• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

QC forum

Windowshopping

Do not accept unsolicited offers
8/3/23
7
2
3
USA
Wondering if there is a place on this forum where members discuss QC pics. Would love a second opinion when the pictures come in!

(Getting a Daytona 116520 Clean V2)
 

eBoy

⚜️ RWI NMA Chief Bracelet Link Remover ⛓️‍💥🔗🪛🔧
Section Moderator
Certified
2/4/21
14,064
23,246
113
A place of darkness and light a.k.a. EU
Wondering if there is a place on this forum where members discuss QC pics. Would love a second opinion when the pictures come in!

(Getting a Daytona 116520 Clean V2)
Posting a full set of QC photos and asking "help me with QC" will most likely end with all photos deleted by a moderator, plus possible account sanctions for repeated offenses, as it is against RWI's forum rules.

What you can do though, is ask a specific question and post 1 or 2 appropriate photos to support your question, such as "Do you guys think my 6 hr marker is crooked" or "Does the printing on my bezel look too bright". That's allowed.
 

P..DR..D

Legendary Member
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
12/1/21
23,831
25,190
113
Éire
Short answer is No, they are for you.

As to why:







Remembering at all times, details on a watch, magnified X-times on a computer screen, are normally next to impossible to see without a loupe in real life on your wrist. Plus at a fraction of the price, 1:1 replication can not, and should not, be expected.
 
Last edited:

g00n

Cunning linguist & Master debater
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
1/9/16
11,459
21,566
113
3 great responses perfectly explaining QC etiquette…..
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Feefo and P..DR..D

thea

Getting To Know The Place
18/8/22
16
7
3
I do not know of any forums but there is r/RepTimeQc on reddit and there are discords such as RepTimeBST that do qc
 

g00n

Cunning linguist & Master debater
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
1/9/16
11,459
21,566
113
I do not know of any forums but there is r/RepTimeQc on reddit and there are discords such as RepTimeBST that do qc
Sarcastic Season 9 GIF by The Office
 

g00n

Cunning linguist & Master debater
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
1/9/16
11,459
21,566
113
Sorry, heasked the question 🤷‍♂, trust me you will survive the TDs dealing with some inconvenience
He asked if there was a place on this forum regarding QCs, the responses he received were more than adequate. You recommended Reddit which many users will tell you is not the best source for information (putting it as nicely as much as possible).
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rolex4me

thea

Getting To Know The Place
18/8/22
16
7
3
He asked if there was a place on this forum regarding QCs, the responses he received were more than adequate. You recommended Reddit which many users will tell you is not the best source for information (putting it as nicely as much as possible).
If someone asks if there is a deli that sells sandwiches, assuming there is not, would you not point him towards a supermarket that does even though it is not a deli? Just because it does not exactly answer his question does not mean that relevant information couldn't be helpful to the post author.
 

g00n

Cunning linguist & Master debater
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
1/9/16
11,459
21,566
113
If someone asks if there is a deli that sells sandwiches, assuming there is not, would you not point him towards a supermarket that does even though it is not a deli? Just because it does not exactly answer his question does not mean that relevant information couldn't be helpful to the post author.
Respectfully, the point is you are trying to send him to a supermarket that only sells dog food…..OP can go wherever he wants but what usually happens is after a visit to Reddit they are usually straight back here asking silly questions…..
 

P..DR..D

Legendary Member
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
12/1/21
23,831
25,190
113
Éire
Deli v dog food, love it :ROFLMAO:

I actually have this watch on order at the moment, but I believe there is a V3, hopefully with improved dial, guess we shall see. Are you ordering black dial or white dial?

My advice, if you really want it, is to look through the main RWI thread on this watch. See if you can see half of the stuff the guys there focus on, I know I don't. But, full disclosure, trust me when I say, you don't know what you don't know, and sometimes you can't unsee things when pointed out.

So if you want your watch dissected, by all means use some QC tool and the Reddit 'experts', but if you want to enjoy it, read the above re expectations and use your own eyes.
 

Rx4Time

Supporter, Panerai lover
Patron
Certified
31/3/16
11,878
10,371
113
CONUS
Deli v dog food, love it :ROFLMAO:

I actually have this watch on order at the moment, but I believe there is a V3, hopefully with improved dial, guess we shall see. Are you ordering black dial or white dial?

My advice, if you really want it, is to look through the main RWI thread on this watch. See if you can see half of the stuff the guys there focus on, I know I don't. But, full disclosure, trust me when I say, you don't know what you don't know, and sometimes you can't unsee things when pointed out.

So if you want your watch dissected, by all means use some QC tool and the Reddit 'experts', but if you want to enjoy it, read the above re expectations and use your own eyes.
... So basically you're getting a better version than OP? You do realize you're going to make him reject it now regardless of how good it is.... :unsure:
 

RepPossessed

100 watches in the uk 🤌🏼
Trusted Dealer
10/11/15
7,062
2,172
113
N. Ireland
If you can’t spot a problem then you either need your eyes tested or there is no problem worth worrying about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rx4Time

Windowshopping

Do not accept unsolicited offers
8/3/23
7
2
3
USA
Sorry to have kicked the hornets nest lol.

But seeing as I have some attention. For a Super Asia Clone 4130 Movement (Clean Daytona V2) is a 320 amp Timegrapher reading something to be concerned about? I've heard the range ends @ 320 on the high side and that the movement can damage itself if the amplitude is too high.

The watch LOOKS great ladies and gentleman.
 

Rx4Time

Supporter, Panerai lover
Patron
Certified
31/3/16
11,878
10,371
113
CONUS
Sorry to have kicked the hornets nest lol.

But seeing as I have some attention. For a Super Asia Clone 4130 Movement (Clean Daytona V2) is a 320 amp Timegrapher reading something to be concerned about? I've heard the range ends @ 320 on the high side and that the movement can damage itself if the amplitude is too high.

The watch LOOKS great ladies and gentleman.
The amplitude is acceptable. There's always a bit of anxiety making an expensive purchase like that for the first time. Once you get it in hand I'm pretty sure you'll be enthralled with it. Enjoy!
 

Windowshopping

Do not accept unsolicited offers
8/3/23
7
2
3
USA
I actually have this watch on order at the moment, but I believe there is a V3, hopefully with improved dial, guess we shall see. Are you ordering black dial or white dial?

After some poking around, I've learned that Clean has only started making its V3 version for the Ceramic/Stainless steel panda and black dial. I ordered the Stainless/Stainless 116520 white dial V2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: g00n

g00n

Cunning linguist & Master debater
Staff member
Moderator Sales
Certified
1/9/16
11,459
21,566
113
After some poking around, I've learned that Clean has only started making its V3 version for the Ceramic/Stainless steel panda and black dial. I ordered the Stainless/Stainless 116520 white dial V2.
I had the 116520 white v1 not long ago. It was awesome so I can only imagine what v2 is like. Personally I can’t tell the difference between different versions let alone next to Gen 😂
For reference…..

Alas me and Daytonas don’t get on with one another, just ask @P..DR..D about it 🤪
Edit: Had a total of 5 different references up to now, won’t give up 😂
 
Last edited: