I thought to ignore this thread because I think it is useless. But I'm going to reply before you get wrong or take a bad decision
It is very difficult to say about the quality of a replica even with all data in hand. You would need to be a little expert to get wise opinion.
Besides this is a watch with GMT and Power Reserve functions, and we know nothing about the functions of these replicas.
But you are asking about opinion with two bad pics of two unknown replicas and without knowing features, materials, crystal, caseback, movement, functions ....
I cannot see the GMT hand in left watch and Icannot see date window in right one (GMT hand seems to be at the back of hours hand ??)
Whatever answers you get from available info will be worthless
I just can say one thing, sure both replicas are bad ones, because there are no known good replicas of this watch.
ALE