Tudor Pelagos XF vs ZF, 9015 vs A2824

[Rolfo013]

Hi guys,

I’m new to the channel, and new in the watch rep scene.

For my 35th birthday I’m looking for the Tudor Pelagos 42mm black. The hole weekend I’m driving myself crazy on which one is the best. I reed a lot of different thing. The miyota 9015 is very noisy but very reliable. The other one choose the 2824 Asian.

My question to you guys; which one is the best and newest rep for the Tudor Pelagos 42mm black? And why.

Tips for sellers or selling. I want only the best quality.

Thanks!!

 

[Rx4Time]

Okay so I personally would recommend the 2824 over the miyota. As you mentioned you don't have to deal with the rotor noise, they tend to be more accurate for timekeeping and unless you get a lemon the Asian 2824 is just as reliable as a miyota. Should there be an issue with the movement it's a standard movement and it's something that any watchsmith can either service or you can swap it out for ETA 2824 / SW200. Beyond that I recommend you read up on the makers and the known flaws. They are highly accurate replicas in general. Below is a picture of my genuine next to a replica I used to have for your information

 

[Feefo]

Hi and welcome to RWI! Glad you found your way here.
@Rx4Time already gave valuable advice, there's threads on the topic in the Tudor section, an example:

MASSIVE Tudor Pelagos 25600 Photo Comparison of Rep vs Gen (Warning: Bukkake of photos included)

Alrighty, it's been a long while since I last wrote a review for the family here, and since then I've acquired a gen Tudor 25600. The Pelagos is my first serious Swiss watch that I got as a present for being accepted into a grad school in a PANDEMIC AND RECESSION. An impossible achievement...

forum.replica-watch.info

Please take some time to read the sticky threads in the new members area (all subsections), learn the basic forum rules and get some very good advice in the process. A number of questions has already been answered there, this is just an example:


https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/you-are-welcome.10935638/post-11179738
Another good thread to read to understand where RWI comes from and some fundamentals is this:
https://forum.replica-watch.info/threads/the-first-constitution-of-rwi.51989/


For anything else, feel free to reach out to @eBoy or me, we're happy to assist.


This forum is a treasure trove of information and benefits from the engagement of all members who take their time to share their knowledge, help each other out and have some fun. We hope that you'll benefit and enjoy this platform as well as contribute positively to it.


If at any point you feel to contribute also on another level, feel free to pm the boss (trailboss99) to become a supporter and get some little perks with the status (editing rights, for example).


Enjoy the forum.

 

[john442]

Go with the XF V5 with the A2824 , you won't regret it.

 

[Rolfo013]

Go with the XF V5 with the A2824 , you won't regret it.

Any tips where to buy?

 

[Feefo]

Any TD. Read this before (as all the other stickies in the new members area):

Trusted Dealers - read this before sending a cent!

This forum contains plenty of information on how to go about your (first) purchase with a Trusted Dealer. The purpose of this thread is to put expectations into perspective and wipe the slate clean of some misconceptions around the whole purchasing experience of counterfeit watches. Also, I...

forum.replica-watch.info

 

[john442]

Any TD. Read this before (as all the other stickies in the new members area):

Trusted Dealers - read this before sending a cent!

This forum contains plenty of information on how to go about your (first) purchase with a Trusted Dealer. The purpose of this thread is to put expectations into perspective and wipe the slate clean of some misconceptions around the whole purchasing experience of counterfeit watches. Also, I...

forum.replica-watch.info

This! ......stick with the TD's ( trusted dealers) on this site

 

[Rolfo013]

Any tips where to buy?

Is that the most recent version of the Pelagos replica? And the best?

 

[factory2nd]

hi, do the v4 xf is good or not???