is this an eta or a clone 2836-1

[chrisb]

Can anybody help me with this one.. Is this an Eta or a clone..

[/URL][/IMG]

[/URL][/IMG]

[/URL][/IMG]

 

[Tucker]

I'm pretty sure it's a genuine ETA. [MENTION=42327]Raddave[/MENTION] @KBH

 

[chrisb]

I was thinking the same.. but not sure..

 

[Zeinharis]

It looks like an ETA movt mate.


[emoji1129] Sent from my iPhone 6s using Tapatalk [emoji1129]

 

[chrisb]

that would be nice..LOL

 

[Tucker]

that would be nice..LOL

Is it supposed to be a clone?

 

[Rx4Time]

Markings look crisp as you would expect in an ETA. See the below thread for some more info...
https://forum.replica-watch.info/vb...-to-tell-quot-Swiss-quot-from-quot-Asian-quot

 

[chrisb]

Well I thought it was a BP version when i bought it, but was not sure as was advertised as an asian. buyer confirmed it was a BP, but tought maybe it got a new movement or so. and the other Bp's I had belive they had a 2836-2 movement, so this one looked a bit strange to me as it is 2836-1

 

[chrisb]

Is it supposed to be a clone?

was from this sale: https://forum.replica-watch.info/vb...ga-Planet-Ocean-Ceramic-CRPO-45-5-A2836-in-EU

thought that is was a BP, and normally they have the reclaimed eta ( as I had a 42, but that one had the 2836-2 movement eta and looked a bit different then these markings..)

 

[Raddave]

Baseplate looks like an old gen ETA plate, but the keeper spring is clone , i really cant tell of the retainer.......id have to go with a cobble job...mix and match of parts


EDIT :After looking at chrisbs above post of the last listing , the retainer is clone too, but the base plate still looks gen to me

 

[chrisb]

that probably is, as with most BP version then..

as it is the same with the gold and silver gears I see.

Thanks all

 

[chrisb]

Baseplate looks like an old gen ETA plate, but the keeper spring is clone , i really cant tell of the retainer.......id have to go with a cobble job...mix and match of parts


EDIT :After looking at chrisbs above post of the last listing , the retainer is clone too, but the base plate still looks gen to me

[/URL][/IMG]

[/URL][/IMG]


I think i will be the typical reclaimed BP eta.

 

[seikosumo5]

its swiss eta?

 

[chrisb]

its swiss eta?

it is BP, and they are mostly reclaimed swiss eta's. ( meaning they use older Eta movements, and use some clone parts to get them working again) but most parts are ETa parts.

 

[seikosumo5]

ok thanks