• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

PAM243 - Noob V2 VS. H factory ! [ PICS ]

smokiedabong

Put Some Respect On My Name
22/8/12
3,546
12
38
I've searched all over the internet and I couldn't find a direct comparison of the two so now that I just received my 243 Noob V2, I'll try to compare it with the H factory the best I can.
Disclaimer: I'm not a photographer, I don't have a light box and I'm using a cell phone camera. I don't have the skills or experience to write something like this, English is not my first language, hell it's not even my second language. I've never held the original 243 in my hands and I am no PAM expert so here it goes :

Dark strap is H factory and light strap noob factory

THE CASE: There are small differences between the two cases, the main one and clearly noticeable is the grit of the brush, you can easily tell them apart just by that. The noob case has a really fine brush, looks more sandblasted than brushed with a more matte look. The brush grit on the H case is a little bigger, not by much, but it doesn't have that matte look, it looks more metallic, shiny and rough, which I think is more appropriate for this type of watch, looks more gen like from what I've seen in the gen pics.
The noob case is cut very precise, the lines and curves are all straight, the H is not far behind but in some areas it looks a little waved, may be from the finish though.
The Winner : I'll go with the noob , seems to be cut more precise, but a noob case with H brush would look great.

IMG_20121107_163516.jpg


IMG_20121107_163549.jpg


IMG_20121107_163233.jpg


IMG_20121107_163403.jpg


IMG_20121107_163357.jpg


IMG_20121107_163332.jpg


IMG_20121107_163721.jpg


IMG_20121107_164133.jpg




THE He VALVE: To my untrained eyes both seem to have the same shape. The font looks a little thicker on Noob
The Winner: The difference is barely noticeable in real life so it's a tie
IMG_20121107_163815.jpg


IMG_20121107_164122.jpg



THE LUGS: The H has some type of bevel at the end of the lugs, something not seen on the gen. Noob has the correct shape.
The noob push buttons are a little closer to the edge which is more gen like. But here's the problem, it might have something to do with the poor rep QC, but on the H the pins and buttons worked butter smooth, on the noob however it took a fair amount of fight and I thought I'm gonna scratch the watch trying to get the pins in and out. I had to use a jewelers file to smooth out the mechanism to make it work like the one on the H.
THE WINNER : I say it's a tie, that bevel might not be to gen like , but the frustration provided by those push buttons had me all nutted up.

IMG_20121107_164314.jpg


IMG_20121107_164433.jpg


THE CASE BACK : The H has a clear, deep engraving and the metallic look helps a lot .On the noob the engraving doesn't seem so deep and the matte look doesn't help at all:

The winner: The H looks much better

IMG_20121107_164503.jpg


IMG_20121107_164528.jpg



THE CROWN GUARD: Although I had to go through 3 sets of QC pics to find this noob CG , the crown guard and lever on noob are perfect, gen like bevel where the CG meets the case, gen like shaped lever, lever perfectly flush with the GC, correct REG. T.M. engraving position .
On H the bevel isn't that noticeable, the lever doesn't have the correct shape and it's not perfectly flush with the CG . REG TM engraving is closer to the edge. The crown guard does fit a little better against the case on the H though.
The 1000m engraving on the lever does look good on both of them.
H lever does snap into place a lot better than the noob , noob has almost no snap, problem I saw a lot on these forums.
The winner : Although the H snaps into place a lot nicer and I think it does it's intended purpose of water proofing better, the noob looks so much better , so the winner is Noob.

IMG_20121107_164611.jpg


IMG_20121107_164629.jpg


IMG_20121107_164717.jpg


IMG_20121107_164757.jpg


THE BEZEL: H bezel has 120 clicks, it rotates nice with a nice sound to it but it is loose compared to the 60 click tight noob bezel. The Noob bezel rotates harder but it snaps into place with precision.
The markers and fonts are about the same.
There was a big deal about the bezel teeth having the correct shape on the noob , I can't really tell the difference in real life but indeed the noob has a more gen like shape.

The winner : Noob , looks almost the same but it rotates nicer.

IMG_20121107_164903.jpg


IMG_20121107_163342.jpg


THE PEARL: Both pearls are flat, the only difference is the size of the pearl and ring that surrounds it.
The H pearl seems spot on with what's on the T dial version of the gen.
The noob is closer to what's on the L dial . This being an L dial replica, noob is closer to gen but not quite there as the ring is smaller and pearl to big.

The winner : Tie as I've seen both sizes on different versions of the gen. H looks like the T dial , Noob like L dial.

IMG_20121106_234251.jpg


IMG_20121107_165038.jpg


THE CRYSTAL : Both single AR coated . The AR on H is a little better but only if you look really close.
The cyclops are still rep grade and both are distorting quite a bit. H has a little more distortion as it has a higher magnifying power. Noob's magnifying power is smaller and apparently closer to gen

The winner : Noob

IMG_20121107_163233.jpg


THE DIAL : The diffrences are very small but there are a few.
The Panerai logo print on the Noob is thicker and has some volume to it which is not necessary good thing as he thickens of the print varies, but only noticeable under a magnifier . The H has a smooth, thinner more precise flat print which looks better and more high end.
The numerals is where it gets bad. H numerals are thinner and perfect printed with a nice volume to them. Noob's numerals are thicker, rugged looking and have a white printed base on which the lume is painted. They look rough and the lume is not equally distributed or centered to the white base , noticeable when the lume glows. The noob numerals just look like they are not part of the watch compared to the nice H numerals.
The markers on noob are also smaller with smaller lume dots, noticeable when both glow side by side. The rings surrounding the dots are more visible on noob. H markers look better and more gen like with big lume dots and discrete rings..
The hands are pretty much the same but the noob hands are more concave where they sit on the cannon pin making them distort the reflections more, the H hands are flater with a nice flat reflection
The cannon pin is is flat on noob , little rounded on H.

