Oyster Perpetual 124300 (41mm) GEN, GM, KING, EW & BP Comprehensive Comparison

[steve_theonewatches]

Our previous WhatsApp account is temporarily unavailable.
We have switched to a new contact:
WhatsApp: + 86 135 0241 3035
Please add us using this number.

Hello everyone,

Today I’m going to bring you a comprehensive comparison of the entry-level model of the Rolex - Oyster Perpetual. In the beginning of this year, I had planned to do a comparison of the Oyster Perpetual. It is not as popular as other Rolex series, after all, it is the pioneer series of Rolex watches. If we don’t have comparison for this model, it’s a bit unreasonable. Haha.

Without further ado, let's get started.

Front Dial View

Natual Light View

Light View

Color difference is unavoidable for these color dials, so we have to see which is the closest. Through the comparison view, we can clearly distinguish the color differences between the factories. The colors of KING and EW are brighter, and their color is very similar, it seems that they use the same dial. The color of GM is a little bit darker. The color difference of BP is actually not very big, but its color looks a bit faded and lacks gloss, which leads to its overall feeling by the dial color is not very comfortable. In general, I personally think that the color difference of GM is the smallest.

Bezel View

Except for BP, the bezel shape of all factories is consistent with GEN, and the side section of the BP bezel is too thick, which makes the bezel appear a bit too large from the front.

Crystal Side View

For the chamfering and height of the side of crysta, GM is the closest to GEN, followed by EW. The chamfering of KING is too much, resulting in obvious layers, while BP is slightly lower in height.

Crown and Stick View

GM’s crown logo has the smoothest edge chamfering treatment, and the overall shape among GM, KING and EW are very similar, no big different with GEN. While BP is slightly different, mainly because of its slope width is a bit narrower.

Hands Luminous Fill View

All factories have a certain luminous graininess, there is not obvious difference for this part.

 

[steve_theonewatches]

Dial Mimeograph Front View

Relatively speaking, the regularity of BP fonts is slightly worse, and the mimeograph thickness and three-dimensional effect of other factories are similar.

Let's take a look at the opening of crown at 6 o'clock. Except for EW, the other three factories have relatively large deviations. Of course, this might caused by batch issue of the factories.

In addition, let’s talk about the dial. From the high-definition pictures, we can see that all factories’ dial is actually a grainy dial but not a glossy dial like GEN. It is just invisible to the naked eye and non closeup photos. King and EW are slightly better, the graininess is not particularly noticeable.

Hands and Middle Axis Dial

Compared with GEN, the leaking cylindrical part of the middle axis is different from each factory. Relatively speaking, GM and EW are closer to GEN. The flaw of BP is the most obvious, the hollow part in the middle is too large, and the processing is relatively rough, with obvious welding marks.

Rehaut Side View

In terms of the overall lettering shape and clarity, there is no obvious difference between the factories. If you have to score high and low, I personally think that KING is slightly better. Zoom in on the picture to see that the edges of KING’s font are more regular, and the shading is more clearer.

Crown Side View

There is nothing to say about the crown as there is no problem with the appearance and size. It feels a bit scratchy when you tough the crown of King, mainly because the teeth are not chamfered.

Case Side View

According to the past habits, usually, we don’t comment on the case, but I noticed it this time, so mentioned here. It is not difficult to find through the pictures. Compared with GEN, the curvature of the lug end of GM and BP seems to be more downward. I found that it is indeed the case by comparing with real watches. So KING and EW are naturally the winners in terms of case shape.

Caseback View

No more comments for the caseback, You friends can compare it in accordance with the photo. Steve is still in a hurry to write the next comparison, haha.

Endlink Side View

In terms of endlink, it is very difficult for factories to be completely consistent with GEN. In my opinion, as long as the lugs are not completely flush, it is within the acceptable range. Obviously, EW and BP are not good. GM is the best in this part and it is the closest to GEN, followed by KING.

 

[steve_theonewatches]

Bracelet Details View

For the engraving inside the buckle, factories are different. EW’s overall engraving lines looks more comfortable. GM and KING lack clarity, and a few small engraving dots below the ''ROKEXSA'' font of BP is missing.

