of potential for a neat little budget build.

Pros
  • 3135 movement is direct drop in fit
  • fits gen spec bezel insert
  • fits gen spec crystal (tbc)
  • fits gen spec crown
  • fits gen spec dial
  • decent shape, plenty to work with for reshaping
  • it's 35 bucks.
Cons
  • poor engraving
  • non gen spec bezel assembly / crystal mounting
  • lugs a tad bit wide
Below are some more pics, leather strap pics also show it after I've brushed down lugs to soften case shape a bit for a more aged / worn look:
ZW3aDp.jpg

ZW33YG.jpg

ZW3mUq.jpg

ZW3rNs.jpg

ZW35a6.jpg
 
Last edited:

p0pperini

Uses Too Many Big Words
Staff member
Global Moderator
Gold Patron
Certified
29/1/19
9,652
35,525
113
UK
This seems like a proper bargain. It certainly looks absolutely fine for a budget build, as you so ably demonstrate. The construction is classic BP style. Wonder if it is a BP case (but with different insert and LEC crystal)? Not sure - I think BP lugs may be a little slimmer. It'd be interesting to do a direct comparison.

Anyway, thanks for taking the time to post this excellent in-depth review. Bravo!

(And thanks for not leaving on that terrifying orange strap... lol)
 

johloo

Renowned Member
14/3/17
786
227
43
This seems like a proper bargain. It certainly looks absolutely fine for a budget build, as you so ably demonstrate. The construction is classic BP style. Wonder if it is a BP case (but with different insert and LEC crystal)? Not sure - I think BP lugs may be a little slimmer. It'd be interesting to do a direct comparison.

Anyway, thanks for taking the time to post this excellent in-depth review. Bravo!

(And thanks for not leaving on that terrifying orange strap... lol)

Yea the overall construction and feel of this case does very closely resemble the classic BP subs from what I can recall about them; forgot to mention the crystal on this does appear to be sapphire as well, not mineral crystal, so quite possibly from the same factory but with more economical parts. Also that orange strap serves the practical purpose of diversion by distracting terrified lookers from spotting the flaws on the watch and calling it out as a rep - so far no one has called out my 24k plated diamond quartz daydate when mounted on this strap.
 

FaekieOne

Active Member
18/1/22
211
152
43
Thank you! If ARF16610 needs a movement upgrade anyway (-> VR3135) wouldn't this be more cost effective for a 16610 build? I've already ordered one of these, so I will make a comparison with ARF's too. I think I will actually order one more. :D
 

johloo

Renowned Member
14/3/17
786
227
43
The fit, finish, and overall quality of the ARF is still better than this and a major difference is that the ARF bezel assembly and crystal fitment is gen construction, it's also 904L (if you can see the diff) + comes with a bracelet that matches up well with the case. This budget case definitely makes for a cost effective build so depends what the end user is going for and willing to spend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FaekieOne

alligoat

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
17/3/06
2,253
646
113
Nice write up! The only thing I would change is the bezel pearl- I'm still having good results with the watchmaterial.com pearls- they even have a nice green glow that matches the hands and dial.
 

MisterMike

This member is doing hard time, they pissed off the goat.
INMATE
23/6/17
31
17
0
This was a fun read! I think it came out very nice for the price you've paid for it. Really interested in getting a 5 digit sub myself, will probably go with ARF.
 

vcelkama

I'm Pretty Popular
Patron
Certified
14/10/21
1,028
748
113
I would be very curious to see side by side comparison review of this cheapy from Ali (likely BP?) with the ARF. Please post it here when you get it ;)

Thank you! If ARF16610 needs a movement upgrade anyway (-> VR3135) wouldn't this be more cost effective for a 16610 build? I've already ordered one of these, so I will make a comparison with ARF's too. I think I will actually order one more. :D
 

FaekieOne

Active Member
18/1/22
211
152
43
I would be very curious to see side by side comparison review of this cheapy from Ali (likely BP?) with the ARF. Please post it here when you get it ;)

I will post photos later. It's really a night and day different. ARF is way better on every way.
Yesterday I received this cheapie case and I have a ARF franken.
 

vcelkama

I'm Pretty Popular
Patron
Certified
14/10/21
1,028
748
113
Great, looking forward for it. Where did you get ARF case? Also from Ali (expensive there...) or purchased a full watch from TD?
Note: I saw ARF case on Ali for $430 while the complete ARF16610 is $488 - if anyone has a source for cheaper ARF case only I would love to buy 1-2.

I will post photos later. It's really a night and day different. ARF is way better on every way.
Yesterday I received this cheapie case and I have a ARF franken.
 

vcelkama

I'm Pretty Popular
Patron
Certified
14/10/21
1,028
748
113
Hi, any news with this comparison?

I will post photos later. It's really a night and day different. ARF is way better on every way.
Yesterday I received this cheapie case and I have a ARF franken.
 

FaekieOne

Active Member
18/1/22
211
152
43
Sorry, se have a toddler at home and lot of world etc. Time's limited now.
 

vcelkama

I'm Pretty Popular
Patron
Certified
14/10/21
1,028
748
113
Hi, still no chance to compare ARF with this lower cost case?
 

pompompurin

:3
Patron
Certified
28/7/15
6,019
5,183
113
Hong Kong
Thank you for satisfying our curiosity.

I also saw these cases on aliexpress, and they resemble the old BP 16610 cases.

BP 16610 / 16613 / 16618 cases have rehauts that are wider than gen spec (hence your minute/ seconds train tracks are floating on your dial). BP 5 digits cases use cheapass bezel wire bezel assembly (with exception to older batches of BP 16600 SA3135, but the latest batch of BP 16600 SA3135 started to use this cheapass bezel wire assembly).

The "M" serial also reminds me of what BP stamps on their 5 digits Rolex reps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJ2020