The winner : The H dial, markers and print look better and closer to gen , it also has a more high end feel to it. If I had the skills to swap the dials without damaging the hands I'd swap the H dial into the noob case .

IMG_20121107_163721.jpg


IMG_20121107_164133.jpg


IMG_20121107_165205.jpg


IMG_20121107_165251.jpg


IMG_20121106_233346.jpg


THE LUME : Both of them have good C3 lume on the markers, they keep up well with my other superlumed watches . H markers have bigger lume dots visible when both of them are side by side.
The numerals is where it gets bad, while H has perfect printed and lumed numerals with same color as the markers, the noob has some sub par lume not evenly distributed with jagged edges.
The numerals on H do decrease in brightness faster than the markers as they don't have the same amount of lume, but the ones on the noob go out in minutes and not evenly.

The winner : Clear winner H

To compare the brightness I've used a superlumed 111 and a bag of brightest available lume powder.

From left to right : H , Noob, 111 , bag of lume

IMG_20121107_165803.jpg


minutes later the numerals on noob have very little glow left
IMG_20121107_170217.jpg


Here you can see how nice and even the lume is on H

IMG_20121107_170014.jpg


and the jagged edges on Noob

IMG_20121107_170030.jpg


Conclusion: Both of them are nice watches with pros and cons. On the wrist they feel about the same with minimal differences between them. But if you have OCD, noob is the way to go, although not perfect it is a more finished watch. Would've been nice if it had the H factory dial though.
 

machiavegli

Active Member
7/11/11
485
12
18
@smokiedabong: Bravo, sir!!! A fantastic comparison & thanks very much.

-Mach
 

rhoffer

Horology Curious
24/10/12
15
0
0
Great job. Would you please give the dealer and price for each watch?:lolcina:
 

nielsen

I'm Pretty Popular
22/1/08
1,216
3
0
Having just yesterday received my Noob 243 from Puretime, I'm glad to read that it was the right one to choose. Having said that, I suspect I wouldn't have noticed the difference, based upon your excellent review. Thanks very much for that.
 

Focal

Known Member
11/9/12
125
0
0
Awesome! Amazing to see that two rep factories get so close to producing the same watch.
 

OceanView

You're Saying I Can Sell?
19/10/11
93
0
0
Thanks for the detailed analysis!
Gotta get me one of these when they come back in stock.
 

the_don_robinson

Active Member
20/4/12
325
6
18
Fab review! And i think your english is just grand! Thanks for taking the time!

Sent from my BlackBerry 9810 using Tapatalk
 

watchman12345

I'm Pretty Popular
8/10/06
1,630
7
38
Great work. In my opinion the H-factory AR and lume are as good as it gets. There have been rumours for a while now that noob don't use genuine superlume but it still looks ok.
 

ALE7575

Section Mod
Section Moderator
Certified
18/1/11
19,826
338
83
Hi smokie
Thanks for this fantastic review
We need such a things to analyze the watches and take decisions.

I will put directly in the PAM GUIDE

ALE
 

mysterio

Mythical Poster
Advisor
19/8/08
9,794
863
0
Awesome! Amazing to see that two rep factories get so close to producing the same watch.

Still boggles the mind though how they can't replicate the watch completely with such capability.

Great comparative thread, smokie. :)
 

smokiedabong

Put Some Respect On My Name
22/8/12
3,546
12
38
Hi smokie
Thanks for this fantastic review
We need such a things to analyze the watches and take decisions.

I will put directly in the PAM GUIDE

ALE

Glad to help.
Before I bought these two I've searched for info on them so I can make a decision but couldn't find a clear response why one is superior to the other. Even if the differences are minimal and you have to look closely I tried to point out all of them that I could see and maybe help others take a decision.
 

Rogerthat

Renowned Member
6/11/06
919
1
0
Excellent job, great to see then side by side and thank you for taking the time
One big thing for me but maybe it comes out more in pics than in person
On the noob and the gen the way the bezel meets the case seems like they are 1 piece
On the h it looks more like a seperate bezel, like 2 pieces

In person you don't see any difference in the case construction in regard to the bezel?

I also prefer the fine brushing on the noob think it looks more gen
In person I find Pam gen brushed cases to look very matte/dull
Lastly the pearl you mention noob closely matches the l dial and h the t dial, but this is an l dial rep which makes the h factory pearl quite inaccurate

Great to see the head to head lume exposures

My noob qc release works great so that likely is a manufacturing minor flaw on yours
In comparison your cg lever seems closer to the case when closed than on mine and I prefer your closer distance of course so hard to find 2 identical reps of you start inspecting real close

Your summary that the best of both worlds would be h dial and noob everything else definitely makes sense after seeing the pics!