Laser Mark and Lume View

Although the laser marks appear slightly different in the picture, there is no difference in reality.

KING's luminous color is different, it is more green than GEN, and the other three factories are consistent with GEN.

Movement View

GM and KING use the VR3230 movement, while EW and BP are A3230 movement which is modified and based on the 2824 movement. After all, their prices are cheaper. Compared with other factories, EW and BP have always take the cheap route, so it is justifiable to adopt the cheaper movement for these two factories.

Data Comparison View

Note: All measurements are in a clamped state, and there may be tolerance due to slight deviations in the position of the caliper.

Well, this is today’s post, thank you guys for watching, if there are any mistakes, please correct me. If there is anything else I overlooked, you can put it up, and I will try my best to do it complementary and comprehensive, welcome to comment and exchange!

I will continue to bring you more detailed comparisons between replicas and GEN, which is for you guys to better choose your favorite replicas.

(Note: Some photos deviate from the real object due to the angle of the light. The details are mainly written in text. The size of the comparison picture is relatively large. You can download it and enlarge it for comparison.)

Thanks

There is no perfect replica, only your favorite replica.

Steve

Website: http://www.theonewatches.ws

Telegram: u/Theonewatches_steve

WhatsApp: + 86 135 0241 3035

Wechat: The5711

 

[raremedium]

Great Job Steve! What would be your advise if we talk about the Tiffany dial?

 

[raremedium]

Great Job Steve! What would be your advise if we talk about the Tiffany dial?

 

[raremedium]

Great Job Steve! What would be your advise if we talk about the Tiffany dial?

 

[McDuck888]

WOW. This is gorgeous. Thank you Steve.

 

[aHero]

I’m still not convinced about the GMF bezel, having two GMFs and one EWF myself.

 

[QQ0]

I’m still not convinced about the GMF bezel, having two GMFs and one EWF myself.

Too fat?

 

[FiliGelli]

Having the king green i can say that dial color has a very nice color variation depending on light conditions.
Below two pics taken in the same place and in the same moment:

Gen is a bit darker under natural light.
I don't want to say that king is better than gen, obviously, but i personally prefer the color of the king dial.
Also the king tiffany dial seems to be brighter than gen one.
Anyway we have to consider also that these models are quite rare so it's near to impossible to meet someone who wrists a gen to have the chance to do a face to face comparison.
I'd live fearless with any color of king stock watch as in my opinion is the best one.
Bezel is superb and also the case profile is incredible.
My two cents

 

[Oydoone]

Great detailed review thanks for posting

 

[Hesekiel]

Steve,
thank you very much for taking the time and the effort to compare these watches. It has kindled my interest in a very basic Rolex which if worn on a high end leather strap could well serve as a sort-of daily / dress watch. That said, we live in a great time where the differences between GEN and replica are so small that it takes forensic inquiry. I would probably choose the GM out of the bunch.

My next order of a new rep will go to you, Sir!

 

[luftgekühlt]

Great comparison, I like the how you point out every little detail.
I fell in love with the yellow dial one, would you say the King version is the closest to gen overall?

 

[BUBEST]

Great comparison , in fact I think King and EW are very good to look at, although compared to Gen is much brighter, but at least look very comfortable

 

[raremedium]

Tiffany comparsion please!

 

[steve_theonewatches]

Tiffany comparsion please!

That would be in my plan, man.

 

[Artie Lange]

Excellent comparison, thanks. Seems like BP is the worst.

1) Can you compare the weight of all?

2) What about a silver dial comparison?

3) There are also UB, GS, and JD factories, any info?

 

[Buythedip]

Super helpful post as always! Thank you

 

[silentcut]

I think someone already requested, but yes if you get a chance please compare Tiffany dial. Really want to pull the trigger on the 41 mm. Per your suggestion i'm going to start looking for a King version.

 

[steve_theonewatches]

I think someone already requested, but yes if you get a chance please compare Tiffany dial. Really want to pull the trigger on the 41 mm. Per your suggestion i'm going to start looking for a King version.

Bro, King is currently closed, and there are plans to do such comparisons for Tiffany dials at a later date, but probably not so soon.