People like EVALUATIONS but don’t like participating in them. CLAIM

[ALE7575]

How many times have you need a sound and wise Evaluation when you have been looking for a replica??
Sure many times.
But the good Evaluations must be made with study, analysis, comparisons and mainly with the opinions from users.
An Evaluation don’t appear by itself, it needs to be promoted and started, a compilation of info and an analysis of this info available in order to get a final result.

We can see that a lot of people read the EVALUATION threads but few members take an active part in them.

I’m starting the EVALUATION threads to have a valuable evaluation of all replicas included in the PAM GUIDE. And mainly the new reps pending evaluation.
Without these evaluations the info in the PAM GUIDE has much less worth.

The PAM GUIDE was a hard work, but it is only a skeleton to be filled out with all needed info. Without this additional work and updates the PAM GUIDE will be useless.

It is very interesting for all people, beginners and veterans, to have this info when we are purchasing a replica.

I’m very encouraged to start a lot of EVALUATION threads, preparing before all the available info in order to help people to decide the evaluation. But we will need the kind participation in these threads from the biggest possible quantity of members.

If I have no replies to these EVALUATION threads, they will be useless and I will have to stop their publication.
We have set up a PCTeam to have many expert opinions but we will need much more info from all people in RWI to have appropriate evaluations.

PLEASE BE GENEROUS AND KIND TRYING TO STUDY MY PREVIOUS INFO AND PARTICIPATING IN THE EVALUATION THREADS.

That will take a few minutes of your time but the info will be many times helpful for many people, included yourself, in the future.

Thanks for your understanding and participation

ALE

 

[Fiddo]

Some probably don't participate because they are afraid of posting something that may not be correct...with the added fear that others may also criticize what they post.

I usually post what I think and or believe. It may or may not be correct. However, it's my opinion. Although. I haven't posted much recently. I will make the effort to do so.

I encourage others, especially those new to the forum, to actively partcipate in ALE's Evaluation posts and the forum in general. The more the merrier!!

:cheers:

 

[ALE7575]

Thanks Fiddo for your kind comments
I agree with your opinion about people are afraid about that
But I publish the Evaluation threads with a lot of info and links to be studied by eveyone with or without previous knowledge.
An people with this info can have an opinion and vote without post.
There are usually two options, no problems to get critized or to get ridiculous.

I encourage all people to give their opinions, after study the info please

ALE

 

[bigbangtheory]

I love your evaluation of the Hublot v6..... And I agree with the fear of sounding too "noob" LOL

 

[thran]

i am not well informed about difference of watches, but ill try to take as many pictures needed of what i have and try to give the best feedback i can to the best of my knowledge

 

[ALE7575]

As a reminder of this thread

I have placed two evaluation threads for PAM 104 N from h maker and Noob factory
I ahave 0 (zero) replies and merely four evluations and more than 65 visit in each thread.

IN THIS WAY WE CANNOT GET A CORRECT EVALUATION OF THIS REPLICAS TO INCLUDE IN THE PAM GUIDE

This is not for me. I know almost perfectly these watches. But we need more opinions and comments to have more info, a statistical result, valuable comments for all people here, mainly the noobs.

Please bear in mind that sometime ago you were a noob too.

Share your knowledge !!

ALE

 

[nielsen]

Ale: I've been here on the forum for a number of years now, and have contributed many comments. The problem is that I don't consider myself an expert on watches. Period. I'm just a guy who has fallen in love with Panerai watches and like mechanical stuff. Your 'guide' is fabulous and I used it, for example, when I bought my new 243. I can't really offer anything valuable for your evaluation. I do not have a genuine version with which to compare my rep 243. I don't know the science behind luming, or the intricacies of the 7750, etc. etc.. Thus I don't offer a review of my new 243 because you experts are my advisors to whom I turn to for advice. I can't offer you anything you don't already know. I suspect there are many of us like that. Thus our silence is not a sign of lack of interest or appreciation. On the contrary! Again: thanks for the fabulous 'Guide'.

 

[xpletiv]

MHO=maybe not so much as a true evaluation,but more thoughts as to how you think it is good/bad. For instance,when was the last time someone bought a Tag Caliber1 or a Sinn 1900(?)-some of these threads havent had a mention in months to a year-someone's had to have bought one since. I'm looking at the not so popular makes and sometimes have a hard time finding info that's not too old-is the quality still the same,has something changed,etc. Just a word or two or just a pic,something as to see the status. It doesn't have to be a all-out review.