• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Tudor Black Bay (v1) by ZF. First impressions (pictures)

slask111

Active Member
26/7/08
259
0
0
Just received this watch a few hours ago. Had to post a few pics and first impression thoughts.

Now i cant compare this to a gen, so all observations are general. I compare fit/finish against other reps like Pam111 and SOSF v2.

Bracelet:
The bracelet did rattle upon arrival. I soaked it in Rock n Roll lube and washed it off. Now if feels very good. No hard edges. Clasp snaps in as it should. SEL fit and endlinks are just great.

Case:
It collects fingerprints like an iphone screen. I find myself polishing the case with my shirt all the time. The inside corners on the lugs are razor sharp. Maybe its possible to sand thoose down.

Crystal:
AR is good. Better than my Noob 111, but not as good as the SOSF v2. Its raised but i don't think its as doomed as the gen. I think..

Color hands/indexmarkers:
We know they are not the same color. But you wont notice this on the wrist. This is a non issue.

Dial:
Just great. Pure class and good execution.

Bezel and pearl:
Biggest letdown of the watch. It turns pretty easy, but its a 60 click bezel. Maybe it should be like that, but im so used to 120 click bezels so it feel strange. It also feels "sheap" when you turn it, it has a bit of play and the pearl does not center 12 marker with a click. Its between clicks if you know what i mean. (Update: GEN has a 60 click bezel and its a little light on the gen also. So no problems here!) Pearl is centered and looks good. I know an updated pearl will be released, i don't see any reason to change this pearl. A non issue for me.

Conclusion:
I have waited for this watch for over a year. Been following the RG thread daily. I had high expectations. But when my boss bought the gen i told myself that this would be a C&R. But im not so sure anymore. Its a stunning watch with a lot of character. The grey dial and gold hand is just purse sex. Its a small watch, but wears pretty big. This is something ppl notice. The feel of the watch is very good, im starting to really love it. I highly recommend this watch. Go get it :)

Now on to the pics.

_SAM8179.jpg

_SAM8161.jpg

_SAM8194.jpg

_SAM8170.jpg

_SAM8189.jpg

_SAM8209.jpg

_SAM8211.jpg


Thnx :)
 

dfq23

Active Member
18/12/12
431
0
16
Good review mate, mine is on a plane from China as I type. Only thing is, its ZF factory, not Noob
 

s3g0y

Renowned Member
15/12/10
756
3
0
Congrats mate on your great watch! Wear it well, it's a stunner.

I'm still hesitating....
Maybe it's a non issue but I have a biggest problem with the crystal in this rep.
It's a instant tell when I look at the pictures. I mean, the way it's domed.
Just for visualising some pictures of a gen thing:

DSC_1061.JPG


Tudor-Black-Bay.jpg


Tudor%2BBlack%2BBay%2Bvs%2BMk%2BII%2BKingston%2Bcomparison%2B%25283%2529.jpg


1331637770507



I think that something is wrong with the inner side of the rep crystal...
 

trailboss99

Head Honcho - Cat Herder
Staff member
Administrator
Certified
30/3/08
43,483
16,907
113
Fixed the title for you mate.
 

Raddave

Most Delicious of all Nipples!
Staff member
Global Moderator
Administrator
Certified
24/12/11
67,017
18,592
113
Congrats there buddy, Looks fantastic !


Was wondering how you fared with the stain/burn on the caseback..

I was thinking a little bit of baking soda on a damp Qtip might help.
 

slask111

Active Member
26/7/08
259
0
0
Thanks for the review, nice Marc Jacobs

thnx, its GEN ;)


Congrats mate on your great watch! Wear it well, it's a stunner.

I'm still hesitating....
Maybe it's a non issue but I have a biggest problem with the crystal in this rep.
It's a instant tell when I look at the pictures. I mean, the way it's domed.
Just for visualising some pictures of a gen thing:

I think that something is wrong with the inner side of the rep crystal...

Yup, the rep dosent come close if you compare the crystals. I will compare the rep with a gen later this week, then i will find out how obvious this is. But its a great rep on its own.

Fixed the title for you mate.

Thnx :)

Congrats there buddy, Looks fantastic !


Was wondering how you fared with the stain/burn on the caseback..

I was thinking a little bit of baking soda on a damp Qtip might help.

The burn is there, but in real life its just a small, small dot. I dont notice it. Just shows how bad these qc pics are for us, we complain about stuff thats not visible in real life. I was for example also worried about wonky lume application on 6 and 12 marker. In real life= you cant see it.
 

set2374

I'm Pretty Popular
19/7/12
1,714
44
48
Great review slask. My TBB is out for delivery. Something to look forward to when I come home from work! I will see for myself later, but hopefully the AR is clear since the gen doesn't have AR. The gen clasp doesn't snap shut. It just closes smoothly and silently. The gen bezel is a 60 click bezel. The gen bracel is also a bit on the light weight side, which surprised me. Anyway, I will report back with my first impressions once I have the watch in hand.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk
 

slask111

Active Member
26/7/08
259
0
0
Great review slask. My TBB is out for delivery. Something to look forward to when I come home from work! I will see for myself later, but hopefully the AR is clear since the gen doesn't have AR. The gen clasp doesn't snap shut. It just closes smoothly and silently. The gen bezel is a 60 click bezel. The gen bracel is also a bit on the light weight side, which surprised me. Anyway, I will report back with my first impressions once I have the watch in hand.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk

Ah, nice to know about the bezel :) The AR is clear, you wont notice it.
 

intheshadows

Active Member
30/8/12
456
0
0
Congrats mate on your great watch! Wear it well, it's a stunner.

I'm still hesitating....
Maybe it's a non issue but I have a biggest problem with the crystal in this rep.
It's a instant tell when I look at the pictures. I mean, the way it's domed.
Just for visualising some pictures of a gen thing:



I think that something is wrong with the inner side of the rep crystal...


+1 on this. The rep crystal edges are not nearly as "smooth" and rounded as the gen. It looks like the rep crystal went through some sort of incremental shaving/polishing process to get that rounded edge, which leaves it with a "white-ish" appearance at angles and some visible rings in there that are more prominent than in the gen.

Well, I dont have my piece in my hand to tell you guys for sure, but the look of the gen crystal really makes this watch special for me. I'll have to see when my rep hits my doorstep, but like s3, this is an insta-tell on the wrist if the pics are proper indicators.
 

tommy_boy

Athletic Supporter
23/4/09
9,562
169
63
The Evergreen State
Damn nice looking watch there. Better looking every time I see good pics of it like these.

Hope everybody finds it to be worth the wait.
 

kilowattore

Sales Moderator / Section Moderator
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Section Moderator
Certified
11/5/13
14,000
6,537
113
Italy
Yes, very good looking, thanks for sharing :)
 

set2374

I'm Pretty Popular
19/7/12
1,714
44
48
I received my TBB last night. The watch is a beauty and is technically very accurate. The biggest let down for me though is the quality of the finishing. The edges of the lugs, case back and parts of the bracelet were razor sharp! I spent a couple of hours sanding it down and there.is still more work to be done. In contrast, my noob exp. II had a gen like finish out of the box. I haven't seen too many other complaints so.maybe it's just me. One I finish the watch iff it will be a super rep. I agree 100% with slask about the hand color and pearl. No issue at all there!

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk
 

co-axial

Legendary Member
Advisor
16/9/10
23,225
10
0
I received my TBB last night. The watch is a beauty and is technically very accurate. The biggest let down for me though is the quality of the finishing. The edges of the lugs, case back and parts of the bracelet were razor sharp! I spent a couple of hours sanding it down and there.is still more work to be done. In contrast, my noob exp. II had a gen like finish out of the box. I haven't seen too many other complaints so.maybe it's just me. One I finish the watch iff it will be a super rep. I agree 100% with slask about the hand color and pearl. No issue at all there!

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk

Happens with many ss bracelets and case. I sanded down all of them. Personal sort of upgrade ;) and Certainly not a big issue imo

?sent from somewhere?
 

sharrkey

Legendary Member
Advisor
14/6/08
13,129
44
48
Looks fantastic, I've one on the way to me and looking forward to seeing in the flesh